National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Μελέτη της τεχνικής εξωτερικής οστεοσύνθεσης Ilizarov και των εξαρτημάτων της, με στόχο την αναζήτηση - τεκμηρίωση των βέλτιστων συγκροτημάτων για διάφορα κλινικά σενάρια
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe Ilizarov external fixator is a wire circular frame device proposed by Gavriil Ilizarov in Kurgan, Siberia in 1952. The method is based on the main biomechanical principle of axial compressive loads and micromovements stimulating biological bone bridging of the fracture gap. The purpose of the present PhD Thesis was the study of the mechanical performance of the Ilizarov external fixator and the optimization of the configuration for various clinical scenarios. Mechanical tests and finite element analysis were used for the study of the mechanical performance of either simplified or complex frames. The validated and calibrated final model was used for the parametric study of the Ilizarov device. In the first chapter, a general analysis about external fixation is given. The historical background and the classification of the external fixation are presented. Also, the advantages and disadvantages of the Ilizarov external fixation are analysed. Finally, the basic principles of bone regeneration and facture healing are presented. In the second chapter, a critical review of the published studies concerning the biomechanical behaviour of the Ilizarov external fixator is attempted. The Ilizarov external fixator is being studied using mechanical tests, mathematical models and theoretical approaches. The methodology and the results of these studies are presented. Due to the complexity of the Ilizarov frame, it is useful to study the influence of each parameter independently. The study of the mechanical behaviour of a simplified Ilizarov frame is presented in the third chapter. After a series of preliminary mechanical tests it was concluded that the main limitation of the Ilizarov device is pretension loss due to wire slippage through the cannulated bolts. The result of this phenomenon is the reduction of the device rigidity. The method adopted for the elimination of this phenomenon was the combined use of special metal nuts and metal stoppers of the wire (olive-form stoppers) in order to prevent wire slippage. Using this procedure, a standard Ilizarov frame was assembled consisting of two rings and four K-wires. The wires in each ring were placed normally to each other. At the one side of the wire, the above described stopper was used to prevent slippage while at the opposite side the threaded nut was attached after pretension was applied. A numerical analysis followed based on the Finite Element Method in an effort to study parametrically the factors influencing the behaviour and effectiveness of the Ilizarov technique. The numerical model constructed simulated accurately all the geometrical details of the experimental model, the load application mode (axial and torsional) and the mechanical characteristics of the materials used to assemble the frame (stainless steel and acetal). The wire-bone interface conditions were simulated as simple contact with friction. This way the wires were free to slide within the bone, along the wire axis. From the numerical analysis it was concluded that the regions most suspectible to failure are located around the points where the wires are coming in contact with the bone. Both the wire and the bone are under extremely intense stress fields at these regions. An attempt to quantify the pretension loss due to wire slippage is presented in the fourth chapter. First, mechanical tests were performed using a simplified frame in order to measure wire slippage under quasi static loading conditions. As a next step a second series of tests were performed in order to further investigate the pretension loss due to wire slippage under cyclic loading. It is concluded that a critical threshold of the axial strain exists at which sliding occurs. This phenomenon is terminated only when the current load cycle is finished. A numerical analysis followed based on the Finite Element Method in order to create a 3D model of the Ilizarov frame with a sliding mechanism at the ring-wire interface. The numerical model designed accurately simulated all the geometrical details of the experimental set-up, the load application mode and the mechanical characteristics of the materials used to assemble the frame. The experimental data obtained were used for the calibration and validation of the numerical model. Comparing the predictions of the model with the respective experimental data yields an excellent agreement. In the fifth chapter, the mechanical behaviour of a complete Ilizarov frame is studied. The frame consisted of four rings and two wires placed in each ring. As a first step, mechanical tests were performed under axial and torsional cyclic loading. An interesting observation was that alternate tensioning of the wires results in unequal wire tensions, with the tension of the first tensioned wire increasing as the second wire is tensioned. The experimental results were used for the calibration and validation of a Finite Element model. The wire slippage mechanism as well as the alternative tensioning technique were taken into account for the design of this model. In the last chapter of this PhD Thesis, the previously validated model was used for the parametric analysis of various parameters factors affecting the mechanical behaviour of the Ilizarov device. The characteristics that can be modified for each case are quite a few, and that’s why the selection of the optimum configuration is not easy. The parameters which were selected (based on the experience of clinicians) to be studied are the ring diameter, the wire diameter, the initial pretension, the bone location, the distance between the rings and the angle of the wires. Interesting results were drawn from this study concerning the influence of these parameters on the mechanical behaviour of the Ilizarov frame. The final conclusions can be used as guidelines for the optimization of the configuration for various clinical scenarios.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2011
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Mitousoudis, Athanasios
- Μητουσούδης, Αθανάσιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 11Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/30015