National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Η έννοια της διαλεκτικής στον Πλάτωνα και τον Αριστοτέλη
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe aim of this thesis is to compare the point of view of Plato (and platonic Socrates) and Aristotle about the concept of the dialectic. The historical-comparative method is used to comprehend the meaning and the value of the dialectic of the three philosophers. Also, a reference is made in pre-Socratic philosophers, mainly in Heraclitus and Parmenides and in Sophists, because signs of the dialectical way were also observed in them. We conclude that the dialectic is a dynamic evolving method, which is correlated with the ontical and ontological reality, the metaphysics, the theory of knowledge, the logic, the rhetoric and the politics. For Socrates the dialectic is a way of dialogue and inquiry, while the reality is a place full of oppositions and contradictions. The three principles of the Socratic dialectic are that nobody knows the truth of the ον, that the truth comes from inside '(the theory of anamnesis, the theory of ιδέα and the myth of the immortality of the soul give the objectivity of the knowledge), and that the beginning of the dialogue is 'what is the x', a very significant question. The aim of the conversation is the definition, after completing the elenchus of the personal opinions of the individual participating in the dialogue. This period of platonic dialectic is called oυσιολογία and it investigates the essentia of the ον. In Plato we discriminate two periods in his dialectic, the Ontology and the new Ontology, in the dialogue “Sophist”. In the first period, Plato inquires the meaning of the ον and in the second one he defines the ον in correlation with the έτερον (μη ον, but not as absolute μη ον). Now, the dialectic sets boundaries. The platonic Idea communicates partially with other ideas. The problem of the essentia of the Oν remains. The solution of the methexis (communication) between intelligible and perceptible world is problematic. A solution will be given in “Timaius” with the introduction of Χώρα. Plato uses the elenchus, the hypothesis -the method of the mathematicians-, the division and the gathering (synagogue) of the ον, to find the principles of the knowledge and the truth of the οντως όντος. The Αγαθό is the un-hypothetic and its approach is accomplished through intuition. The triple way to approach the platonic ideas and then return to the perceptible things and again to the ideas shows the necessity of the verification of the truth. The platonic dialectic is not inductive. It is aprioristic. But the knowledge of the things depends on their ontological situation (the icon of the line of knowledge and the classification of the things). The dialectic man is the philosopher who αληθείας ηφθαι, λόγον ουσίας εκάστου λαμβάνει, δουναι λόγον και αποδέξασθαι, εις μιαν ιδέαν τα πολλά πεφυκόθ οραν. For Plato dialectic, science (επιστήμη), philosophy and ontology are identified. For Aristotle the dialectic is a method of the first Philosophy and the sciences. Aristotle distinguishes the philosophy and the ontology. He asks “τί ην ειναι” the ον and gives to his philosophy a causal orientation (not teleological as Socrates). The aristotelic dialectic has three uses. Ιt exercises the mind, contributes to the transaction of the dialogues and finds the principles of the sciences (dialectical induction and intuitive comprehension of them). The aristotelic dialectic is determinated by the aristotelic problem, the syllogism, the endoxa and the topoi. The dialectic is the method by which we can converse every problem (αφ ης δυνησόμεθα διαλέγεσθαι περί παντός του προτιθέντος προβλήματος...) and although, at first sight, it seems inferior to philosophy, it opens the gates to the real knowledge. The same role has the phetoric for the aristotelic dialectic. The logos in both philosophers have the same dual purpose. It directs and controls people desires and it catches the truth of the ον. Plato and Aristotle believed in the ability of the man to improve himself as citizen and as individual. The dialectic is an applicable activity in human societies.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2012
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Μεσσάρη, Αναστασία
Subjects
dc:subject × 43- Φιλοσοφία
- Διαλεκτική
- Ρητορική
- Σοφιστική
- Γνώση
- Δόξα
- Έρως
- Οντολογία
- Μεταφυσική
- Μαθηματικά
- Λόγος
- Διάλογος
- Γλώσσα
- Ψυχή
- Ιδέα και ορισμός
- Γένη
- Είδη
- Συλλογισμός
- Επαγωγή
- Παραγωγή
- Ενόραση
- Θεωρία ανάμνησης
- Phylosophy
- Dialectic
- Rhetoric
- Knowledge
- Doxa
- Eros
- Ontology
- Metaphysics
- Mathematics
- Logos
- Dialogue
- Language
- Idea and definition
- Syllogism
- Epagoge
- Intuition
- Theory of anamnesis
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Φιλοσοφία, Ηθική και Θρησκεία
- Humanities and the Arts
- Philosophy, Ethics and Religion
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/30017