Agricultural University of Athens
Αξιολόγηση και έλεγχος διατεμαχικού ανταγωνισμού σε πειράματα σκληρού σίτου
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe aim of this study was to investigate the effect of interplot competition in durum wheat (Triticum turgidum var durum) evaluation experiments, to understand the causes of the emergence of such competition and to explore ways to settle and control it under Greek conditions. In this context, we studied the extent of interplot competition with regard to the number of harvested rows and the height difference among the genotypes in the competing plots, as well as the impact of such competition on the accuracy of the experimental evaluation. For a more detailed assessment of the height impact, the current study included both typical experiments which involved evaluating all genotypes regardless of their height and respective experiments where there was grouping of genotypes based on their height. The role the orientation of lines in the experiment plots play in the event of competition was also studied, since it was possible to vary according to the geographical location the experimental evaluation was conducted. Also, through specific experiments of diallel competition the competitive ability of a group of genotypes was evaluated, and at the same time the contribution of the genotypes under evaluation, the competing genotypes, the environment and their interaction to components of variance which are associated with competition were assessed. Finally, using data from both the typical experiments and those of diallel competition, the possibility of improving the experimental accuracy by correcting the measurements based on the height difference of neighboring units was studied. The results showed that interplot competition is an important factor used in the configuration of precision in benchmark durum wheat experiments in our country. Given the lower homogeneity of our experimental fields compared to other countries (e.g. North America and Northern Europe) and therefore, the inherently higher coefficients of variability, special care should be taken in checking and removing the adverse effects during comparative evaluation in the Greek farming conditions. This interplot competition during benchmarking different genotypes is due to their different competitive ability, which in turn depends greatly on the height of each genotype. The different competitive ability of each genotype affects significantly the performance of its neighboring border-lines and hence the performance of the entire experimental plot. The result is an overestimation or underestimation of the genotypes under evaluation. Consequently, the removal of adverse effects of competition on the accuracy of the benchmarking of genotypes can be achieved with the exception of border rows of experimental plots from the statistical analysis. Depending on the size of the differences in height, the removal of at least two border lines for blocks of seven, or five lines, appears to reduce the impact of competition sufficiently. The same could be said for three-line plots, where only the assessment of the central line would be free of the competition effects. In this case, however, the so small evaluated area itself can lead to erroneous conclusions while the harvesting of all three lines can possibly give better results.When the genotypes under evaluation have gained their identity, for example, in an advanced stage of development of new varieties, or in comparative experiments of pre-commercial and commercial varieties, their grouping based on height results in significant removal of the interplot competition effects. In cases when it is not possible to remove border lines without an accompanying increase in experimental error, or there is not enough information for grouping of genotypes (e.g. in early improvement stages), we can remove the effects of competition in the statistical analysis correcting the odds with an analysis of covariance using as covariate the difference in height between adjacent plots. Interplot competition can also be removed to a considerable extent by placing the lines of experiment plots with direction from north to south, which, in contrast with that from East to West, is not conducive to competition when there are differences in height between the experimental units. Finally, the estimation of variance components associated with interplot competition can provide important information for more rational designing of future trials evaluating durum wheat gene in the Greek agro-climatic conditions.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Agricultural University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2011
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Κατσιλέρος, Αναστάσιος
- Katsileros, Anastasios
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- Ομαδοποίηση γονοτύπων
- Διαλληλικό σχέδιο ανταγωνισμού
- Συστατικά διακύμανσης
- Προσανατολισμός γραμμών
- Διόρθωση απόδοσης
- Grouping genotypes
- Diallel competition designs
- Variance components
- Row orientation
- Yield adjustment
- Γεωπονικές Επιστήμες και Κτηνιατρική
- Γεωπονία, Δασολογία και Αλιεία
- Agricultural and Veterinary Sciences
- Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/30441