Back to search

Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)

Μια διερευντηική μελέτη των σχέσεων και των συγκρούσεων μεταξύ των τμημάτων μάρκεττινγκ & πωλήσεων σε ελληνικές επιχειρήσεις καταναλωτικών προϊόντων: προσδιοριστικοί παράγοντες και επιπτώσεις

Abstract

dc:description

Marketing and Sales departments are considered the most customer-centric departments of businesses (Shapiro, 2002). The two departments, through their functions, come into direct or indirect contact with the market and customers of a business. Cooperation and coordination between them is considered absolutely necessary for a company to achieve better performance, satisfying the needs and desires of its customers (Kotler et al., 2006). The organization of Marketing and Sales and the management of their functions, as well as the relationships between these two departments, are important factors in creating a comparative advantage that allow the company not only to differentiate itself from the competition, but also to improve its performance and its results (Guenzi and Troilo, 2007).The literature emphasizes that Marketing and Sales must be coordinated at every level, from the general strategic planning, to the smallest detail in the implementation of their functions (Shapiro, 2002). This thesis initially attempted to delineate these levels based on an extensive review of the literature (e.g. Dawes and Massey, 2006 / Dewsnap and Jobber, 2002 / Guenzi and Troilo, 2007 / Homburg et al., 2008 / Kotler et al. al., 2006 / Krohmer et al., 2002 / Rouzies et al., 2005 / Shapiro, 2002 / Vorhies et al., 1999), and then to examine the coordination of the two parts in terms of said levels. Specifically, a framework of cooperation between the Marketing and Sales departments was developed which consists of three levels, (a) the organizational dimensions of the Marketing and Sales departments, where (i) their relative strength, (ii) the form of strategy, and ( iii) the degree of market orientation, (b) the functional dimensions of the Marketing and Sales departments, where (i) their competence in nine key marketing functions (market research, segmentation, targeting, positioning, product design, advertising, pricing, distribution channels and customer relationship management), (ii) the importance that the two departments attach to these functions, and (iii) the degree of cooperation between the two departments in the execution of said functions, and (c) the relationships between the departments Marketing and Sales, where (i) the intensity of the conflicts between them are examined, and (ii) the degree of implementation of integration mechanisms in order to reduce the intensity of these conflicts. Each of the three levels above seems to be linked to the performance of the business.The feasibility of this thesis results from the above demarcation. Specifically, the purpose of the thesis is to examine (a) the sources of conflicts between Marketing and Sales in terms of a possible lack of coordination in their functional and organizational dimensions, (b) the effect of these conflicts on the performance of the business, and (c) ) the ways of dealing with said conflicts in terms of (i) the implementation of appropriate integration mechanisms, and (ii) the design and management of said operational and organizational dimensions. From these issues emerges the contribution of the thesis to both the academic and business fields, as the organization and relationships between the Marketing and Sales departments are considered by the literature as unexplored areas (e.g. Guenzi and Troilo, 2007 / Homburg and Jensen, 2007 / Meunier-FitzHugh and Piercy, 2007 / Panigyrakis and Veloutsou, 1999 / Rouzies et al., 2005). In addition, the thesis, attempting to contribute to the limited knowledge that exists around the area of Marketing and Sales coordination, examined the above issues based on the opinions of both the Marketing Managers and the Sales Managers of the sample companies, a method which is proposed by the literature as ideal (Dawes and Massey, 2005 / Homburg et al., 2008) and has not been implemented to date. This method will shed light on the real situation in the coordination of the two departments, as the opinions of the Marketing and Sales Managers of the same company will be compared, strengthening the contribution of the thesis.Based on the feasibility of the thesis, five research objectives were defined which delimit the study. Specifically, the first research objective concerns the examination of the views of the Marketing and Sales Managers regarding the concepts included in the cooperation framework of the two departments, which was previously developed. The purpose of this objective is to see if there are differences in perception between the Marketing and Sales Managers, which will be examined as sources of conflict. The second research objective concerns the exploration of (a) the effect of the intensity of conflicts between the Marketing and Sales departments on the company's performance, and (b) the role of the implementation of integration mechanisms. The third objective concerns the investigation of the role of the functional dimensions of the two departments on the one hand in the conflicts between Marketing and Sales, on the other hand in the performance of the business. The fourth research objective concerns the investigation of the role of the organizational dimensions of the two departments (a) in the considered functional dimensions, (b) in the conflicts between the Marketing and Sales departments, and (c) in the performance of the business. The fifth research objective concerns the testing of an integrated model with the aim of (a) interpreting the creation of conflicts between Marketing and Sales, (b) examining the effects of these conflicts on business performance, and (c) investigating the methods of dealing with these conflicts, in order to detect the critical success factors of a business. In all of these objectives, differences between Greek and multinational companies were examined, while the role of the external environment of the companies was also taken into account (in terms of instability, the intensity of competition and the intensity of technological developments).In order to examine the above five research objectives, appropriate empirical research was designed and implemented. The research studied 132 consumer goods companies, which were drawn from a population of 412 companies defined by the existence of autonomous Marketing and Sales departments. Data collection was done through personal interviews with the Marketing and Sales Managers of these companies, using a structured questionnaire (without each knowing the other's answers). The questionnaire used consists of psychometric scales, which were selected from the literature in order to measure the variables examined in the thesis.Regarding the first research objective, it was found that Marketing and Sales Managers have different opinions regarding (a) the importance of marketing functions, (b) the cooperation of their departments to perform these functions, and (c) the strategy of their business, while agreeing on (a) the responsibilities of the Marketing and Sales departments (with the Sales department appearing to take responsibility for performing core marketing functions such as pricing and distribution channel planning, and the Marketing department appearing to limits its responsibilities to performing "traditional" marketing functions such as market research, advertising, and product planning), (b) the strength of the Marketing and Sales departments (with the Sales department appearing stronger than the Marketing department within the business), (c) the degree of market orientation, and (d) the intensity of conflicts between their departments (which was generally found to be at moderate to high levels).Regarding the second research objective, the analyzes of the thesis showed that the high intensity of conflicts between the Marketing and Sales departments negatively affects the performance of the business. In fact, this relationship was confirmed both in Greek and multinational companies, while at the same time it was seen that the high volatility in the external environment of the company and the intensity of competition have a regulatory role in this relationship. In addition, it was found that the integration mechanisms concerning (i) the exchange of jobs between the members of the Marketing and Sales departments, (ii) the organization of joint training programs for the executives of the two departments, (iii) the exchange of information between the members of the of two departments for the market, and (iv) in the open discussion between the members of the two departments on any problematic issue, bring positive results both in reducing the intensity of conflicts between the Marketing and Sales departments and in increasing the performance of the business, while on the contrary, the mechanisms related to (i) the establishment of common development time for the executives of the Marketing and Sales departments, and (ii) the existence of a higher authority with responsibility for solving interdepartmental problems, appeared to be ineffective in reducing the intensity of conflicts between of the Marketing and Sales departments, without having any effect on the performance of the business.Regarding the third research objective, it was found that the disagreement between the Marketing and Sales Managers regarding the importance they attribute to the marketing functions, as well as regarding the degree of cooperation of their departments for the execution of these functions, are sources of conflicts between the of two departments, having by extension a negative effect on the company's performance. Also, it was seen that the high degree of importance of these functions and the high cooperation between the Marketing and Sales departments in the execution of these functions increase the performance of the business.Regarding the fourth research objective, it was found that (a) the power difference after of the Marketing and Sales departments in the company's internal environment, (b) the disagreement between the Directors of the two departments regarding their business strategy, and (c) the low degree of market orientation, are sources of intense conflicts between Marketing and Sales, by extension having negative effects on the performance of the business.Regarding the fifth research objective, it was found that the most successful companies (in terms of their performance) are characterized by (a) the low intensity of conflicts between the Marketing and Sales departments, (b) the implementation of the most effective integration mechanisms, as they have previously described, (c) the performance of high importance in the core marketing functions by both the Marketing and Sales departments, (d) the high degree of cooperation between the two departments in the execution of these functions, (e) equal responsibility between Marketing and Sales departments to execute strategic decisions related to market segmentation, targeting and positioning, (f) equivalent Marketing and Sales departments, (g) alignment of views between Marketing and Sales Managers regarding their business strategy, and (h) a high degree of market orientation.The conclusions obtained from the examination of the objectives of the thesis attempt to cover gaps in the literature in the area of relations between the Marketing and Sales departments, and to propose to companies practices that may contribute to the better organization and management of the Marketing and Sales departments. Sales, giving them a competitive advantage with a beneficial effect on their performance. It is worth noting that many of these conclusions have been presented at international and Greek academic conferences, as well as in international academic and Greek journals.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
Year dc:date
2010

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Lionakis, Konstantinos
  • Λιονάκης, Κωνσταντίνος

Subjects

dc:subject × 12

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/33023

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Lionakis, Konstantinos; Λιονάκης, Κωνσταντίνος. Μια διερευντηική μελέτη των σχέσεων και των συγκρούσεων μεταξύ των τμημάτων μάρκεττινγκ & πωλήσεων σε ελληνικές επιχειρήσεις καταναλωτικών προϊόντων: προσδιοριστικοί παράγοντες και επιπτώσεις. Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB), 2010. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/33023