Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Αιτιότητα και πιθανότητα: ο ρόλος της πιθανότητας για τη συναγωγή εννόμων συνεπειών στο ιδιωτικό δίκαιο

Abstract

dc:description

The aim of this thesis is to prove the important role of possibility as prerequisite of a) compensation for damages and b) other legal consequences. The reason for studying this problem is the tendency of English courts to adopt a relaxed causation between the damaging fact and the damage, which is based on possibility.The research has two parts: The first part refers to a general overview of the issue and especially to the transition from the mechanical causation to possibility. The second part refers to certain types of possibility, which approach coincidence. Therefore, the distinction made is: The realization of chance is contrary to its cancellation.First of all, the dipole causation - possibility is investigated in terms of a philosophical, historical and law comparative perspective. The Roman law has not formulated a general theory of causality, but it adopts a case by case manner of dealing with this issue. On the contrary, the Byzantine-Roman law distinguishes causality from fault, causality is accepted by reasonable condition and requires fault for any injury to limit the extent of liability. For the first time, the assumption of causality is used through the concept of damage.Next a consideration is made to the comparative law (Common law, German and French law) from which the following forms of causality were emerged: Actual causality, statistical probability, personal probability and implied causality. It is noted that all jurisdictions distinguish causation, in fact, from legal causation (causation in law). In the second part, the realization of possibility is considered as an object of the insurance contract. It is found that the role of causality as forming or excluding liability is limited, because of the dominant role of conventional possibility. Similarly, the role of causality as determining the extent of liability of the insurer is limited because of the insurance contract. The causality here connects the conventional probability with the damage or the insured amount. Causality has limited role in cases of hypothetical and concurrent causality.Next, it is considered the possibility of losing profit or avoiding loss as foundation of responsibility in the field of special medical liability and as factor which determines the extent of liability. Here, the probability is not general and abstract, as in statistical probability, but specific and concrete.The study of Greek case law shows that Greek courts compensate the loss of chance as forming the liability of the respondent and especially the loss of chance of treatment or survival of the patient, even if it is less than 50%. Instead, it is reluctant to quantify and calculate the specific probabilities of profit lost by the plaintiff, which are restored only case by case. This is achieved firstly by the art. 298 l.2 c.c. (expectation) arg. a majore ad minus and by the art 914 c.c., 197-198, 919c.c., 105-106 Intr.L.c.c. as legal reasons of liability. Moreover, the mechanism of fair compensation with regard to the equitable judge is used as expressed in art.932 par. 2 c.c. (expectation) for moral harm (present and future), art. 931 c.c.(expectation) and art. 288 (good faith) as hope of profit. The chances of profit (hope) are also compensated through the mechanism of abstract assessment of damages under the c.c.345 par. 1, and especially the uncertainty of the plaintiff as to the actual causality is taken into account in art.926 par. 2 c., which allegedly offers a new legal ground of liability based on the probable causality.Generally, it is observed that causality based on the concept of logical- necessary condition is the rule. It can not be overlooked the important role of probability as a prerequisite for compensation, even if it is only case by case. The latter is treated by Greek courts with a general and abstract manner, without specific quantification and calculation and more conceptual (e.g. fair compensation according to judge righteous judgment, mechanism of abstract calculation, by interpretation of art. 298 par.2 c.c.).Regarding the possibility as a prerequisite of other legal consequences (out of the law of compensation) the following variants of possibility are distinguished by the study of the respective provisions of the Civil Code: The statutory presumptions, the fierce probability, expectation, hope, doubt, approximate assessment, forensic probability and uncertainty.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2012

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Βίτσα, Πολυξένη

Subjects

dc:subject × 25

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/33195

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Βίτσα, Πολυξένη. Αιτιότητα και πιθανότητα: ο ρόλος της πιθανότητας για τη συναγωγή εννόμων συνεπειών στο ιδιωτικό δίκαιο. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2012. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/33195