Back to search

University of Patras

Ανάλυση της απόκρισης σύνθετων πολυμερών υλικών υπό συνθήκες φωτιάς: εφαρμογή σε αεροπορικές κατασκευές

Abstract

dc:description

The current dissertation, titled “Fire Response of Composite aerostructures” deals with acrucial subject of the aeronautics industry that is the fire response of composite aerostructures,more specifically the issue of interest in this work is the fuselage fire burnthrough from anexternal liquid jet-fuel pool fire. Other fire issues that “bother” the aeronautics industry arethe fire spread inside the cabin, smoke generation and toxicity of the fumes, but these are nothandled in the current dissertation.Aircraft structures are designed to withstand various loading scenarios during theiroperational life. These loading scenarios are associated to a great extent with normal aircraftoperation (flight manoeuvres, take-off and landing). However there are situations where theaircraft structures are required to assure the safety of the passengers and crew. In the case ofan emergency crash landing, the threat of an external jet-fuel fire always exists. Consideringthat the aircraft structure survives the impact, the survivability of the passengers and crewonboard the aircraft depends solely on the fire resistance of the aircraft structure. A measureof the fire resistance of an aircraft structure is the time needed for the flames to penetrate thefuselage and spread inside the cabin, the so-called, burn-through time.So far, the aircraft fire resistance has been extensively studied by conducting lab, mediumand full scale tests. The early lab scale tests were performed by the Federal AviationAdministration (FAA) and involved the Bunsen-burner flammability test of coupons fordeveloping fire safe interior materials. As the application of polymer materials on aircraftskept increasing, the problem of fire burn-through due to external fire emerged. Marker wasone of the first to perform full-scale fuselage burn-through tests to access the insulatingperformance of materials. Also a statistical analysis was performed by Cherry and Warrenthat accessed and analyzed data from past accidents and their work resulted in proving theimportance of fuselage fire hardening and the passengers’ lives that could be saved using lowcostsolutions. These works led the FAA to proposed new fire testing procedures for aircraftmaterials.The scope of this dissertation was to assess the performance of various structural materialsin a pool-fire scenario. A simplified approach is made, approximating the pool-fire conditionswith a flat panel burn-through test in accordance to the ISO2685:1998(E) Standard.The originality of the present work comes from the fact that it incorporates a multistageapproach in order to investigate the behaviour and response of composite aircraft structures inthe possibility of a fire event. The current approach goes down on material level in order toinvestigate and model the deterioration (decomposition) of the polymer composite. Thus, itinvestigates and proposes a methodology of how the thermophysical properties of thecomposite are deteriorated due to the fire event. It proceeds into developing a progressivedamagematerial model (material properties varying with the deterioration degree) and finallyimplementing this custom material model into a commercial FE package and solving theloading scenarios.Being more specific the current work begins with a quick review of the literature whereincidents and work done on the burnthrough event for the past 20-30 years are summarized. Itprogresses then to presenting the various types of polymers used in the aircraft industry andtheir basic decomposition mechanisms, from the unsaturated polyesters to the epoxies andphenolics and in the end reference to the thermoplastics is made. Every organic material,hence, polymers used in aerospace applications, present a set of response characteristics when subjected to fire, specifically the heat release rate, thermal stability index, limiting oxygenindex, flammability index, time-to-ignition, surface flame spread, mass loss, smoke densityand smoke toxicity.Following is the backbone of this dissertation, the kinetics modelling. Two approaches aremade, one simplified using single stage kinetics where the decomposition degree a iscalculated based on the Arrhenius reaction theory and using the kinetic triplets (kineticparameters) extracted from thermogravimetry, TGA, data using the Friedman multi-curvemethod. The second approach is more complicated and considers multi-stage decompositionof the polymer composite. Specifically a 3-stage reaction network is considered for everymaterial, the LY-Ref, and the two modified batches, one with ammonium polyphosphateAP423 and the other both with AP423 and multi-wall carbon nanotubes MWCNT. Again thekinetic parameters, activation energy EA, frequency factor A, and reaction order n, areextracted for every step using the van Krevelen methodology. In the end using the reactionrates equations the reconstruction of the TGA curves is achieved with an error of less than 5%from the test data. Correlations that consider the material deterioration and affect thethermophysical properties of the materials are proposed. Those expressions are beingdeveloped for both of the two kinetic approaches, the single and multi stage.Another crucial part of this work is the measurement and calibration of the applied fireload. Again two fire load approaches are used, one according to the ISO2685 Standard wherea propane burner was manufactured and calibrated according to the Standard for mediumscale samples testing and a lab scale butane burner for small samples. The ISO2685 burnerwas also CFD simulated and the models calibrated against analytical expressions, ISOrequirements and real measurements. The CFD simulations were performed so the heat fluxor heat transfer coefficient to be extracted and used as input for the later thermal FEburnthrough models. The heat flux distribution of the lab-scale AML burner on the specimensurface was measured via a water cooled Schmit-Boelter SBG01 heat flux sensormanufactured by Hukseflux.Manufacturing and material details are presented concerning the samples used for everytest campaign. Metallic (AL2024-T3) samples, CFRP neat and modified, and hybrid GLAREones where manufactured. Also the experimental work performed is described. Conecalorimetry testing data are available, results from thermogravimetry tests, differentialscanning calorimetry, and finally the burnthrough tests with both the testing apparatuses, theISO2685 one and the AML lab-scale burner.The modelling work in this dissertation involved thermal models that were developed intoa commercial FE package. It was not part of this work to develop a thermal solver so acommercial one was selected and all the developed methodology was adapted to itsrequirements and specifications. The boundary conditions on the models are presented bothfor the ‘hot’ front surface and the rear ‘cooling’ one. For the ‘hot’ one the heat fluxdistribution is used and for the ‘cooling’ one an equivalent convection is applied that accountsfor both convective and radiative cooling. The decomposing material model is implementedinto to FE solver via user defined subroutines for the single stage kinetics and the multi-stageapproach. Finally the simulations were run and the results and models were compared againstthe available experimental results.Since so far the burnthrough response of aerostructures was limited to coupon, samplesand medium size flat panels. A more realistic approach was performed by developing amathematical model of a real size test. The certification tests conducted by the FAA are forfull size fuselage sectors under the fire load of a burning jet-fuel pan pool-fire. A burning jetfuelpool fire is a complex phenomenon on its own, combining it with a decomposingfuselage structure make the modeling approach even more difficult to simulate if notimpossible. Required data for the pool-sizes under investigation were not available, so data for large external hydrocarbon pool fires from literature were used. Also, because the maincharacteristic of a jet-fuel (kerosene) pool fire is that the flames are not clear, on the contrary,great amount of shoot is produced making combustion modeling and radiative heat transfer tothe fuselage even more of a challenge to model, it was decided to try and tackle this full-scaleapproach by a simplified the modeling approach. Instead of liquid fuel combustion, an equalhot air stream with mass flow, velocity and temperature properties extracted from literaturecorrelation data was performed.Conclusively, in terms of completeness the benefit analysis performed by Cherry andWarren is presented in brief. The objective of their analysis was to assess the potentialbenefits, in terms of reduction of fatalities and injuries, resulting from improvements infuselage burnthrough resistance to ground pool fires. Fire hardening of fuselages will providebenefits in terms of enhanced occupant survival and may be found to be cost beneficial if lowcostsolutions can be found. The maximum number of lives saved per year in worldwidetransport aircraft accidents, over the period covered by the data, if hardening measures wereapplied, was assessed to be 12.5 for the aircraft in its actual configuration (when the accidentsoccurred) and 10.5 for the aircraft configured to later airworthiness requirements.These figures are completely significant and give an extra confirmation that this work oninvestigating the fire response of composite aerostructures is on the right track. As the workof Cherry and Warren concluded, the fire hardening measures in order to be applicable needto be cost efficient. The concept under which this whole dissertation stepped on was toinvestigate the fire response of composite aerostructures and the possibility of hardening thestructure itself without the use of extra protective layers that add cost and weight to theoverall aircraft and its maintenance. In the end it was concluded that there is the possibility ofhardening the fuselage structure by design and by material. Incorporating composites into thestructure it is possible to prolong the burnthrough time at least for 4-5 minutes before autoignition occurs on the inner side of the fuselage. Auto ignition of the inner side fuselage cabinmaterials is mentioned since in NONE of the burnthrough tests of the CFRP composites andthe GLARE samples flame penetration was observed.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Patras
Year dc:date
2012

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Sikoutris, Dimitrios
  • Σικούτρης, Δημήτριος

Subjects

dc:subject × 22

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/33258

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Sikoutris, Dimitrios; Σικούτρης, Δημήτριος. Ανάλυση της απόκρισης σύνθετων πολυμερών υλικών υπό συνθήκες φωτιάς: εφαρμογή σε αεροπορικές κατασκευές. University of Patras, 2012. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/33258