Back to search

Harokopio University

Μελέτη των παραγόντων που επηρεάζουν το βαθμό προσκόλλησης των χρονίως πασχόντων ασθενών στις διατροφικές συστάσεις

Abstract

dc:description

Various chronic diseases could be effectively prevented or managed by appropriate lifestyle changes (diet and exercise). This is the case of Metabolic Syndrome (MetSyn), which increases the risk for the development of type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease. On the other hand, there are diseases, like Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA), in which even though diet does not constitute an integral part of their treatment, it could have a supportive role. In the majority of diseases, especially those of the first category, despite health professionals’ efforts, patients seem to not adequately follow treatment guidelines and this is recorded as low adherence, depicted in both clinical and dietary indexes. Research so far has yielded various factors associated with patients’ adherence to treatment guidelines, in general, or to lifestyle recommendations in specific. Little is known, however, on the most effective way of intervention (means or content of intervention) for a specific disease, nor it is know whether the type of disease or disease symptoms affect dietary adherence. Aim of the present thesis was to explore some of the factors related to adherence to lifestyle recommendations: in specific, to evaluate the effectiveness of a novel goal-setting approach, the effect of telephone intervention and the potential role of the type of disease. Under this aim, 4 clinical trials were conducted, some of them in MetSyn patients and some in RA patients. In the first study, 88 MetSyn patients participated. At baseline, all patients were prescribed a Mediterranean-type diet (hypocaloric, when needed), as well as general guidelines on how to increase their physical activity levels. Then, patients were assigned to one of the three treatment groups: (i) the “Increase - Decrease” group (n=29); (ii) the “Increase” group (n=30); and (iii) the “Minimum intervention” group (n=29). The “Minimum intervention” group received no further lifestyle-related counseling and contact until the end of the study, 6 months later. Patients of the other two groups participated in individual dietary counseling sessions provided by a skilled dietitian, based on goal setting theory. In the “Increase - Decrease” group, all dietary and physical activity recommended goals were discussed and targeted (i.e. increase of fruit intake, decrease of portion sizes, etc.). In the “Increase” group only goals proposing an increase were included. All patients underwent fullmedical and nutritional assessment at baseline and at the end of the study. The between-groupanalysis revealed that the BMI change after the 6-month period was significantly differentbetween the “Increase - Decrease” or the “Increase” group and the “Minimum Intervention”group (p=0.005 for both comparisons). Waist circumference values decreased in the “Increase- Decrease” and in the “Increase” group compared to the “Minimum Intervention” group (pfor comparisons to the “Minimum Intervention” group 0.001 and <0.001 respectively). Additionally, a statistically significant difference between groups was also found for diastolic blood pressure, with “Increase - Decrease” group achieving a decrease compared to “Minimum Intervention” group (p=0.018). A statistically significant time×intervention interaction was found for BMI (p=0.002), waist circumference (p=0.018) systolic blood pressure (p=0.039) and diastolic blood pressure (p=0.021). No time×intervention interaction was found for triglyceride levels (p=0.479), glucose concentrations (p=0.158) and HDL cholesterol (p=0.084). Forty eight percent, 32%, and 19% of the patients in the “Increase - Decrease”, “Increase” and “Minimum Intervention” groups, respectively, ceased to fulfill the criteria for the metabolic syndrome (p=0.031). Following intervention, no changes were detected between or within groups regarding eating habits. In the second study, 87 patients with MetSyn participated. As in Study 1, at baseline, they received a Mediterranean-type diet (hypocaloric, when needed), and general recommendations on increasing physical activity levels. Then, patients were assigned to one of the three treatment groups: (i) the “Face-to-face” group (n=29); (ii) the “Telephone” group (n=29); and (iii) the “Minimum intervention” group (n=29). Patients in the “Minimum intervention” group received no further lifestyle-related counseling and contact until the end of the study, 6 months later. Patients of the other two groups participated in individual dietary counseling sessions provided by a dietitian, based on goal setting theory. The only difference between them was in the means of contact between patient and dietitian, depicted in the name of the intervention groups. All patients underwent full medical and nutritional assessment at baseline and at the end of the study. At the end of the intervention, improvements in various MetS parameters were found in all groups, compared with baseline values. In specific, patients in the “Face-to-face” group significantly decreased five of the metabolic parameters, patients in the “Telephone” group significantly improved four of the parameters and those in the “Minimum intervention” group showed improvement in only two parameters. In total sample, 42% of the participants no longer showed symptoms of MetS; the reduction rates differed significantly between the groups (p= 0.024), with those in the face-to-face and telephone group exhibiting similar rates (52% and 54%, respectively, vs. 21% in the usualcare group). Additionally, telephone group had the greatest improvement in dietary adherencecompared to the other two groups. In the third study, 39 RA patients took part. At baseline, they received a Mediterranean-type diet (hypocaloric, when needed). Then, patients were assigned to one of the three treatment groups. The three treatment groups were: (i) the “Face-to-face” group(n=13); (ii) the “Telephone” group (n=13); and (iii) the “Minimum intervention” group (n=13); the names of the groups reflect the intervention provided. The methodology of the study was the same as the one of Study 2; it differed only in the frequency of patient – dietitian contact in the “Telephone” and “Face-to-face” groups. All patients were evaluated at baseline and at the end of the study, in both objective and subjective disease parameters, dietary and anthropometric parameters and socioeconomic characteristics (only at baseline). At the end of the study, no differences were found between groups regarding both objective and subjective parameters, except adherence to Mediterranean Diet, with “Telephone” group achieving the greater improvement. Additionally, this group decreased adiponectin levels (p=0.037). In the fourth study, patients receiving telephone and face-to-face counseling in Studies 1 and 3, were included. In specific, 90 patients assigned to two groups, depending on their disease: (i) the MetSyn group (n=58); (ii) the “RA” group (n=26). All patients were evaluated in various parameters but for the scope of this analysis, only dietary, socioeconomic and anthropometric data were used. For the evaluation of adherence to the Mediterranean Diet, the MedDietScore was calculated. Repeated measures analysis revealed that the type of disease (MetSyn vs RA) was significantly associated with changes in dietary adherence (p<0,001). No association was found for the kind of intervention delivered (telephone or face to face) (p=0.374), or the interaction of the type of disease and intervention (p = 0.667). The present thesis aimed at exploring new ways of increasing dietary and physicalactivity adherence of chronic disease patients. Promoting only the consumption of healthy foods induced improvement in various metabolic parameters as well as body weight in patients with MetSyn compared a minimum intervention, representing usual care. However, it was found that, such an approach was not as effective as conventional goal-setting approach (targeting not only the increase of healthy foods but also the decrease of unhealthy), regarding the degree of improvement of MetSyn parameters and the percentage of patients that resolved it. In relation to the effect of telephone intervention, it was found to increase patients’ dietary adherence compared to both the minimum intervention and face to face group, regardless of disease. On the contrary, of the results are inconsistent regarding biochemical indexes. In MetSyn patients, increase of dietary adherence was depicted in improvement of biochemical indexes, even though not to the extent found in face to face group. Such a finding was not observed in the case of RA patients, with the exception of adiponectin. Finally, the type of disease was found to affect dietary adherence, with RA patients achieving greater improvements compared to those with MetSyn. For explaining these findings wehypothesized that patients with MetSyn experience no symptoms and lifestyle changes constitute the cornerstone of its management, whereas, patients with RA experience serious symptoms, which are only partly, and sometimes not affected by diet. In conclusion, there are different effective approaches of improving patients dietary or lifestyle adherence and thus their health status. Health professionals, and especially clinical dietitians, may have a variety of tools and alternative ways of intervention. Further research is needed to explore factors that are important in their decision of the most appropriate way to intervene to each patient, for achieving the highest possible short- and long-term adherence.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Harokopio University
Year dc:date
2013

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Fappa, Evangelia
  • Φάππα, Ευαγγελία

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • BY_NC_ND
Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/33344

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Fappa, Evangelia; Φάππα, Ευαγγελία. Μελέτη των παραγόντων που επηρεάζουν το βαθμό προσκόλλησης των χρονίως πασχόντων ασθενών στις διατροφικές συστάσεις. Harokopio University, 2013. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/33344