Back to search

Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)

Βαρυτική ακτινοβολία από συστήματα αστέρων

Abstract

dc:description

IntroductionIn this thesis we study the dynamics of realistic young star clusters focusing on the eventsthat lead to the emition of gravitational radiation. This radiation could be detectable by earth-based detectors, such as LIGO and VIRGO, or by the planned space-based detector LISA.For this research we have developed a new N-body code, called Myriad, which is capableof simulating models of star clusters that contain tens of thousands of stars. The code itselfis one of the main products of this study, while the others are the astrophysical results wemanaged to have by using Myriad for astrophysical simulations.In the first chapter we present all the theoretical background that is related to star clusters,paying special attention to globular clusters, which are of our interest. In the second chapterwe describe in detail the sources and detectors of gravitational radiation, while in the thirdchapter we describe the theory and observations that indicate the existence of intermediate-mass black holes (IMBH) at the centers of many, if not all, globular clusters. In the fourthchapter we give a description of the basic numerical methods that are used in N-bodysimulations together with the main features of N-body codes. In the fifth chapter we presentin detail our new code, its first results and comparisons with other sophisticated N-bodycodes. Finally, in the sixth chapter we present the results of detailed simulations of realisticmodels of young star clusters that contain an IMBH.Star clustersThis chapter of the thesis is about the observational and theoretical aspects of star clusters.We focus mainly in globular clusters, which are among the densest stellar environments inthe universe, since the density of stars at their centers can be as high as 100 − 1000 starsper cubic pc. Because of this high stellar densities, it is difficult to identify individual starsclose to the center and thus to study the dynamical processes there.There are 158 globular clusters in the Galaxy, which is maybe hiding 10−20 more behinddense interstellar gas-clouds. A typical spiral galaxy has hundreds of globular clusters, whileelliptical galaxies have tens of thousands of them. The shape of a typical globular cluster isalmost spherical, but most of them have small ellipticities due to rotation. The characteristicdistances for a globular cluster are:• The core radius, r c , which is defined as the distance from the center of an observedcluster in which the surface luminosity drops to half of its central value.• The half light radius, r hl , which is defined as the radius of the sphere around the centerfrom which the cluster emits half of its total luminosity.• The half mass radius, r hm , which is defined as the radius of the sphere that containshalf of the mass of the cluster. This is sometimes assumed to be equal to the half lightradius.• The tidal radius, r t , which is defined as the distance from the center of the clusterin which the gravitational potential of the Galaxy becomes more important than thegravitational potential of the cluster. This distance is assumed to be the outer limit ofthe cluster.Almost all galactic globular clusters have r hl ≤ 10pc, while most of them have r c ∼ 1 − 2pc.The density profiles of globular clusters may be approximated by simple or more sophisticatedmodels. The most simple is the Plummer model [10], but the most realistic that is usuallyused is the King model [11]. In the latter a parameter W 0 defines the level of consentrationof the cluster. W 0 ranges from 1 to 12 so that clusters with low W 0 have a big core in whichthe density of stars is almost constant, while clusters with high W 0 have a small core andthe density increases all the way towards their centers.One of the characteristic time-scales for a globular cluster is the half-mass relaxationtime, which is the time-scale in which a typical star of the cluster looses any informationabout its previous velocity. This time scale is given by equation [3] and [1]( Nr 3 ) 1/2 1h,(8.18)t rlx = 0.138 ̄G mln Λ ̄ is the mean mass and ln Λ is the Coulomb logarithm [1] given bywhere mln Λ = ln γN,(8.19)where N is the number of stars and the factor γ is usually chosen to be 0.4 [3], but in somecases values of around 0.1 may be more appropriate [135]. A typical value of ln Λ used inN-body simulations is 10. In more useful units, t rxl can be written as( r )( M ) 1/2 ( 1M )th(ln Λ) −1 .(8.20)t rxl 1.9Myrm1pc MThe most massive clusters have t rxl of the order of Gyr. Another time-scale is the time neededfor a typical star of a cluster to cross the system. This is the crossing time t cr and it is givenby√ ( r 3 v ) 1/2t cr 2 2,(8.21) ̄GN mFinally, the another time-scale that is important for the dynamical processes in a globularcluster is the time for the cluster to reach core-collapse. During core collapse, the mass-density at the center of the cluster reaches its maximum value, while the core radius reachesits minimum. The time of core collapse for an ideal equal-mass system of stars distributedinitially according to a Plummer density profile, is found theoretically to be [1]t cc15t rlx .(8.22)This result has been confirmed by detailed simulations of star clusters. For a system containingstars with different masses distributed according to a King density profile [11], the corecollapse time becomes [19]t cc 0.2t rlx .(8.23)Finally, the most important differences between the color-magnitude diagram of a typicalglobular cluster and of the solar neighborhood are mentioned. Those are• The main sequence in the color-magnitude diagram of a globular cluster does notcontinue up to the blue giant region, but instead stops at a turning point, which indicatesthe age of the cluster.• The sub-giant branch is very thin, and this indicates that all stars of the cluster havethe same age. From this we can conclude that all the stars of the cluster formed in asingle burst of stellar formation.• After the turning point there are a few stars that appear to lie on the main sequence,which according to the theory, shouldn't be there. Those are the blue stragglers, andthe most probably scenario of their formation is collisions between stars in the cluster.If this scenario is correct, then collisions of stars in a globular cluster are often.Gravitational radiationIn this chapter we present in detail the most important sources of gravitational radiationand some of the recently discovered results of Numerical Relativity.One of the most promising sources of gravitational radiation are close binary systemsconsisting of black holes or/and neutron stars. The asymmetry of those systems, leads tothe continuous emition of gravitational radiation, which carries away energy and angularmomentum of the system. This makes the semimajor axis and the period of the systemshrink, while at the same time the eccentricity of the binary becomes lower. The evolutionof the semimajor axis and eccentricity of close binary systems of relativistic objects aredescribed by the equations of [26, 27], which have been calculated using the post-Newtonianformalism. Since the frequency of the emitted gravitational radiation is twice the orbitalfrequency of the binary, as the period of the binary decreases, the frequency of the emittedradiation increases and the binary enters the band of the already constructed earth-baseddetectors (LIGO or VIRGO), or the planned space-based detector LISA. Finally, the twomembers of the binary merge emitting a burst of gravitational waves with a characteristicpattern and creating a black hole.According to the recent results of Numerical Relativity [? 32? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ], the outcomeof such a merger would be a recoiling black hole, because just before merger, the systememits gravitational waves asymmetrically. The asymmetry in the emission is higher if thetwo black holes have spins and according to the magnitude and orientation of the spins, with respect to the orbital angular momentum and the ratio of masses of the two black holes, theresulting black hole might get a recoil velocity of the order of 4000kms −1 . This is very highand it can make the black hole escape from systems like globular clusters, where the escapevelocity is around 50kms −1 or galaxies, where the escape velocity is higher. We describe indetail the different semi-analytic equations for the recoil velocity found in the literature [? ?] and compare their results. Finally, a detailed discussion about the different types of earth-based detectors and their limitations is presented. The operating principles and the sourcesof noise for the resonant-mass detectors and (earth or space-based) laser interferometers arepresented, together with the details about their operating frequency bands.Intermediate-mass black holesIn this chapter we present the observational evidence of the existence of Intermediate-Mass Black Holes (IMBH) at the centers of star clusters, their possible formation mechanisms,their influence in the structure of their hosting star clusters, and the gravitational radiationthey could emit.Although there is direct proof of the existence of stellar-mass black holes (BHs) andsupermassive black holes (SMBHs), the existence of IMBHs is still under controversy,This is because the current telescopes cannot provide us with detailed observations of theenvironments where these black holes are supposed to exist. These environments are thedense centers of globular clusters, and we will need the next generation of extremely largetelescopes in order to identify the motions of individual stars and presumably observe indirectlythe existence of IMBHs. Direct observations of IMBHs might be possible when LISA willstart collecting data, since IMBH-BH and SMBH-IMBH binaries are expected to be strongsources of low frequency gravitational radiation. In some cases IMBH would emit higherfrequency gravitational radiation, which might be observable by the next generation of LIGOand VIRGO. IMBH-IMBH binaries if they existed or exist at the centers of clusters, mightbe one of the most frequent observables by LISA.There are three possible formation mechanisms for an IMBH. An IMBH might be formedafter the collapse and of a Population III (Pop III) star that contained hundreds or thousandsof solar masses. Pop III stars are supposed to grow very large, because of their very lowmetalicities, and thus their remnants might have masses of the order of 100 − 200M . Thestars of globular clusters belong to the Population II, but, since most of the globular clustersare very old, they might have some Pop III stars in the past. Another formation mechanismof an IMBH has been observed in simulations of star clusters [136, 19]. This is the runawaymergers of stars and it could happen in star clusters with short half-mass relaxation timeswhich also contain stars with different masses. Very early in the evolution of such clusters,the core becomes full of heavy stars, which tend to sink there faster than lower mass stars.This is due to equipartition of energy between the stars of the cluster, which makes thelighter stars gain larger kinetic energies, and subsequently move to the outer parts of thecluster, and the heavy stars gain less kinetic energies, which forces them to sink towardsthe center. In such systems, the core collapses early, and if this happens before the firstsupernova explosion in the cluster, which is expected around 3Myr after the birth of thecluster, collisions between the heavy stars at the center might happen. Simulations showedthat such collisions might lead to the formation of a very massive star, which is supposed tocollapse to a black hole, without much mass loss. This black hole would have mass around250 − 500M which is in the range of IMBHs. According to [74], if more than 10% ofthe stars of a cluster form binaries, then runaway mergers is possible to form more than onevery massive star in a single cluster. This might be very important, since it would lead tothe formation of an IMBH-IMBH binary, which might be a strong source of gravitationalradiation. We note here that this result comes from Monte Carlo simulations and needs to beconfirmed by detailed N-body simulations. Finally, if core collapse happens later than thefirst supernova in the cluster, an IMBH might be formed by collision between the stellar-mass BHs that sunk to the center.N-body simulationsIn this chapter we describe the basic features of most present N-body codes and wedescribe important algorithms that are used by them.The Hermite 4 th order algorithm (H4) is the one that is widely used as the core of N-body codes. The advantage of this numerical scheme is that it required one calculation ofthe accelerations and their derivatives every time step. Other numerical schemes of the sameorder, like Runge-Kutta 4 th order, require more than a single calculation of the accelerationsand this makes H4 superior to them, because this calculation is the most time consumingcalculation in an N-body simulation. The successive steps of the H4 algorithm are presentedand discussed in detail. Finally, a description of the time-symmetric Hermite 4 th orderalgorithm is presented. This algorithm, requires more calculations of the accelerations duringa single time step, but it is very accurate, since its numerical error does not grow monotonicallywith time, but remains bounded. This algorithm is usually used for simulations of N-bodysystems with small number of stars N. Binaries, close encounters of stars and small boundsub-systems can be integrated in time using this very accurate, but slow numerical scheme.Myriad: A new N-body code for astrophysical simulationsIn this chapter we present a detailed description of a new N-body code, called Myriad,that is capable of simulating models of star clusters that contain tens of thousands of stars.Myriad is written in C++ and it is using C++ classes to store and manipulate data. Itsmain features are:1. It contains one of the fastest and most accurate integrators for N-body simulations.This is the H4 scheme, which is presented in Chapter 4.2. All stars do not advance their positions and velocities simultaneously, but there areblocks of stars that share the same integration time step. This makes Myriad a block-time step code.3. The special purpose computer GRAPE-6 is used for calculating the acceleration andits first derivative for every star, when it is necessary.4. When a binary forms in a simulation, it is replaced in the N-body system by its centerof mass, while its internal motion is accurately followed using the time-symmetric H4scheme. External perturbations from nearby stars are also taken into account. A thirdstar might become a member of the binary, forming a 3-body system, if its perturbationon the binary is significant.5. Close binary systems of black holes are evolved in time using the post-Newtonianformalism. We have adjusted the post-Newtonian equations in the code, following theformalism of [111]. We expressed the post-Newtonian terms as corrections on theaccelerations of the two black holes, and we calculated the post-Newtonian correctionson the first derivatives of the accelerations.6. Collisions between stars are simulated as simple plastic collisions. The final productis a new star with the characteristics of the center of mass of the merged stars.7. We included the effect of recoil in collisions between black holes. The produced blackhole contains the sum of the masses of the two merged black holes, but a recoil velocityis assigned to it, because of the asymmetric emission of gravitational waves just beforethe merger. If black holes exist in a simulation, they carry information about their spinmangitude and direction, which are important for the recoils.The accuracy and speed of the code have been tested in detail providing satisfactoryresults. Myriad and another widely used N-body code, Starlab, were used for simulatingthe same system up to core collapse. The numerical errors of the two codes are similar, whilethe simulation done with Myriad required less computational time. The accuracy of Myriadin treating binary systems is excellent, since the integrator used does not allow the numericalerrors grow monotonically with time.We used Myriad for simulating a system of 1024 equal-mass stars, initially distributedaccording to a Plummer density profile, beyond core collapse. We calculated the time ofcore collapse of this system, which is t cc 17t rlx . This time is similar to what is expectedtheoretically [1], and to the results of other N-body or Monte Carlo simulations of similarsystems [19, 18].We also used Myriad for simulating more realistic systems that contain up to 16384stars with masses given by a Scalo [13] initial mass function. The clusters were evolved upto core collapse which happened at t cc (0.17 ± 0.05)t rlx . The result is close to the resultof [19] were the simulations were done using Starlab with identical initial conditions.Finally, we tested Myriad in simulations of close binary black holes and tested thecorrectness of the post-Newtonian formalism that we used. The result of Myriad in the timeof merger between the two black holes is in perfect agreement with the theoretical result of[26, 27], when only the 2.5PN term is used. If we include the other two PN term (1PN and2PN) the time of merger becomes shorter, as expected [112].From the above we can conclude that Myriad can be used for simulations of realistic starclusters with large mass ratios between the most and less massive stars. Also, Myriad canevolve binaries of black holes accurately in time providing information about the emittedgravitational radiation. If black holes merge in a simulation, the code can calculate theproperties of the resulting black hole and its recoil velocity according to the recent resultsof Numerical Relativity.All the results and descriptions of this chapter have been published in [20].Applications of Myriad: Simulations of star clusters containing an IMBHAs an application that pushed Myriad to its limits we simulated star clusters with realisticmass-functions that contain an IMBH at their centers. We assumed that the IMBH hasbeen formed, due to runaway mergers of stars, at 3Myr after the birth of the cluster, sobefore starting the simulations we evolved all the remaining stars up to this time, using astellar evolution code. The resulting cluster contained a number of stellar-mass black holesdistributed all over the system. For the initial density profile we used a King model withparameter W 0 = 7 and half-mass radius R h = 1pc, which is expected to fit the densityprofile and half-mass radii of post-collapsed clusters. The mass of the IMBH has beenchosen to be 500M , which is an expected value for the mass of an IMBH formed byrunaway mergers. Using this mass, in a system of N = 32768 stars, makes the relationM IMBH − M cluster unrealistic, because the mass of the IMBH is too high, but this way theinteractions of the IMBH with the stellar-mass black holes will be realistic. After 3Myr ina cluster of N = 32768 stars with initial masses following a Kroupa initial mass function[14] with realistic limits (m upper = 150M , m lower = 0.5M ), about 60 of them haveevolved to black holes with masses from 10M to 30M according to the stellar evolutionscenario used. We assumed that all BHs were maximally spinning, with a random orientationof their spins. This assumption is expected not to be far from reality, since many of the BHsof a cluster, might increase their spins during their lifetime, due to accretion of mass fromcompanion stars, as most of them are expected to form in binaries.We started the simulations paying special attention to the behavior of the IMBH in thecluster, and to the formation of close binary IMBH-BH systems. In the first 5Myr afterthe formation of the IMBH, the central black hole remains in the core where its motion issimilar to a random walk. It is dynamically active, interacting strongly with stars and blackholes that sink to the center. Due to mass-segregation, most of the stellar-mass BHs, whichare the most massive objects in the cluster, sink to the center very soon, forming a corerich of BHs. The first stable IMBH-BH binary formed at t ∼ 2.5Myr after the beginningof the simulation. The semimajor axis of this binary shrunk continuously due to stronginteractions with other BHs, while is some cases the companion of the IMBH changedseveral times during the simulations. The final IMBH-BH binary formed after 30Myr witha semimajor axis of α ∼ 1AU. Due to the gravitational radiation emission, the semimajoraxis of this binary shrunk even more, while its period decreased. As the binary becomesharder, the gravitational radiation that is emitted enters the LISA band and the binary wouldbe detectable by this space-based detector. The eccentricity of the binary when it wouldbecome obervable by LISA is around ∼ 0.1 − 0.3 similar to what is found in [137].In some of the simulations the two black holes merged in short time-scales and a recoilvelocity was assigned to the produced IMBH. We found that if the mass of the companionis above 15M the recoil velocity can be higher than the escape velocity at the center ofthe cluster, which is about 50kms −1 , and could lead to an escaping IMBH. The real recoilvelocity depends also on the orientation of the spins of the two black holes and might belower than the escape velocity of the cluster, making the IMBH oscillate with initially largeamplitudes around the cluster's center. This oscillation will have an obvious result on thestructure of the cluster.The results of these simulations are included in a new publication which is under preparation.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Year dc:date
2011

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Konstantinidis, Symeon
  • Κωνσταντινίδης, Συμεών

Subjects

dc:subject × 6

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/34554

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Konstantinidis, Symeon; Κωνσταντινίδης, Συμεών. Βαρυτική ακτινοβολία από συστήματα αστέρων. Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH), 2011. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/34554