Back to search

Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences

Η εθνοτική κινητοποίηση των αποσχιστικών κινημάτων

Abstract

dc:description

The primary theoretical and research interest of the dissertation is in how separatist collective action emerges and is sustained. Given the tacit agreement in the relevant literature that collective action in this type of movements necessitates a form of coalition between “publics” and considerable parts of the “elites”, the research question was formulated as ”how publics connect with elites in cases of separatist movements?”. Separatist movements have usually been studied within the frames of the literatures of nationalism and/or of ethnic mobilization. The dissertation examines exhaustively (and forms typologies of) theories of nationalism, ethnic, mobilization and separatism; the “classical” theories of the above phenomena seek to specify the structural, social or political conditions that are conducive to the emergence of nationalist/ethnic aspirations. However, the transition to political struggle and the dynamics of mobilization remain for the most part a black box. More suitable to address such concerns are (more recent) approaches that focus more on social agency and base their explanations on the role of identities, ideologies, individual interests and, mainly, on elite antagonisms (“elite manipulation”). Some drawbacks of these explanations are that they do not go beyond the specification of micro-social necessary conditions for the emergence of collective action and, most importantly, that they over-emphasize the role of elites. The dissertation’s analytical orientation is closer to a small subset of “social agency approaches” of nationalist/ethnic movements that employs concepts from the social movements’ field (political opportunity structures, framing, etc). However, it differentiates from these studies by adopting the research agenda of Dynamics of Contention (DOC), co-authored by C. Tilly, S. Tarrow and D. McAdam. DOC criticizes the “classic agenda” of social movements’ research for producing “static” analyses that do not assess adequately the fundamentally relational character of contentious politics; DOC not only puts emphasis on social relations, interactions and dynamics, but seeks to capture them analytically through concrete social mechanisms. Τhe dissertation not only adopts the DOC framework for the analysis of separatist movements, but also employs a specific set of five causal mechanisms (among those proposed by DOC), namely “boundary activation/deactivation”, “attribution of opportunity/threat”, “social appropriation”, “frame bridging” and “brokerage”. Thus, it puts forward the hypothesis that these five mechanisms can jointly explain the emergence of effective, separatist mobilization, i.e. that they can explain the emergence of coordinated, sustained collective action of publics and elites in cases of separatist claim-making. This hypothesis is tested through the comparative examination of two relatively under-researched separatist movements, the West Papuan in Indonesia and that of the Oromo in Ethiopia. The content and the possible manifestations of the five mechanisms are specified, so that their function is observable; then, a five-point ordinal scale is proposed, in order to assess the effectiveness of their function. By proposing a periodization of each of the two movements, more observations of the operation of the five mechanisms are produced. The core observation of the comparative analysis is that in periods of heightened collective action, the joint operation of the five mechanisms is more observable and more effective, and vice versa. Thus, whereas the articulation of separatist (as well as nationalist or ethnic) claims by organizations is relatively unproblematic, the emergence of massive, effective contentious action needs explanation: and this can be provided by the proposed set of five mechanisms that captures the interactions of elites and publics in collective action. Therefore, the dissertation concludes that the hypothesis put forward is plausible. The explanation of the emergence of separatist mobilization does not need to rest primarily on elite interests and elite manipulation; rather, an explanation that focuses on the multifaceted connections and relations between various actors of “elites” and “publics”, seems more fruitful and socially grounded.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences
Year dc:date
2012

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Γούμενος, Θωμάς
  • Goumenos, Thomas

Subjects

dc:subject × 22

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/34988

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Γούμενος, Θωμάς; Goumenos, Thomas. Η εθνοτική κινητοποίηση των αποσχιστικών κινημάτων. Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences, 2012. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/34988