Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Το παλαιοπαθολογικό προφίλ της πορώδους υπερόστωσης ως επιδημιολογικής έκρηξης στις κοινωνίες του πρώιμου ολόκαινου στον ελλαδικό χώρο: μία βιοπολιτισμική προσέγγιση

Abstract

dc:description

The shift in current bioarchaeological research focuses on new interpretative synthesis on the identity of the Greek prehistory and how it is shaped through the processes of phenomena during the Holocene, a chronological period (10000 B.C.-today) which signs the biocultural microevolution of societies. The Neolithic period (~7000-3200 B.C.) has been a field of hot debate, as the critical stage of the beginning of the agricultural economy with the consequent biological and socioeconomic implications, from the hunting-gathering stage of the preceding Mesolithic period (~9000-7000 B.C.) to the advent and intensification of farming and the development of the civil structures during the Bronze period (~3200-1200 B.C.). Within that conceptual framework, a significant number of scholars support the major impact of the Neolithic structures on the health status of societies due to the shift from the nutritious animal protein intake of the Mesolithic hunters to the low nutritional quality of carbohydrates and the lack of microelements of the Neolithic farmers, furthermore related to severe demographic events. Porotic hyperostosis and cribra orbitalia have been investigated as the most popular disorders in prehistoric archaeological samples identified as the epidemic/endemic events in the Neolithic period. The iron-deficiency anemia, as the cause agent of those diseases due to dietary behavioral patterns, has been established as the most popular theory in both Greek and European area. However, new data from the examination of archaeological collections and the revising of the sociocultural models in prehistoric contexts dispute the prevailing paradigm. Therefore, the established methodology of the traditional archaeology is tested to new experimental methods through an interdisciplinary approach and a logical dialectism in bioarchaeology. The present project aims to build up the clinical, biocultural and biogeographic profile of a disease group, that is, the porotic hyperostosis and cribra orbitalia with the occasionally co-occurring pathological finds in the endocranium and the postcranial skeleton. They are developed as porotic lesions in different degrees of severity and morphology on the cranial and orbital areas with occasional co-occurrence of endocranial and postcranial lesions. From 14 excavated prehistoric sites-units of various environmental and geomorphological settings in Greece, developing a stratigraphic sequence with chronological diachrony, human remains of 230 individuals, mainly of young ages (<30), were studied. In comparison to the routine macroscopic and radiological analysis, new analytical laboratory methods were applied such as, endoscopy, scanning electron microscopy-SEM and microscopic-histological analysis applying adjusted alternative technical protocols. The main objective of that attempt is to construct the clinical picture of those diseases using reliable methods for differential diagnosis and possible paleoepidemiological research in combination with the introduction of “know how” in order to build up a database of diseased ancient bone. As reference control groups, samples from prehistoric and medieval sites in central and northern Europe, Levant and northern America were examined both macroscopically and microscopically. By applying the new analytical laboratories techniques, the main variables of the outer table, the diplöe and the inner table of both cranial and orbital regions entered in the database include: the morphology of pitting/porosis, the frequency distribution pattern per anatomical area, the stage of severity of porosity, the morphology and pattern of angiosis/hypervascularity, osteoblastic and osteoclastic processes, features of lamellar and woven bone, the morphology and changes in the architecture and size of diploic trabeculae and lamellae, striation patterns, hypertophic and proliferate organizational zones of bone reaction, islands of remodeling and mixed structures, contact areas of the bone tissue, structures and stages of healing processes. The statistical analysis used raw data and categorical variables (chi-square) to assess significance of correlation of groups and variables. The testing of the selected parameters in the macroscopic examination did not provide either a consistent morphotype or a pattern of the distribution or stages of severity and prevalence of the lesions, except from the few cases exhibiting an advanced stage of porotic lesions. There was assessed a broad spectrum of variability in the relation of the variables with chronological period. Furthermore, no correlation between the prevalence of the lesions and age/gender was observed, while a significant variability on intra-, and inter-site level was evaluated. In contrast to the results from the macroscopic analysis, the combination of the new analytical methods provided sound criteria to enter to the database, to apply protocols and attain a reliable differential diagnosis, yet of major disease groups. Very few cases of porotic hyperostosis and cribra orbitalia were diagnosed as anemic episodes, yet of a mild degree and in a successfully healing process. The same finds stand for scurvy lesions which are identified in few individuals in a mild stage and/or a remodeling process of healing. The percentage of lesions on the outer table diagnosed as cranial periostitis and of the endocranial ones as non-specific infections, meningitis, leptomeningitis, pachymeningitis, tubercular meningitis, hemorrhagic events caused either from localized trauma or epidural, subdural hematoma or scurvy, mixed structures of inflammation-hemorrhage or hemorrhage-inflammation compose the clinical picture and differential diagnosis of porotic hyperostosis and cribra orbitalia, evaluated as morphological features of a multifactorial etiology. In a significant number of specimens the histological examination diagnosed the porotic lesions as diagenetic, identified as pathological in the macroscopic analysis. The statistical analysis of categorical variables showed a relationship of the prevalence of the lesions with the type of physical environment but it is not possible to assess a causal link per se. Furthermore, the epidemiological profile of the syndromes under investigation is not documented considering the continuous population movements in Greek prehistory with the genetic impact on their demographic profile. In the interpretative synthesis, the current research, under the new findings of the genetic background and polymorphism of the iron-deficiency anemia, megaloblastic anemia and scurvy, beyond their dietary cause, and the anemia of inflammation, needs to be incorporated. It is expected that some individuals may have suffered from different categories of anemias, with or without hyperplasia of marrow, such as, the genetic anemias, autosomal anemias, the sideroblastic anemias, the hemolytic anemias, the megaloblastic anemias, the anemia related with chronic leukemia, the anemia of chronic heart defects, hypoxia anemias, anemia of lead poisoning, idiopathic anemias of unidentified cause without the involvement of any erythropoietin dysfunction. In combination with the paleohistological examination, molecular and biochemical analysis for tracing immunological dysfunctional proteins on genetic anemias and scurvy, methods already successfully tested on ancient bone disease, will contribute to more reliable diagnosis. Furthermore, the application of spectroscopic techniques for the quantification and bioelementary analysis of porosis will provide new variables to the database and research on diagenesis, a new developing field in paleopathology

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2012

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Stravopodi, Eleni
  • Στραβοπόδη, Ελένη

Subjects

dc:subject × 20

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/35014

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Stravopodi, Eleni; Στραβοπόδη, Ελένη. Το παλαιοπαθολογικό προφίλ της πορώδους υπερόστωσης ως επιδημιολογικής έκρηξης στις κοινωνίες του πρώιμου ολόκαινου στον ελλαδικό χώρο: μία βιοπολιτισμική προσέγγιση. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2012. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/35014