Abstract
dc:descriptionThe main purpose of this study is to conceal the collusion between Immanuel Kant and the Stoics, with reference to the problem of Ethics, through three main themes concerning: a. The concepts of Good and Evil in relation to the moral law b. coupling virtue and happiness and c. the model of Stoic Wise.Were investigated primarily the concept of reason, freedom and duty on both philosophical schools, in order to understand the similarities and differences of the above have thematic. In these chapters, it was found that the similarities between Kant and Stoic is of particular importance, although Kant himself does not explicitly refer to the Arcade.Therefore, the work is composed of eight (8) chapters, divided into subsections in order to achieve systematic reference to the test individual issues.The first chapter presents the sources that toppled the Immanuel Kant and drew his knowledge of the Lodge. The Stoicism is one of the main sources of moral philosophy of Kant. There is a range of key passages in the works of the philosopher, on virtue, the will, the Supreme Good and the moral value of the person, where the Stoic ethics has a special place. The Kant sometimes praises the Stoics for the validity of their reflections and sometimes rejects, through the systematic review, their positions in their respective subjects. One of the first scholars who dealt with the position of Stoic ethics in Kant's philosophy, is Willi Schink. In his article "Kant und die stoische Ethik" lists the sources of Königsberg philosopher in relation to the Stoic ethics. O A. Warda also deals extensively with the philosophy of Immanuel Kant and presents the sources of the philosopher, in his "Immanuel Kants Bucher". Important in this chapter, is the reference to Johann Jacob Brucker. O Brucker wrote a world history of philosophy, entitled "Historia critica Philosophiae", which consists of two volumes. In the first volume (and few in the second), inter alia, in Stoicism, paying special attention, as did Kant, in moral philosophy.The second chapter investigates the place and role of the Word in the minds of the Stoics and Kant, in order to find the common course. It is characteristic that both the Kantian and the Stoic ethics, the position of the Word predominate. The Word is a fundamental concept for the determination of human life and harmony with nature, is a common denominator of the two philosophical schools. However, the reason for Kant, is approached in the context of purely practical Speech and away from any empirical evidence, while the Stoics is connected to the flat sensation experience. Despite the differences found between Kant and the Lodge, it is important to their common position on obedience to moral law, but which for Kant defined under task through a priori moral law, while the Stoics defined under nature. Frequent and accurate reports of Kant in the respective positions of the Lodge concerning the Word and Nature, show that the Kainixvergios philosopher fully understood the meaning of Stoic ethics. Specifically, this chapter examines a. The position of the Word in Kant and Stoic ethics b. The interpretation given by Kant in dogmatic philosophy of Stoics and c. The affinities of the cosmic Logos of the Stoics with the Categorical Imperative of Kant.The third chapter analyzes the concept of freedom in the Stoics and Kant. Studied mainly a. The problem arises when freedom confused with the necessity or "Doom" by the Stoics and b. The concept of moral conscience, which coincides with freedom in Kant and the Stoic moral intellect. Substantial concurrence not present in the conception of Stoics and Kant's about freedom, but is a comparative examination, to conceal the differences that exist in moral theory and two respectively. On the issue of freedom of the Kant differs from the Stoics, as they frame the freedom to Nature, God and the cosmic Logos, while the Kant considers necessary request of Practical Reason. Therefore expresses its own position, one hand admiring the views of the Lodge, on the other hand, developing the thought of self. So Kant approaching freedom through the moral law, the consciousness of which the Faktum Speech.The fourth chapter touches on the concept of Kantian duty and it is different from the Stoic teaching. For this purpose, investigated the position of Stoic "feat" in relation to the Kantian duty to elucidate the differences between the two theories. Also stressed the "moral sense" of duty in Kant, as a feeling of satisfaction or pleasure (here Immanuel Kant identifies with Epicurus), in discharging his duty itself. It even how separation of functions is in perfect and imperfect, by Kant, is stoic origin, as evidenced by the sources. But for Kant, the task associated with freedom and, through the moral law leads us to the supreme good. Such a quest to attain the supreme good, sets the request of the immortality of the soul, which for Kant is part of the practical reason, but the claim of the existence of God.In the fifth chapter deals with the overarching objective of philosophizing in Kant and the Stoics. Presents the interpretation given by Kant on the definition of the Stoic philosophy and his own position with reference to the Supreme Good. Also analyzed the interpretation of Kant on the ethical principles of the Stoics. The Kant endorses, analyze and justify the Stoic division of Philosophy (Physics-Logic-Ethics). Disagrees, however, with the Stoics in the definition of philosophy, arguing that they should Philosophy is not teaching of wisdom (as claimed by the Stoics), but the supreme good. The Kant also explains the concept of perfection and examine its suitability as a condition of morality. It argues that the physical principles can not be the moral authority, because all matter of practical rules always based on subjective conditions. The principle of the Lodge, in Kant, belongs to bliss, since reduced to the world of experience.The sixth chapter explores the dimensions of Good and Evil in the Stoic and Kantian philosophy. The Kantian theory calls for the setting of ethical standards related to the Good and the Bad in order to conceal the similarities and differences with the Stoic ethics. So the process is perceived to be the Supreme Good (and relative to the a priori moral law), which for Kant is a fundamental moral sense. According to Kant, evil must be evicted from the property of morality, from the corrupt rule and hence by freedom itself and not from the slopes. Therefore, the Stoic would have the moral criterion of option within the meaning of freedom. Also Kant, compares the stoic virtue with Christian ethics in the choice of their ethical standards. It should also be noted that the Kantian distinction on predisposition and torque, there is a potential affinity with the Lodge, even though the distinction is not developed with such clarity and insight, as in Kant.The seventh chapter studies the virtue and happiness in the Stoic and Kantian moral intellect. Presented and analyzed in depth review in which Kant makes, for the Stoic positions for virtue, and emphasized the value of the Supreme Good, which is the coupling of virtue and happiness, the moral philosophy of Kant. The philosopher agrees with the Stoics in the identification of virtue with courage and cultivation through exercise. However, slams the persistent effort of the Lodge to simulate the practical principles of virtue and happiness, to integrate ie happiness to virtue, which is the supreme good.The eighth chapter explores the Stoic ideal of the Wise in relation to the Kantian ethics. It examines and analyzes the passions and apathy to the Stoics and Kant, beyond the power of human morality and human dignity. Although Kant adopts some general views of the Stoics on the passions and their connection with the Word, does not agree with the definition of the passions and functional capacity, as it considers bad moods. It also differs from the Lodge to the issue of apathy, rejecting it, while approaching pity and compassion in the same study light with that of Stoic, using and enhancing their own examples. The characteristics of the Stoic Wise and reduction in authority, it is perfectly acceptable Posts by Kant, as the philosopher considers perfection as material and separates from the "End". Simultaneously determines the moral power differently from Stoic philosophers.Still, it is obvious how Kant opposes the stoic acceptance of suicide, as says the spontaneous suicide is never justified - unlike the Stoics who justified in cases - and a crime against ourselves, against other people and God. Moreover shows that the preservation of life is dictated by the task itself. The Kant, clearly rejecting eudemonism the Stoics said that man can not and should not escape the pain. A righteous man, when Kainixvergio philosopher, he feels satisfied when elevate and honor humanity in his own person, even if it succeeded, living the great miseries of life. Duty and will not have exact equivalent in Stoicism, but are fundamental concepts in Kant.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2014
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Stamouli, Anthoula
- Σταμούλη, Ανθούλα
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/35254