National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Επικοινωνία και αναθεώρηση πεποιθήσεων: διερεύνηση και επεξεργασία ενός περιγραφικού μοντέλου μέτρησης
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe descriptive belief adjustment model of a recipient (“hearer") in her communication with a "speaker", proposed by the theoretical-philosophical research of Aris Koutougkos about the possibility of partial agreement, is being investigated as far as its empirical adequacy is concerned. The variables of this descriptive ‘bipolar’ model are: a) the motivation to 'register' (or integrate, absorb) the claim of the speaker in her own system of beliefs, where this motive is perceived as product of two factors: a1) the hearer’s credibility account of the speaker within the broad concept of incorporating all the relative communication details in it, and a2) the magnitude of the divergence between the hearer and the speaker, determined after the announcement (by the speaker) of the speaker’s probability to the sentence p, and b) the resistance of the hearer’s belief system to change (anti-motivation).Regarding the methodology of measurements, two empirical studies (Pilot- Main) were performed where participants were asked to revise their degrees of belief about sentences (p) that were given to them. Having completed, at an earlier stage, a questionnaire designed to measure their resistance K, the hearers complete another questionnaire (after the procedure) which measured the credibility W they attached to the speaker. So, ensuring maximum validity and reliability of data acquisition, this methodology provided values for the variables of the model. First a comparison was carried out between empirically recorded revisions and revisions according to the descriptive model. Results showed that the bipolar (motivation/anti-motivation) belief adjustment model seems to be confirmed to a large extent and the level of matching between theory and empirical data seems quite satisfactory.At a second level of analysis, comparability with the application framework of Bayesian inference was investigated. Through the structural asymmetry of the two models, concerning the absence of a value in the hearer’s posterior possibility to the fact that the speaker assigns a probability to E evidence, the concept of 'subsequent probability' emerged (according to Van Fraassen’s Reflection Principle, RP). This concept allows for the model to be regarded as strictly 'bipolar', ie, the probability at which the hearer confronts the speaker/estimator about the exact same sentence, is already a 'subsequent probability', in the sense that it already incorporates every possible assessment of the hearer for this belief. Then the descriptive model was combined with Dempster-Shafer‘s belief functions in order to examine its predictiveness compared to the empirical revisions. Results showed that the mean difference between predicted and observed beliefs is statistically insignificant, providing another control measure of the proposed model and offering a greater degree of authenticity to the project, since there is a link with the normative oriented belief functions theory.Finally, an interesting finding, that provides a base for further development, has been the observation of an “unexplainable behavior” (neither approach nor repulsion) on behalf of the hearers that led to the 'emergence' of a negative resistance to belief change as a variable of the model.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2014
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Stelios, Spyridon
- Στέλιος, Σπυρίδων
Subjects
dc:subject × 20- Αναθεώρηση πεποιθήσεων
- Επικοινωνία
- Μπεϊζιανή γνωσιολογία
- Εμπειρική μελέτη
- Πειραματική φιλοσοφία
- Πειραματική ψυχολογία
- Belief revision
- Communication
- Bayesian epistemology
- Empirical study
- Experimental philosophy
- Experimental psychology
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Ψυχολογία και Γνωσιακή Επιστήμη
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Φιλοσοφία, Ηθική και Θρησκεία
- Social Sciences
- Psychology and Cognitive Sciences
- Humanities and the Arts
- Philosophy, Ethics and Religion
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/35326