National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Αίλιος Αριστείδης: ένας σοφιστής μεταξύ δύο εποχών: δεύτερη σοφιστική και ύστερη αρχαιότητα
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis doctoral dissertation is about the life, the personality and the work of Aelius Aristides, one of the most prominent representatives of the Second Sophistic and aims at a) the study of the characteristics which integrate the sophist in his time (2nd century A.D.) b) the search for the impact he had on the texts of following scholars, especially in the field of rhetoric and c) the detection of thematics of Late Antiquity which share common features with the life and work of Aelius Aristides. As far as the method followed is concerned, it has been attempted to define the terms Second Sophistic and Late Antiquity in order to determine the temporal limits this dissertation is ranged within. The term Second Sophistic was invented by Philostratus in his work “Lives of Sophists” in order to methodically approach the intellectual phenomenon, with the intention of recording the criteria according to which some individuals should be included in this movement. Taking into consideration the attributes of these people (noble descent, wealth, higher education, roman civil rights etc.), as peak period of the sophistic movement was considered the period intervening the time of Plutarch and Dio of Prusa, who are considered precursor figures of the Second Sophistic and the time of the author of “Lives of Sophists”, Philostratus (mid. 3rd century A.D.). Nevertheless, this time span should not be considered as absolute since there are references of sophists and orators with characteristics similar to those of the people whose biographies are recorded by Philostratus in inscriptions originating from the 3rd century. On the other hand, Late Antiquity is a historical period the time range of which is still an object of deliberation and the scholars do not agree neither on its beginning nor on its end. However, despite any disagreements, the historical period in question is characterized by significant changes in political, economic, social, cultural, and religious level: the main features of these sectors, which had remained intact for centuries in an extended geographical area (mainly around the Mediterranean Sea, without excluding areas such as the Northern Europe, the Near East etc.) are transformed radically, despite the preservation of elements from the “classical past” (e.g. we are led from a pagan to a Christian world and from a universal Roman state to a disintegration into the Byzantine Empire of the Eastern Europe, the “barbaric states” of the West and the areas of the Islamic domination.) Therefore, the limits (geographical and chronological) of the Late Antiquity vary according to the object of study of each researcher.In the case of Aelius Aristides, the delimitation of the term Late Antiquity was achieved using as a criterion the available sources which are the references of subsequent authors of Aelius Aristides and his work. These are divided into two groups: a) those which appear at the time of the sophist (the atticist Phrynichus) and spread to the 6th century A.D. (the philosopher Olympiodorus) and b) those of the Byzantine authors of the 11th-14th cent. (Michail Psellos, Theodorus Metohites etc.). Based on these, the research was limited to the sources of the first category because the impact of the sophist’s work on subsequent scholars is determined, while at the same time, the majority of the researchers of the Late Antiquity identifies the most important transformations which differentiated the character of public and private life in these centuries (especially in the 3rd and 4th cent A.D.)During the authorship of this dissertation, the hereby directions were followed: a) a thorough study of primary sources (texts of ancient Greek and Latin literature, epigraphical and numismatic testimonies) in order to record the characteristics of Aelius Aristides’ personal identity which integrate him in the historic, political, social, cultural and religious reality of his time, but also the features which differentiate him from the rest of the sophists and make him a precursor of evolutions that occurred in the Late Antiquity (mainly in religion). b) the testimonies of subsequent scholars (3rd- 6th cent. A.D.) were collected, so as to clarify the dominating views about Aelius Aristides (his paideia, his rhetorical abilities, his ethos, and work) and also the impact he had upon them. c) Thematics of his work of a diachronic nature were detected (e.g. the conflict between rhetoric and philosophy, the universality of the Roman Empire, the eulogy of the emperor) which had already appeared in previous times but were also developed by authors following Aelius Aristides, in order to determine the contribution of the sophist as a “link in the chain”.Conclusions: a) Aelius Aristides embodies a number of the most characteristic features of the sophist movement. He originates from the geographical area of the greek-speaking East, he is descented from a wealthy family, he owns a significant fortune, he is a member of the upper social class (in his work he defends the ideology of the administrative aristocracy of the cities), he has roman civil rights and receives higher education orientated at the classical past of Hellenism. His achievement in rhetoric makes him one of the most prominent representatives of the Second Sophistic, who in accordance with the practices of the other sophists, gives lectures in cities, sanctuaries, and celebrations while at the same time he develops an intense writing activity.b) The fame for Aelius Aristidis’ educational capacity had as a result him being mentioned in the works of other authors even of his own time. The references are divided into two categories: 1) those mentioning the sophist in a laudatory manner regarding his rhetorical abilities, his fluency in the attic dialect, the impression created by some of his speeches and his higher ethos (Phrynichus, Apsines, Hermogenes, Menander Rhetor, Libanius) and 2) those which declaim against Aelius Aristidis criticizing severely elements of his character and, mainly, the views he expressed against Plato and philosophical life in general in his so-called platonic speeches; the latter accusations have been put forward by the representatives of neoplatonism.c) A number of traits of his personality, though, differentiate him from other representatives of the Second Sophistic: 1) he exalts the noble descent of people and cities but he does not reveal information about his family, being connected mainly with his servants, 2) he spends a significant part of his life in cities of the greek-speaking East (eg. Smyrna) but, at the same time, he frequently retires to villas, distinguishing in his love for nature, 3) he defends the ideology of the administrative aristocracy of the cities but refrains from their two essential activities, the adoption of offices and the evergetism, 4) he includes elements of the roman political ideology in his work but he does not participate actively in the imperial cult and he describes unfavourably his trip to Rome, 5) he illustrates his educational abilities but avoids to communicate his excellent paideia by providing lessons to young men or by founding a school and 6) he has a specific attitude towards religion, forming a close, personal relationship with one deity, Asclepius.d) The characteristics of Aelius Aristidis’ religious identity are the ones that particularly connect him with the Late Antiquity and especially with the two dominant currents of the time, christianity and neoplatonism. Such are: 1) the deification of paideia, 2) the personal connection and communication with the divine element, 3) the monotheistic tendencies, 4) the significance of some holly texts, 5) the symbolic- ritual content of names and invocations, 5) the belief in the existence of prophetic dreams and divine epiphanies, 6) the adoption of ascetic forms of life and 7) the formation of communities with a religious character.e) Finally, it is also worth noting some features of the ‘divine man’ detected in autobiographical information provided by Aelius Aristidis: divine dreams or visions, prophecies, miraculous cures control over the elements of nature etc. This incomplete image of the ‘divine man’ is evolves during the Late Antiquity (a time when religion plays a significant role), both in the case of neoplatonism (e.g. the Pythagoras’ biographies by Porfyrius and Iamblichus, Proclus’ biography by Marinus, works which form the type of the neoplatonic theurgist) and within the Christian religion (the Christian saint, ascetic, monk or bishop).
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2015
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Mpatás, Michaíl
- Μπατάς, Μιχαήλ
Subjects
dc:subject × 10Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/35428