Back to search

Athens School of Fine Arts (ASFA)

Η διαλεκτική της κριτικής δύναμης: μια συμβολή στην τρέχουσα συζήτηση για την πραγματολογία με βάση τη διπλή Αισθητική της Κριτικής της κριτικής δύναμης του Καντ

Abstract

dc:description

Frederic Beiser has recently argued that the contemporary discourse of normativity reproduces the problems of the neo-Kantian discussion, because it does not take it into consideration. The dissertation examines the viability of the attempt of contemporary “normative Pragmatics” to return to post-Kantian German Idealism in order to develop a conception of normativity that can address the problem of “rule-following”, i.e., the problem of the infinite regress of rules that arises concerning the application of conceptual rules to reality and is known since Kant as the problem of “judgment” (Brandom, Pippin, Habermas). To achieve this aim Ι focus on the reception of Kant’s Critique of Judgment in “normative Pragmatics” and disclose its origin – via Gadamer and Arendt – in the reception of the Critique of Judgment within the neo-Kantian philosophy of language (Cohen, Cassirer). According to this interpretative continuum that concentrates on the transcendental principle of judgment, whose use is being referred by Kant at bottom to the “feeling of life” (beautiful) of the empirical human subjects in order to avoid the infinite regress, the problem of the Critique of Judgment lies consequently in its normative deficit concerning the practical dimension of “rule-following” (or “judgment”). In Chapter II Ι oppose this reception on the basis of an interpretation of the “double Aesthetics” (beautiful, sublime) of the Critique of Judgment. In particular I argue that Kant addresses the problem of naturalism through the second, “practical” principle of judgment that is being disclosed in the “Analytic of the Sublime”. In examining this principle I locate the real problem of the Critique of Judgment in the fact that the normative determination of the practical dimension of judgment marks the limit of the transcendental method, because it refers to a particular natural cause (the empirical human subject or the human “faculty of desire”) “that acts in accordance with concepts”. Thus this principle is not transcendental, but “metaphysical” and has within the “Critique” the irreducible status of “moral faith”. On this basis I claim that the “pragmatic transformation of Kant”, which is being proposed since Cassirer and up to “normative Pragmatics” as the appropriate correction, does not overcome the dialectic between naturalism and moral faith that characterizes Kant’s conception of normativity as regards the practical dimension of “judgment” (‘Dialectic of Judgment’). On the contrary it reproduces this dialectic, as it transforms due to an insufficient understanding of the real problem of the Critique of Judgment its “practical”, “metaphysical” principle. Finally in Chapter III I examine the question whether the ‘Dialectic of Judgment’ is a necessary conclusion and propose a reconstruction of the problem of “rule-following” and of the irreducible practical dimension of “judgment” as expression of the fundamental, modal distinction of transcendental philosophy between (conceptual) possibility and actuality. I follow thus the method of conceptual analysis from the perspective of critical philosophy in the Kantian tradition. According to the suggested reconstruction this distinction and the relevant problem does not refer only to human “understanding” or “judgment”, but to critical understanding in general. It is thus not a specifically human problem, but a structural element of rationality in general. On this basis I reconstruct precisely as expression of the fundamental transcendental modal distinction Cassirer’s use of the concept of “question” as logical form of “understanding” that reappears –also via Gadamer and Arendt– in “normative Pragmatics”, e.g. under the form of Brandom’s fundamental “practice of giving and asking for reasons”. As it thus refers to a strict transcendental principle (valid for rationality in general) the proposed reconstruction offers a conception of normativity (or rationality) that disentangles itself from the ‘Dialectic of Judgment’.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Athens School of Fine Arts (ASFA)
Year dc:date
2014

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Polias, Konstantinos
  • Πολιάς, Κωνσταντίνος

Subjects

dc:subject × 28

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/35476

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Polias, Konstantinos; Πολιάς, Κωνσταντίνος. Η διαλεκτική της κριτικής δύναμης: μια συμβολή στην τρέχουσα συζήτηση για την πραγματολογία με βάση τη διπλή Αισθητική της Κριτικής της κριτικής δύναμης του Καντ. Athens School of Fine Arts (ASFA), 2014. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/35476