University of Ioannina
Συστηματική αποτίμηση τεκμηρίων για την αποτελεσματικότητα της ψυχοθεραπείας
Abstract
dc:descriptionBackground: The field of psychotherapy research appears to be vulnerable to non-financial conflicts of interest (COIs) such as researcher's own therapy allegiances (RA). However, reporting and evaluating allegiance effect in meta-analyses and in randomised controlled trials (RCTs) have not been systematically estimated.Objectives: To systematically evaluate if researcher’s allegiance was adequate reported by any means in meta-analyses and in RCTs of psychotherapeutic treatments. Furthermore, using a meta-analytic approach we aimed to estimate the impact of this allegiance effect on the results of psychotherapeutic studies.Method: We searched for meta-analyses of RCTs of various types of psychotherapies, in Medline and in Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Meta-analyses were eligible if included at least one study with RA, published in journals with impact factor larger than 5 and in Cochrane Database. Thirty eligible meta-analyses from Cochrane Database were further analyzed by comparing the effect sizes in allegiance trials with non-allegiance using random and fixed models and a summary relative odds ratio was calculated. Heterogeneity was quantified with the I2 metric.Results: We identified 146 eligible meta-analyses in total of 3.038 search results which synthesized data from a total of 2727 RCTs. Only 25 (17.2 %) reported allegiance whereas only 5 (3.5%) of them used a proper method to control its effect. Of the 1198 eligible primary RCTs, 793 (66.3%) had a clear evidence of RA. Twenty five out of 793 (3.2 %) allegiant RCTs reported allegiance, while only one (0.2 %) controlled for its effect. From the Cochrane Database, 30 eligible meta-analyses (published until January 2011) including 240 randomised controlled trials were analyzed. Effect sizes of experimental intervention with psychotherapy allegiance has more favorable effect than experimental intervention without psychotherapy allegiance [sROR=1.31 (95% confidence interval 1.03 to 1.66) P=0.30, I2=53%]. The impact of allegiance in mental and medical disorders comparison did not differ significantly. Allegiance treatment effect was significant for all forms of psychological interventions except cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) (Supportive: sROR=1.44, 95% CI:1.01-2.05, I2=0%, others [Behavioral therapy, Family systems therapy, Psychodynamic]: sROR=2.34, 95% CI: 1.03-1.66, I2=79%, CBT: sROR=1.07, 95% CI: 0.85-1.34, I2=19%). Moreover, the impact of allegiance was highest when the allegiant was neither the first nor last author of the report. Allegiance effect was even stronger where the experimenter was also the developer of the therapy.Conclusions: The vast majority of meta-analyses of psychological interventions published in high-impact journals as well as Cochrane Database seldom reported and evaluated allegiance effect. The results of the present study highlight a major gap on this information regarding meta-analyses and their included studies of psychotherapeutic interventions. Moreover, experimenter’s allegiance influences the effect sizes of psychotherapy RCTs and can be considered non-financial conflict of interest introducing a form of optimism bias. As in other research areas, clear guidelines and principles should be needed in order to eliminate allegiance potential effects.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Ioannina
- Year dc:date
- 2014
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Dragioti, Elena
- Δραγκιώτη, Ελένη
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Επίδραση της υποταγής του ερευνητή στη μέθοδο
- Ψυχοθεραπεία
- Σφάλμα θετικής προδιάθεσης
- Μη οικονομική σύγκρουση συμφερόντων
- Συστηματικό σφάλμα
- Allegiance effect
- Psychotherapy
- Optimism bias
- Non-financial conflict of interest
- Systematic bias
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Άλλες Ιατρικές Επιστήμες
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Ψυχολογία και Γνωσιακή Επιστήμη
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Other Medical Sciences
- Social Sciences
- Psychology and Cognitive Sciences
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- BY
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/35537