Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Η αρμονική σύνθεση ως φορέας θεμελιωδών αρχών στην καλλιτεχνική δημιουργία: μία εμβάθυνση στο έργο του Johannes Vermeer

Abstract

dc:description

Vermeer’s name and work are often connected by his studiers to a mystery. Most of the documents that refer to Vermeer are related to his family, even though the artist’s fame has spread also beyond Delft, where he was born and lived. For example, none of his personal documents or correspondence survive, nor any of the painter’s drawings or drafts –no element that might contribute to a deeper understanding of his intellectual and artistic temperament. The only element that really connects us to his interests, his pursuits and his temperament is his oeuvre itself. And here lies yet another question mark. Vermeer died at the age of just 43 years old leaving behind less than 50 works, of which 34-36 have been acknowledged to date. It is thereby estimated that the artist would complete only about two works per year; Works that are usually notably small in size, so as to assume that the time required for their creation would be less than in the case their size were, for example, double or triple. This dissertation aims at a deeper understanding of Vermeer’s work. Even though it is analyzed in the spatio-temporal context in which it is included, the Dutch Golden Age and the social, economic and political circumstances in Delft, where the artist lived, the research hypothesis is not limited to the ineffectual impression that his oeuvre is simply compliant with the requirements of this framework, as some experts claim.Initially, the elements that feature relations with contemporary artists and possible teachers are explored, as there is no documentation of Vermeer’s apprenticeship, in or outside Delft, or of his relationships with other artists. It was finally suggested, after thorough research, that Vermeer had different teachers during the overall period of his apprenticeship, which explains why there isn’t a very strong univocal influence on his work. The possible reasons, why he was not officially documented as an apprentice of at least one of the three artists that are hereby suggested as the most predominant ones, are individually analyzed.In order to deepen into Vermeer’s distinctiveness however, his artworks were paralleled with artworks of various distinguished contemporary Dutch painters. This comparison was proven an invaluable guide to a different viewing of his work, as this stands discreetly distant. The consistency of his images is remarkable, especially of his relatively mature works. The peculiar limitations of these works appear in contradistinction to the ensemble of daily life depictions. Vermeer is distinguished by being notably faithful, notably committed to a very specific “mise en scene”. His works constitute a unity with a specific identity; His intent structures clearly and with consistency the ensemble of his compositions.As a next step, the relationship of Vermeer’s work to the work of the Flemish Jan van Eyck, who left his mark on the History of Art at least two centuries earlier, was thoroughly explored. The comparison concentrated on the values that consistently govern the work and formulate the personal artistic proposal of the two creators. Gradually, an integrated proposal is established, in the entire dissertation, on Vermeer’s total approach, which, according to the tradition that he inherited from Jan van Eyck, is based on a geometric structure, and impregnates with meaning all the individual elements that constitute his compositions. At the same time, according to the spirit of his era, the rendering of Vermeer’s depictions is utterly naturalistic. This is precisely the most misleading point in the eyes of a modern viewer. As was established in this dissertation, the camera obscura was the pioneering, for his time, tool that gave Vermeer the opportunity to support his naturalistic depictions with pure and complex geometry. The process that is hereby suggested that the artist followed reveals in total a complex mental schema-conception and a deep preparatory work underlying each work. This whole process provides an interpretation for the perfection of his oeuvre and for the limited number of his artworks, as such a methodology would require time-consuming elaboration for the formation of the desired outcome.As a possible link to Vermeer’s use of the camera obscura, Constantijn Huygens is suggested in preceding studies, a distinguished Dutch diplomat and intellectual, poet and composer. In this dissertation the link to his son Christiaan Huygens (1629-95), a distinguished mathematician, astronomer and physicist, is asserted as more probable. An integrated proposal is thus developed that connects the great artist with the leading scientist. Subsequently, the geometric structure of Vermeer’s works was explored. Some fragmentary proposals by other researchers were presented, while a thorough approach of the geometric structure of specific paintings was conducted. The particularly elaborated and precise geometric structure of his compositions was thus ascertained, as implemented even in the way the forms of his protagonists are included, and the systematic use of the proportion of the golden section –the Divine Proportion, the universal ratio that expresses a perfection of beauty in nature and art, according to Luca Pacioli (1509).The harmony that characterizes Vermeer’s compositions, but also the way in which the persons that feature in them harmonize with their environment, point to the survival of Platonic principles in his oeuvre. This suggestion is reinforced with the disclosure of the use of the golden section in the internal structure of his paintings, as, in addition, with the deepening in the overall meaning of his works.This dissertation concludes in the overall overview of Vermeer’s mature works as a consistent system, regarding, on the one hand, the symbols, the meaning and the philosophy that govern them, and, on the other hand, regarding the geometry that structures them. As the conceptual and the compositional off-centre centre of the compositions may be supported by the formulation of the golden spiral, the way that this specific formulation highlights visible axes and characteristic points in the artist’s works is analyzed. Besides the fact that the results in the fit of the spiral are sometimes astonishing, this formulation is proven overall a useful tool for the approach of the meaning of Vermeer’s mature works. The (equiangular) spiral, however, attracts the interest of the scientific community during Vermeer’s time with its ‘magical’ properties, as was traced in the correspondence of three of its distinguished representatives, Descartes, Mersenne, and Christiaan Huygens. Besides, the spirals and their design are studied already from Archimedes’ time, as is evident in the manuscripts of the painter and mathematician of the Renaissance, Pierro de la Fransesca. As analyzed in total, the possible inscription of the golden spiral as a basis for the geometry of his compositions wouldn’t have been a complicated task for Vermeer. For the attribution of meaning based on the spiral, Vermeer’s mature works were separated in sections. As established by the individual analysis of the symbols and the overall composition of each work, the section with the more early works is linked to the theme of love and conquest, where the virtue of Temperance and its loss are important in the interpretation of each work, whereas in another section the protagonists may even act as personifications of virtues. In the letters’ section, where the connection to the beloved who is absent is sought, the protagonists are again distinguished for their virtue, their faithfulness and their perseverance. In another section, music is connected mainly with love (and light, or their lack), the tuning and harmonization of the ones in love, or even with Platonic love.The section of Vermeer’s allegorical works was left last purposely, because the analysis of these works was more complex and extensive, with parallel analyses of the different approaches of allegory and symbolism, and the connection of allegory to mathematical relationships, according to Neoplatonic views, which render allegory as the way for the revelation of the absolute truth. As was detected, the depiction of the withdrawn curtain in both allegorical works is linked to the significance of a revelation. The mask that is depicted in ‘The Art of Painting’ is recognized as a mask of Apollon Mousagetēs (Apollo Muse-leader), god of light, who makes everything manifest and visible, with the attribute of the sun light to penetrate hidden causes. The symbolic introduction of sun light, that Panofsky points out for Van Eyck, attaching a transcendental nuance to it, inheres also within Vermeer’s work, as is overall analyzed.Besides, the spiral, as analyzed in its different appearances in nature and in art, may form a symbol with a deep meaning, that is connected to the worship of the sun and that is honored since ancient times. The overall attribution of meaning to Vermeer’s works, through a primordial symbol that may connect his depictions with a trajectory to the light, with the exceptional transcendental nuance that is given to this light through Vermeer’s oeuvre in total, becomes thus more than attractive.Among the numerous and extensive studies on Vermeer’s oeuvre, there are some that provide insight into his approach, others that enlighten specific aspects of his oeuvre or his life, and others, for which any truth of his oeuvre evades. It is a real challenge for the contemporary viewer to apprehend this complex mental schema that is suggested in this dissertation to be structuring each of Vermeer’s works; this geometric web of correlations among the persons depicted and the objects-symbols in the particular setting that surrounds them –as well as to realize that the artist dedicated all this time and devotion to complete his compositions. The artist completed only about two paintings per year of his relatively brief life-even though he would have every reason, judging by the needs of his large family, to be more productive. It appears however that he was loyal until the end to his distinctive and splendid vision –which indeed awards to him the glorious laurels that adorn the head of Clio in the ‘Art of Painting’.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2015

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Dimitrakopoulou, Evgenia (Zenia)
  • Δημητρακοπούλου, Ευγενία (Ζένια)

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • BY_NC_ND
Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/35926

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Dimitrakopoulou, Evgenia (Zenia); Δημητρακοπούλου, Ευγενία (Ζένια). Η αρμονική σύνθεση ως φορέας θεμελιωδών αρχών στην καλλιτεχνική δημιουργία: μία εμβάθυνση στο έργο του Johannes Vermeer. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2015. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/35926