University of Crete (UOC)
Βιοηθικές αποφάσεις που αφορούν τη φροντίδα νεογνών κατά την περιγεννητική περίοδο: απόψεις επαγγελματιών υγείας στη χώρα μας
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe rapid advancement of medical knowledge and technology in the field of neonatal care along with the improvement of living standards in recent decades have brought significant, positive changes to epidemiological indicators of neonatal survival at the international level. However, perinatal complications such as prematurity, intrauterine growth disorders of the fetus, congenital and perinatal infections, congenital anomalies and hypoxic–ischemic stroke inevitably lead to the birth of diseased and extremely/very premature infants, with extremely/low birth weight. These infant categories show low survival rates and suffer from severe disorders, which prevent their social and professional integration and adaptation in later life. So far, international epidemiological data are not encouraging with regard to these categories of infants and, in particular, infants born before completing the 24th week of pregnancy. Survival rates for this category of infants do not seem to increase, while no encouraging changes have been recorded with regard to the rate of occurrence of physical or mental disabilities in early childhood or adulthood. Intensive care is available and is often provided to these infants. However, serious bioethical questions arise in respect of the use and feasibility of intensive care in such clinical cases, in view of its reduced efficacy in preventing death and achieving the full recovery of those children. This has lead to the emergence of a broader bioethical dilemma, namely of whether human life must be saved at any cost and with any consequence by using intensive care, life-support practices, or whether limits must be put in place with regard to the provision of invasive, life-saving techniques and medicines, so that the course of the disease and the health status of the newborn may evolve naturally, without interventions.Three different approaches and strategies for managing the provision of intensive care to extremely/very premature and diseased infants may be found in international literature: (a) the ‘interventionist approach’ or ‘wait until certainty strategy’, which consists in offering ‘aggressive’ intensive care and treatment to all newborns from the outset; (b) the ‘statistic approach’ or ‘statistical prognostic strategy’, which sets limits to the intensive care provided from the outset, according to the gestational age and weight of the newborn, based on statistical probabilities for an unfavorable diagnosis or bad outcome of the incident; and (c) the ‘individualized approach’ or ‘individual prognostic strategy’, according to which intensive care must be initiated for almost every newborn and must be thereafter reassessed on a regular basis, according to the severity of the damages suffered.These different approaches for managing the intensive care services provided to infants, reveal that different, or at least differentiated, criteria are used when it comes to making critical ethical decisions, such as the ones mentioned above. However, international literature and practice tend to converge towards a specific decision-making criterion with regard to ethical questions, namely that of the infant’s ‘best interest’. On the one hand, this criterion seems to be increasingly applied in clinical practice and, on the other hand, it is increasingly recommended by international guidelines and instructions, as well as by scientific organizations. Indeed, in spite of all the criticism which has been leveled at it, the ‘best interest’ approach is highly recommended in cases where decisions concern newborns, infants and children, as well as other persons who lack the capacity of making such decisions for themselves. According to this approach, the criterion for providing intensive care or for defining the care to be provided is the infant’s quality of life, both during hospitalization and in the long run. As an alternative to this criterion, Wilkinson (2011) has recently proposed the ‘Threshold View’, according to which it is not obligatory to continue providing life-support to infants where it is expected that their wellbeing will be extremely restricted in the future. Crucial moral dilemmas arising in clinical practice and the variety of approaches towards managing intensive care for extremely/very premature infants, with extremely/low birth weight, as well as diseased infants, combined with the fact that the relevant legal framework is quite limited and varies between different countries, have put forward the need to establish a regulatory framework for making such decisions and have lead to the introduction of guidelines and recommendations. Despite the lack of consensus, international guidelines and recommendations agree in that there is no hope of survival for newborns with a gestational age equal to or lower than 22 weeks and that the threshold of human survival lies between the beginning and end of the 22nd week of pregnancy. Offering palliative care and comfort is the only indicated treatment for infants of this age. With regard to treating infants born between the 23rd and the 24th (or, for others, the 25th) week of pregnancy, a period characterized as the ‘gray area’, it is recommended to take seriously into account the opinion of parents, in view of the existing uncertainties. In the light of the above and despite international efforts, the regulatory framework for managing neonatal intensive care remains rather unclear and ambiguous. On the other hand, the challenges and dilemmas arising from clinical practice tend to increase with the advancement and progress of available means and techniques. It is therefore necessary to investigate both the decision-making process with regard to ethical questions, such as those involving intensive neonatal care, as well as the framework (clinical, social, cultural, etc) in which such decisions are made and implemented. This situation is particularly exacerbated in countries like Greece, where there are no guidelines and recommendations by scientific organizations, the relevant legislative framework is extremely limited, and, unlike the situation in other countries, the actual conditions of decision-making on ethical issues concerning infants are not being recorded. The purpose of this thesis is to fill this gap.In particular, this PhD thesis focuses on assessing the ethical appropriateness of crucial clinical decisions setting ethical limitations and constraints to the application of life-support and life-saving invasive practices in infants, and investigates the criteria used to justify such decisions. The first objective is approached through international literature. The second objective is approached by conducting a critical analysis of international guidelines and recommendations. The particular empirical goals of this thesis are: (a) making an assessment of the ethical acceptability of posing restrictions to neonatal care by Greek health care professionals, through investigating the degree of acceptance or rejection of specific clinical behaviors that put ethical limits to the provision of neonatal intensive care; and (b) investigating the factors that shape the assessment framework of the ethical acceptability of applying restrictions to neonatal care. The survey was conducted on a sample of 251 Greek health care professionals (physicians, midwives, nurses) working in 15 public hospitals in Greece. Data was collected through international weighted questionnaires (partially differentiated per professional group), which were translated and adjusted to the Greek reality and conditions. The questionnaires used were initially developed in the context of the European program ‘Euronic’ and they have been used in a large number of similar surveys throughout the world ever since. As a consequence, for the first time, the empirical research carried out in the context of this thesis records and brings to the fore the opinions and behaviors of Greek health care professionals (physicians, midwives, nurses) in relation to decision-making on ethical issues when it comes to providing intensive care to exceptionally/very premature infants, with very/extremely low birth weight and diseased infants. In addition, by using this specific research tool, this survey achieves yet another empirical goal, namely to produce data on Greece which are comparable to data from other countries. According to the survey results, Greek health care professionals, both in general and as individual professional groups, tend to attribute an intrinsic value to human life. Hence, for the majority of Greek health care professionals of the sample, the beginning and continuation of neonatal intensive care, regardless of its result or other qualitative criteria, is regarded as ethically justifiable. On the other hand, health care professionals who prioritize quality of life are more likely to believe that it is ethically justifiable to withhold the health care services provided, as well as to implement the relevant practices. However, the above two findings highlight the importance of the attitude of health-care professionals towards human life, given that this attitude conditions their behavior. The views of health care professionals with regard to the ethical appropriateness of restricting invasive practices, even for near-death infants or infants with a highly unfavorable neurological prognosis, range between full acceptance, reservation and full rejection. The vast majority of health care professionals in Greece believe that the most ethically acceptable practice is to restrict intensive care only in the case of anencephaly. In the same context, ‘mild’ intensive care restriction practices also tend to be regarded as ethically justifiable, including the continuation of ongoing treatment without adding any new treatments and administering sedatives and/or analgesics in order to address the pain suffered by newborns, even if these substances may lead to death. The vast majority of Greek health care professionals (87.7%) state that the decision to limit neonatal intensive care is not made very often in Greek Neonatal Intensive Care Units (NICU), whereas a large majority of Greek health care professionals (66.1%) state that some infants are subjected to excessive intensive care. Nevertheless, one third of Greek physicians state that they have made the decision to restrict intensive care at least once during the exercise of their clinical work, in cases of near-death infants (37.7%) or infants with unfavorable neurological prognosis (30.8%). The practices reported by health care professionals with regard to putting ethical limits to the intensive care provided to infants are coherent with their views on ethical acceptability. Therefore, the usual practice is to avoid intensifying the health care services provided, by continuing current treatment without adding new treatments (73.9%), and without using emergency nursing/medical procedures (58.3%). Based on the statements made by health care professionals of the sample, it appears that the initial withholding of life-saving interventions and treatments immediately after childbirth tends to be avoided in Greece, whereas the practice of treatment withdrawal is disapproved.This survey also investigated Greek health care professionals attitude towards the introduction of legislative arrangements on withholding and withdrawing neonatal intensive care. According to the survey, only a small percentage of health care professionals (21.3%) agree with the introduction of legislative arrangements, which would set detailed rules for the limitation and discontinuation of intensive care. Despite the fact that a significant percentage of health care professionals (42.4%) are in favor of legalizing palliative care, which may lead to death, there are certain reservations with regard to establishing a legal framework allowing for the restriction of intensive care. Furthermore, the survey reveals significant reactions with regard to introducing a legal framework which would allow professionals to refuse to conduct resuscitation, while seven out of ten health care professionals (68.4%) declared categorically that they are against a potential legal framework allowing for active euthanasia. Physicians are partially differentiated from other professional groups as they tend to be more positive towards a potential legalization of discontinuing intensive care and not performing resuscitation to infants. On the other hand, they tend to be more negative towards a legislative framework that would allow for active euthanasia, as compared to midwives and nurses.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Crete (UOC)
- Year dc:date
- 2015
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Daglas, Maria
- Δάγλα, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 20- Νεογνική φροντίδα
- Βιοηθική
- Μονάδες Εντατικής Νοσηλείας Νεογνών
- ΠΡΟΩΡΟ ΝΕΟΓΝΟ
- Αποφάσεις επαγγελματιών υγείας
- Νεογνολογική νοσηλευτική φροντίδα
- Neonatal care
- Bioethics
- Neonatal Intensive Care Units (NICU)
- PREMATURE INFANT
- Decisions of health professionals
- Neonatal nursing care
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Φιλοσοφία, Ηθική και Θρησκεία
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Health Sciences
- Humanities and the Arts
- Philosophy, Ethics and Religion
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/36588