National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Ολοκληρωμένος σχεδιασμός προηγμένων διεργασιών δέσμευσης άνθρακα και παραγωγής εναλλακτικών καυσίμων από CO2 και βιομάζα
Abstract
dc:descriptionScope of this Thesis is the design, the process integration and the simulation of various advanced energy systems, the common feature of which is the absence or the minimization of GHG emissions. The main issues that are attempted to be addressed in this Thesis are related to the terms and frames of proper and feasible operation of innovative energy systems. Through the process modeling (Aspen PlusTM), numerous valuable conclusions are extracted related to the design and operation of the total systems and each of the sub-process that compose them. Moreover, the basic economic indexes that determine their economic feasibility of the under investigation concepts are estimated by means of the techno-economic analysis on them.In the first chapter, the methodology followed for the selection of the energy systems that are investigated in this Thesis is explained. In first, a brief discussion is made concerning the prediction of the worldwide energy consumption and CO2 emissions derived from the fossil fuel combustion. At a second level, the predominant strategic options for the drastic reduction of the anthropogenic GHG emissions are defined and presented: a) Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS), b) Carbon Capture and Utilization (CCU) and c) Biomass exploitation for advanced fuels and chemicals production. As far as the CCS is concerned, the analysis is distinguished by the fuel type (natural gas or coal) whereas regarding to the CCU, more attention is paid on the CO2 conversion into alcohols (methanol and ethanol) through catalytic hydrogenation. Concerning the biomass utilization route, the investigation was focused on the biomass conversion into value added fuels and chemicals such higher alcohols and aviation biofuels.The aim of the second chapter is to present a natural gas (NG) fired power plant where Pd membranes are employed for the CO2 capture leading to a near zero GHG emissions energy system. According to this concept, natural gas is transformed into a H2-rich fuel through the consecutive processes of autothermal reforming and water gas shift reaction. Pure hydrogen is recovered through Pd membranes and is led to be combusted in GT. The methodology that is adopted for the selection of the best design of the process in terms of system optimization is presented in detail for each section/unit. Next, a sensitivity analysis of several operating parameters is performed in order to determine the key parameters that maximize the plant efficiency and minimize the total required membrane area. Simulation results showed that the Pd membranes employed with NGCC with 90% CO2 capture efficiency can reach a net efficiency equal to 50.82%, revealing it as the most efficient option for CO2 capture in a NG fired system, as far as the net efficiency is concerned. From the economic analysis it is concluded that the investment cost, which is strongly influenced by the membrane area requirement, plays the most important role on the total plant cost. From this evaluation it is shown that the case with the optimum (i.e. minimum) membrane area can achieve a CO2 avoidance cost 7.4% lower than the MDEA base case.In the third chapter, the most important post combustion carbon capture technologies i.e. the amines scrubbing, and the Calcium looping, are investigated in order to compare their efficient application in large scale fossil fired power plants in comparison with oxyfuel combustion. The post combustion capture techniques differently affect the power plant: the amine system consumes steam for stripping (reboiler), whilst calcium sorbents regeneration process consumes fuel. On the other hand, oxyfuel technology has to suffer the power consumption penalties for the oxygen production from an Air Separation Unit. The comparative tool used is the exergetic analysis of the most significant processes employed in these schemes techniques. The carbonation/calcination process is the most energetically and exergetically efficient with the lowest exergy penalty (-9.0%, whereas in the amine and oxyfuel case is -10.0% and -9.5% respectively), even though a considerable amount of exergy (22.3% of total exergy in fuel) is lost in the CaL unit. In the MEA case, 7.7% of the exergy input was calculated that is lost in the capture unit and 1.0% during CO2 compression. In the oxy-combustion case, the ASU is the main unit where most of the exergy losses for CO2 capture are observed (5.1% of the total exergy input in the system).In the fourth chapter, various design and operating aspects are investigated for the valorization of industrially captured CO2 towards methanol production and the circumstances under of which this concept can be economically viable. Cost breakdown in various Power-to-Fuel concepts confirm that hydrogen cost is the most crucial factor. Several power delivery options for hydrogen production through electrolysis are compared for their economics. The use of cheap electricity in conjunction with adequate time coverage throughout the annum is of high importance for lowering the overall H2 production costs. Also, a Power-to-Fuel system integrated with a coal fired power plant can be an interesting option for excess power transformation when the electricity sell is not profitable. The economic analysis on the H2 production scheme revealed that each of the three main parameters for the determination of the H2 cost (electrolyzer capital cost, electricity cost and storage cost) can play the key role in the feasibility of the plant depending on the concept each time. A considerable effort is needed in order the CO2 derived fuels to reach a competitive level in the global market.The fifth chapter is dedicated to the investigation of various design aspects for the valorization of industrially captured CO2 towards methanol and/or ethanol. In the framework of the CO2 conversion unit, two novel concepts are examined aiming to the improvement of the process performance, one for methanol and another for ethanol production. For the methanol case (CO2+3H2→CH3OH+H2O), a new scheme of employing a membrane reactor with high selectivity either in methanol permeation (organophilic) or in water permeation (hydrophilic) is explored via process simulation. The methanol extraction has a beneficial effect on the methanol yield and requires a more compact sized reactor. In ethanol case (2CO2+6H2→C2H5OH+3H2O), a new process configuration through the intermediate DME (di-methyl ether) synthesis is presented and compared to the conventional method based on CO2 conversion to CO in a reverse water gas shift (rWGS) reactor followed by the mixed alcohol synthesis reactor. The novel synthesis route via DME has a higher efficiency (total energy efficiency: 70.3% on LHV basis whereas the corresponding efficiency of the conventional scheme is 63.2%) because of lower heat and power demands for its effective operation. From the economic analysis, it is shown that the novel ethanol plant results to lower ethanol production cost than the conventional one through the rWGS by 18% but the high cost for H2 production through water electrolysis keeps it far for competitive levels.In the framework of the biomass utilization, the sixth chapter is related with the synthesis of Higher Alcohols (i.e. ethanol, plus C3-C4) from biomass gasification. These compounds could be used directly as fuel or fuel additives or as important intermediates for the chemical industry. A comparison is performed between the different process configurations. All steps and important unit operations are modeled and presented with the aim to correctly evaluate the peripheral energy requirements and conclude with the overall thermodynamic limitations of the processes. The differentiation between black liquor and solid biomass gasification, the type of catalyst employed, and the effect of the recycling scheme adopted for the reutilization of unconverted syngas are evaluated. The design has to cope with the limited yields and poor selectivity of catalysts developed so far. The gas cleaning is different depending on the different requirements of the catalysts as far as H2S purity. The process simulation results reveal that the CO hydrogenation to higher alcohols is favoured by high pressure, temperature around 325 oC and high reactor residence times. A biorefinery using modified Fisher – Tropsch (FT) catalysts (MoS2) prevail over modified MeOH catalyst (Cu-Zn based) for HA production. The efficiency of HA production in HHV terms can reach up to 25%.In the seventh chapter, the conceptual process design for the production of branched paraffins with high carbon number is presented, based on the upgrading of alcohols synthesized from biomass-derived syngas and the economic evaluation and comparison with the Fischer-Tropsch (FT) process and biochemical pathways. Two routes, one based on n-butanol and another on isobutanol upgrading, are described and modeled. The flow sheeting results reveal high performance for both process configurations, resulting in an aviation fuel yield 0.172kg/kgfeedstock and a thermal efficiency of 40.5% in the case of employing a modified Methanol catalyst for the mixed alcohols synthesis (MAS). Such alternative pathways offer higher efficiencies compared to FT synthesis because specific products such as C12+ branched paraffins for jet fuel applications are achieved with higher selectivity in the conversion processes. The water balance at the whole process reveals that the annual demands for fresh water from a 190MWth biorefinery plant are 641000m3, emerging the water management as an important issue with considerable environmental impacts. Simulations of the overall process show a rather high biomass carbon to product utilization ratio (up to 30%) leading to relative low CO2 emissions. The economic evaluation reveals that the minimum jet fuel selling price in a FT plant (1.24 €/l jet fuel) is lower than the corresponding price in a MAS plant (1.49 €/l and 1.28 €/l for cases with different catalysts). The biochemical route based on Acetone-Butanol-Ethanol fermentation is considered as the most economically desirable option (0.82 €/l). Moreover, the option of selling organic compounds, which are produced intermediately (i.e. light and heavy olefins, C4 alcohol isomers) via the alcohols’ upgrading processes was proved promising enough for the feasibility of such biorefineries plants.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2015
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Atsonios, Konstantinos
- Ατσόνιος, Κωνσταντίνος
Subjects
dc:subject × 22- Ολοκληρωμένος σχεδιασμός ενεργειακών συστημάτων
- Μοντελοποίηση διεργασιών
- Δέσμευση και αποθήκευση CO2
- Δέσμευση και αξιοποίηση CO2
- Βιοδιυλιστήρια
- Μεμβράνες παλλαδίου
- Εξεργειακή ανάλυση
- Παραγωγή αλκοολών μέσω θερμοχημικών διεργασιών
- Οικονομοτεχνική ανάλυση
- Process integration of energy systems
- Process modelling
- Carbon capture and storage
- Carbon Capture and Utilization
- Biorefinery
- Palladium membranes
- Exergy analysis
- Alcohols synthesis through thermochemical pathways
- Techno - economic analysis
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη Μηχανολόγου Μηχανικού
- Engineering and Technology
- Mechanical Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/36722