Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Διερεύνηση της ψυχοπαθολογίας Ελληνίδων κρατουμένων

Abstract

dc:description

AimPrison population is on the increase around the world. This is also happening in our country. Within the prison population, women are the minority. Among the most interesting and persistent findings in the literature is that mental illness affects women and men differently. While gender has so often been found to be an important determinant of prevalence and outcomes of mental illness, the particular needs and problems faced by women prisoners are rarely a priority for State agencies. In our country, women prisoners are a minority that only recently has started to become visible. Female prisoners have not been thoroughly studied to date in our country. There are scattered and anecdotal reports on the psychopathology of prisoners in Greek prisons, but there is no structured and organized methodological research in prisons for women and specifically for the Greek General Locked Women’s’ Korydallos prison . Women prisoners’ needs are increasingly recognized in recent years and an effort is made to organize research separately from men prisoners. Rresearch on psychopathology of women prisoners is intended to contribute to our knowledge about this unknown aspect. This particular research can serve as a basis for the development of mental health services for these detainees and also highlight the particular needs arising from gender, motherhood, and the different social roles of women.MethodologyDuring the research period, in 2008, almost all the Greek women prisoners were held at General Locked Women’s Korydallos prison. A locked, high security wing for women, which is outside the perimeter of the male prison. General Locked Women’s Korydallos prison until- 175 -May 2008 was the only Greek prison for women who were either detained or serving a prison sentence.The General Locked Women’s Korydallos prison doesn't have separate health or mental health facilities specifically for women and could not host any women prisoners who are in need of acute or intense psychiatric care.The General Locked Women’s Korydallos prison at the first semester of 2008 hosted 781 to 881 women. During the period of the survey it hosted an average of 767 women including the women who were being held pending trial and the women who were sentenced with imprisonment. Women who were held pending trial ranged from 193 to 225 and the women serving prison sentence ranged from 556 to 588. This variation of female population being held was due to the fact that the prison is a "living organism" with great mobility of detained and sentenced women. Detained women are judged and either converted to sentenced ones or discharged and sentenced women are judged innocent and released by the Court of Appeal. This has as a result fluctuation in the number of women being held.Women who were being held pending trial were excluded from the study. The population of women sentenced, ranged from 556 to 588 and during the first half of 2008 and formed the population investigated with an average number of 573 sentenced women at the survey period.Among these women are included not only women of Greek origin, but also women from other countries who were arrested at the borders or after a short stay in Greece. These women were 195 in total and were excluded from the survey. The remaining 378 women born in EU countries, Balkans, Middle East, were considered as "Greek" for the purposes of this study are included. These women originated from another country but were permanently resident in Greece (speaking Greek at a satisfactory level) and all were married to Greeks thus acquiring Greek citizenship. One hundred thirty two women from the tribe of Roma, (Gipsy) did not wish to cooperate with prison staff in an overwhelming proportion and for this reason were also excluded as a group, from the present study.From the remaining sample of 246 women after randomization we selected a sample of 80% of this population with an effort to picture the whole population in the study. In this way we identified 197 women. Of the 197 women selected, and asked to participate, only eight (4%) refused, leaving 189 women who formed the study sample.The sample of 189 women prisoners which was studied represent 32.9% of the whole female prison population in General Locked Women’s’ Korydallos prison and 76.8% of the originally selected sample.- 176 -Data were collected from March 2008 until June 2008. Data were collected from four sources: Disciplinary files and medical records of the prison, a semi-structured interview, information provided by the prison staff who knew the sentenced women and also from questionnaires {MINI 5.0.0. (The Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview), BPRS (Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale), GHQ-28 (General Health Questionnaire), CAGE} ResultsWe have found the typical Greek female prisoner is 40.7 years old (Sd=12.6), born mainly in Greece (69,8%), with origin from the Balkan Peninsula (23.3%), born abrooad from Grrek imigrants and living in Greece (12.1%) or married to Greeks and living in Greece (18.7%) . She is serving a sentence for drug related offences (42.3%) and almost equally for Murder/attempted murder (17.5%), and offences relating to money (Frauds, forgeries, extortion etc) (23.3%), with theft( 10.6%) and sex-related offences (5.3%) to be rarer. Average sentence time that has been imposed is 119.9 months (Sd=81.7), with about 40.2% of them to have reoffended in the past, but with about 67.2% of them to have prior contact with the justice system or the police, although this contact hasn’t always led to imprisonment.She was brought up by her biological parents (85.7%). They have reported conflicts at home (33.3%) and their carers had issues with the police or imprisonment at 16. 4%.She knows how to read and write. 45.0% has completed second degree school and 15.9% has completed university studies. They have good working history and 61.9% of them have been working for more than 15 years mainly at manual jobs. She had long term sexual relationships (88.8%), 68.3% of them have been married and 25.4% continues to be married while she is in prison. She has children (65.1%) and 12.7% three or more . Quality of the relationship has equal chances to be harmonic (40.2%) or violent (42.3%). Their physical health deteriorates inside the prison and 50.8% of them have somatic issues, when before only 38.1% had medical history. She is requesting and receiving psychotropic medication, mainly anxiolytics (32.8%), for a variety of reasons, antidepressants (18.5%), antipsychotics (3.7%) and mood stabilizers (1.6%) .According to DSM IV-TR Axis I they have depression /dysthymia (23.8%) substance abuse disorder (10.6%) bipolar disorder type I (8.5%), anxiety disorders (7.9%) and schizophrenia/delusional disorders (4.2%). Characteristics of personality disorder cluster Β according to DSM IV-TR were evident for Borderline (22, 8%) and Antisocial personality disorder (43, 9%). She had no contact with mental health services before the imprisonment and she had positive history for alcohol (39.7%) and illicit drugs ( 38.6%).In our sample female inmates with sentences for violent crimes had no prior criminal history (79.4%), but had previous contact with police without always conviction (50.0%). They were serving lifetime sentence (61.6%). Among the inmates with sentences for violent crimes they were suffering from psychiatric disorder (61.6% ), mainly from depression/ dysthymia (26. 5%), followed by substance use (14. 7%), bipolar disorder (8.8%), schizophrenia spectrum disorders (5. 9% and Anxiety disorders (2.9%).Traits of antisocial personality as juvenile were found at 30.2% of the whole sample. During the adult life these traits were observed in 64.6% of our sample. Women with Borderline (22.8%) and Antisocial (43.9%) personality disorder were sentenced for crimes related to drugs (50.8%), murder (19.0%), offences relating to money (Frauds, forgeries, extortion etc) (15.1%), theft ( 9.5 %) and sex-related offences (4.8%) . Women with personality disorder had prior criminal history with imprisonment (48.4%) with the mazority of prior convictions for offences related to drugs (32.5%).DiscussionThe specific characteristics of women inmates are increasingly recognized in recent years and an effort is made for a separate, from male prisoners, research focus, in order to highlight the special needs related to gender, motherhood, and different social roles both in the family and in society, in order to organize in a better way their care. There should be the possibility to organize high quality research. This should be organized by the state. This research should not be limited to or focused only on Criminology, but should expand to other sciences such as medicine, psychology, psychiatry, sociology, etc. There are many practical issues about the research in prisons and the access by researchers outside the Ministry of Justice. Usually the ministry of Justice is unwilling to allow researchers access. Official bodies should be invited to a dialectical process with the services of the Ministry of Justice, forming a constructive dialogue. We consider the Forensic mental health department which has been lately developed as part of the 2nd University Psychiatric clinic at the Attikon Hospital, to have the ability to assist in this assessment.Knowledge of the prevalence of psychiatric disorders in prisons is of outmost importance in order to document needs and develop appropriate mental health services for detainees. Second, but equally important, is that the number of seriously mentally disordered prisoners- 178 -is a measure for the effectiveness of cooperation between the services of Psychiatry and of jurisprudence, with regard to mentally disordered offenders. It is regarded that one of the principal goals of mental health services is to keep offenders with severe mental disorders outside prison. This particular research could form the basis for the development of mental health services for these detainees and also deal with these specific issues of the gender.All the mentally disordered offenders are of disadvantage because of their multiple status as offenders, as mentally disordered, as financially needy and social deprived individuals. For women, gender discrimination should also be added to this list and maybe the additional disadvantage of the gender could be considered almost trivial if placed next to the disadvantages of being a mentally disordered offender, without financial and social power. It appears that the mentally disordered women offenders had more in common with their mentally disordered men than with other women who are not mentally disordered offenders.Ιt was observed that mentally disordered women in prisons have special needs and as there is no developed mental in-patient services, solutions are selected depending on the individual case and the willingness of services to assist. There is no specific section for women inmates. The Korydallos prison mental health hospital admits only male prisoners. In this respect female inmates with mental disorders are referred and transferred at psychiatric wards of specialized psychiatric hospitals and much less often, or hardly ever, at psychiatric wards of general hospitals.One of the main problems in prisons is the great lack of specialized services for women mentally disordered offenders and their interface with community services. The latest comments should emphasize the importance of the education in forensic mental health issues, for those who are working in prison mental health services, so that they could recognize early signs and symptoms of mental disorders and act promptly and effectively in case of disturbed behaviors. Mentally disordered offenders should be considered primarily as mentally disordered persons and secondarily as offenders.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2013

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Tsopelas, Christos
  • Τσόπελας, Χρήστος

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/37540

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Tsopelas, Christos; Τσόπελας, Χρήστος. Διερεύνηση της ψυχοπαθολογίας Ελληνίδων κρατουμένων. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2013. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/37540