University of the Aegean
Acoustic ecology of avians: soundscape and vocalization comparisons between urban and rural environments
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis doctorate thesis attempts to find proof on the increasing anthropogenic sonic effect upon nature. Ever since the anthropogenic “noise footprint” became apparent to the world, biologists have identified that cities change the songs of birds or alternatively that city birds have changed their tune. The aforementioned statements, attributed to the academic elite of the field of bioacoustics stood as incentives for the development of this research, which was carried out in Lesvos Island. The main objectives of the current study are the creation of a conceptual framework regarding noise, the creation of a soundscape dataset from Lesvos Island (LSRPD), the analysis of the hypothesis whether birds in small island urban agglomerations change their tune in respect to their forest inhabiting conspecifics, the physico-centric assessment of noise in relation to other “common” urban pollutants and finally the assessment of quietness via an anthropocentric “point of hearing” through the creation of a novel methodology regarding the identification of urban quiet areas.The central dogma of this research refers to “noise”. Throughout the course of this thesis, noise is being explored in terms of significance, disparity, perception and effect. To achieve this, noise is primarily regarded as a term. A conceptual framework is constructed, upon which the term receives its diverse perceptive meanings. According to these, the substance of noise is furtherly explored and the effects of noise are viewed from a nature-centric, an anthropocentric and a physico-centric angle. Seen from nature’s perspective, noise might interfere with signal thus impeding communication. To test this, the novel approach of this work was based on the idea to replicate the aforementioned well esteemed investigation by Slabbekoorn and den Boer-Visser in a much smaller scale. Pinpointing, as it has always been the basic method for the thorough examination of the unknown mechanisms underlying various hypotheses and statements, is in this case the main idea behind the thesis’s scientific hypothesis: Do city birds change their tune in small island urban agglomerations? The question (and most certainly its response) is not as simple as it may originally seem; besides the first-sighted obvious scale divergence, a range of issues are implied behind the suggestion itself, all of which are mainly based upon the mechanisms underlying the factual observations. To explore these mechanisms, I compared amplitude and frequency song and call attributes from great tits (Parus major) found in small urban settlements and forests of Lesvos Island. The regarding of the findings should be a two way approach: Either differences would resemble the model study ones, indicating that the mechanisms producing the variations are at work regardless the urbanization size (at least to the range between the two studies), or differences would not resemble the model study ones indicating alterations either in the nature of the mechanisms themselves, or in their expression.I found no significant differences for amplitude and low frequency call notes (churring), whilst I did observe difference in both high and low frequency song notes. These results support the hypothesis but also rise issues towards the hypothesized mechanisms at work, as both the low frequency churring calls as well as the amplitude of the songs cannot be accounted for. However, the heterogeneity observed in the normality of mainly the song notes which disallowed for parametric statistical analysis could offer an alternative explanation regarding sampling, which could reintroduce the hypothesis on a new sampling ground.Vocalization samples for the above work were extracted from a Database of recordings, the LSPRD (Lesbian Soundscape Recording Project Database), an ongoing recording project which began in 2011 in order to provide a representation of the island soundscapes, both urban and rural and to allow sonic incidents produced by the avifauna to be extracted from the database in a measurable, comparable way for reference purposes. The continual use of such large recording datasets is a common practice on this field and therefore their appearance in the academic literature is growing. Unfortunately up to our knowledge no such database exists countrywide, so its creation was mandatory.From an anthropocentric point of view, noise obtains a rather more subjective meaning. Humans decide upon noise with rather different criteria than nature. The effect of noise by terms of its lacking was explored in small urban agglomerations such as the case of Mytilene. First, a study was set in an attempt to relate two confoundingly produced pollutants: noise and air particles, both induced by traffic and both affecting urban inhabitants. However, no significant results correlating the two pollutants have been found.Subsequently, a methodology for the assessment of the quiet areas in small cities was evolved and used in the case of Mytilene, using citizen science techniques. These collaborations between scientists and volunteers which have the potential of broadening the scope of research and enhancing the ability of scientific data collection, are not only utilized for their contribution upon gathering valuable information as they learn about wildlife in their local communities (Cohn 2008), but also as members of such gatherings are also becoming acoustically aware in a broader than a strictly anthropocentric spectrum. Finally, an effort was made to bridge the two angles between the anthropocentric and nature-centric viewpoints by the production of an integrative conceptual conceive. By means of a proposal towards the usage of quiet areas as reference sites for field audio recordings, I aim to the formation of a new connection between bioacoustics, noise management and conservation planning.Finally, an effort was made to bridge the two angles between the anthropocentric and nature-centric viewpoints by the production of an integrative conceptual conceive. By means of a proposal towards the usage of quiet areas as reference sites for field audio recordings, I aim to the formation of a new connection between bioacoustics, noise management and conservation planning.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of the Aegean
- Year dc:date
- 2015
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Economou, Chris
- Οικονόμου, Χρήστος
Subjects
dc:subject × 8Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/37683