National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Institutions and cognition: a shared mental model approach on institutional formation and change
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis Thesis attempts a cross-disciplinary approach on the emergence and evolution of institutions, mainly through Economics, other Social Sciences, Cognitive Sciences, Neurobiology and Psychology. More specifically, it approaches – taking as an initial point the logic of Denzau and North (1994) and Mantzavinos, North & Shariq (2004) – institutions as shared mental models and attempts to explain their creation, evolution and institutional interdependence via this methodology. In this context, this Thesis attempts the extension, at a technical level, of the model of Jonker et al. (2011). The approach provides alternative views, but also margins of criticism against the instrumental rationality postulate and typical provisions concerning the behaviour of the economic agent. This Thesis is divided in three parts: On Cognition, On Institutions, and On Mental Models and Institutions. In the first part an attempt is made to recognize the basic cognitive functions of the human brain, highlighting in what points this differs from the typical provisions of mainstream Economics. In this context, an analysis of the importance of the axioms of rational choice and maximization of the individual agent’s utility in Economics is made. It is supported that the figure of the “economic agent” (homo economicus), as present in the neoclassical synthesis, is often at odds with the findings of Cognitive Sciences and Neurobiology. More specifically, it is analyzed how Economics has proved weak to incorporate not only the physical processes of the human brain, but also the mental functions that play an equally important role. Especially regarding mental processes, this Thesis attempts to examine them via the theory of Mental Models. This choice is based on the increased influence of social forces on the shaping and evolution of mental models. In particular, cognitive function (especially the mental part) is strongly influenced by the socialization process, which separates the physical from the mental part of human cognition.In the second part and attempt for a meta-analysis of the nature of institutions, but also the processes that govern their emergence and evolution, is made. This task is managed via a cross-disciplinary approach on institutions, like Economics, Sociology, Politics and Anthropology. The inability of Social Sciences to approach institutional analysis under a common context that respects the differences between institutions active at different social levels is underlined. The main problematic of this inability is traced basically at methodological grounds and more specifically at the differences between methodological individualism and holism. A more meso methodological approach is proposed as requisite for the analysis of institutions, namely that of Institutional Individualism. In this context, a categorizing of institutions in two broad categories is attempted, institutions as rules and institutions as equilibria, while a more circular view of institutions is suggested. Based on the aforementioned theorizing, this Thesis suggests a definition of the term “institution” that includes the cognitive extensions of the institutional structures, namely their ability to describe the external environment and the evident causalities. Taking into consideration the need for a comprehensive and systematic approach of the institutions in such a cross-disciplinary context, a taxonomy of institutions is built, based on six seminal taxonomies in Social Sciences (North, 1990; Scott, 1995; Williamson, 2000; Aoki, 2001; Mantzavinos, 2004; Parto, 2005). The taxonomy includes 7 societal levels (cognitive/primal, socio-cultural, organizational, economic exchange, polity, legal, constitutional), explains the variation of institutions in terms of formality per societal level, sketches the institutional interdependencies that can arise between institutions activated at different societal levels and underlines the requisite cross-disciplinary collaborations needed for each type of institution. In the third part, an attempt to connect the two previous parts is made, more specifically to analyze the institutions as shared mental models that people develop in a society in order to describe the external environment and explain past or evident social causalities. Furthermore, the drivers of institutional change are analyzed in this context. More specifically, if institutions were shared mental models, then institutional change would be marked in practice as a change in a shared mental level. Taking into consideration the need for describing this process in a more technical way, this Thesis builds on the methodology of Jonker et al. (2011). More analytically, it is suggested that a change in the shared mental schema could be explained for three possible reasons: (1) a change in the set of questions that the institution answers, (2) a change in the level of social agreement, (3) a change in the interpreting theory. Furthermore, based on the same methodology, this Thesis expands it for the case of interdependence between two shared mental models, highlighting thus the importance of institutional interdependence. Furthermore, based on the same methodology, an expansion for the case of interdependence between two shared mental models is attempted, highlighting in this way the significance of institutional interdependence. In comparison with the majority of the mainstream literature, this Thesis does not approach institutional interdependence only in terms of institutional complementarity, but also in terms of institutional antagonism and neutrality. At a final stage, an attempt is made to discuss how institutional creation and change is embedded in a wider context, compatible with the mental characteristics of individual and social choice. In this context, the schema of social change as proposed by Mantzavinos, North and Shariq (2004) is adopted. Nevertheless, in this schema some important lacking propositions are inserted. More specifically, the schema developed in this Thesis makes reference also to the importance of exogenous events, power exertion and institutional interdependence. The analysis of this schema of societal and institutional change suggests five drivers of institutional change: (1) setting new questions, (2) a change in the interpreting theory, (3) unexpected outcomes from existing shared mental models, policy outcomes and choices, (4) exogenous events, and (5) power exertion. In total, this Thesis suggests that ideas and findings from Cognitive Sciences and Mental Model Theory can enrich the mainstream model of human behaviour that one usually meets in Economics. Furthermore, at the level of policy-making, a cognitive institutional theory is able to explain why certain policy interventions have failed in the past, but also how policy makers can abet policy-making and policy implementation, in an incentive to human behaviour and mental processes compatible way.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2016
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Vrettos, Konstantinos
- Βρεττός, Κωνσταντίνος
Subjects
dc:subject × 20- Θεσμοί
- Νοητική λειτουργία
- Νοητικά μοντέλα
- Συλλογικά νοητικά μοντέλα
- Ορθολογικότητα
- Θεσμικά οικονομικά
- Θεσμική αλλαγή
- Δημόσια πολιτική
- Institutions
- Cognition
- Mental models
- Shared mental models
- Rationality
- Institutional economics
- Institutional change
- Public policy
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Οικονομικά και Επιχειρήσεις
- Social Sciences
- Economics and Business
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/37799