University of Thessaly (UTH)
Προοπτική συγκριτική τυχαιοποιημένη μελέτη αποτελεσματικότητας των τεχνικών χειρουργικών τομών περιορισμένης επεμβατικότητας
Abstract
dc:descriptionSince the beginning of the modern era of total knee replacement (TKR) in the early 70’s, a continuous research and evolution has led to the point where TKR is an effective and reliable treatment for knee arthritis. The conventional medial parapatellar approach has always been the workhorse and surgeon’s first choice when approaching the knee for TKR.Despite the repeatedly reported excellent long term results63 165, studies based on the subjective evaluation of the outcome by the patients were published in the 1990’s, showing that there might have been potential for improvement of the subjective clinical outcome and patient satisfaction. In this backgroundnand following the minimally invasive surgery (MIS) trend in many surgical disciplines3, the concept of (MIS) was introduced in TKR, after its successful application in the unicompartmental knee replacement62 169 170 . The proposed advantages –and initial reported results- were less blood loss 242 243 206, less postoperative pain and opioid use 241, less hospitalization 241 9 244, faster functional recovery 244 245, less need for postoperative rehabilitation241 increased patient satisfaction 246, increased cost efficiency247 248 and increased range of motion245 6 4.At the same time the first reservations were expressed as MIS techniques were correlated with an increased risk of implant malalignment8 233 and even of increased early revision rate during the first two years of index surgery223.AimsThe tested hypothesis of this study is that MIS midvastus approach gives better clinical outcome compared to the conventional technique. The primary end point is improved results in Knee score, Function score an Oxford score. Secondary endpoints are: radiological outcome, perioperative pain, operative time, blood loss, and complications rate.MethodsBeginning in January 2004, all patients aged between 50 and 80 years with osteoarthritis of the knee joint requiring TKR who had been admitted under the care of one surgeon were considered eligible to participate in the study . Written informed consent was obtained from all patients and the study was approved by the National and Hospital Ethical Committees. Additional inclusion criteria were good mental health, < 15° varus or valgus deformity, fixed-flexion deformity of < 20°, flexion > 90° and a body mass index (BMI)< 35 kg/m. A total of 50 patients were recruited to each group; the last patient was recruited in May 2005 and a final follow-up evaluation was performed in May 2013.Computer-generated randomisation and closed envelopes were used to allocate patients to either the minimally invasive group (group A) or the standard group (group B). In patients from group A, a mini-midvastus surgical approach as described by Laskin,8 Laskin et al, 9 and Haas et al 7 and the special minimally invasive surgical instrumentation for Genesis II (Smith & Nephew, Memphis, Tennessee) was used.One surgeon performed all the operations in a vertical laminar airflow theatre, and the Genesis II Oxinium prosthesis (Smith & Nephew) was used for all patients. Modern cementing technique was used for the fixation of both components. The patella was not replaced; All patients had patient-controlled epidural analgesia for 48 hours post-operatively. Prophylactic antibiotics were used pre- and post-operatively for two days, until the removal of the drain, and low molecular weight heparin anticoagulation was continued for 30 days postoperatively. Intensive physiotherapy was started from the first post-operative day. Clinical outcome data (both objective and subjective) were prospectively collected for all patients at regular intervals commencing pre-operatively, and continuing postoperatively on the first, third and sixth days, at three and six weeks, three, six and nine months, at one year, and annually thereafter. The following validated rating systems were used: the Knee Society clinical rating system (knee score, function score), and the Oxford knee score. Pain in the form of a visual analogue scale (VAS) ranging from 0 to 100 points (0, no pain; 100, worst pain) and the ability to actively elevate the leg with the knee extended were also recorded on the first, third and sixth days and at three and six weeks postoperatively.For radiological evaluation, standard anteroposterior,lateral and Merchant view radiographs and the Knee Society radiological rating system were used. Radiographs were taken and analysed at three weeks, six months, one year and every year thereafter.For statistical analysis Student’s t -test and the paired t-test were used to evaluate possible statistical differences of values within and between groups. Statistical significance was set at p < 0.05. A post hoc power analysis confirmed that there were enough patients in the study to test the hypothesis that minimally-invasive surgery gave better results than standard TKR.ResultsAt final follow-up 48 patients from group A and 47 from group B were available for evaluation. During the operation six patients undergoing the minimally-invasive approach required conversion to a standard approach, These six patients (group A1) were replaced by other patients recruited to group A so that 50 patients remained under investigation. No statistically significant differences were observed when the knee score was compared between the groups at each time interval and atfinal follow-up. Statistically significant differences were observed when the function score was compared between the groups at all time intervals, and at final follow-up. Statistically significant differences were observed when the Oxford knee score was compared between the groups at different time intervals up to the ninth post-operative month only. Pain, as estimated by the VAS, was statistically significantly higher in group A than in group B on the first and third post-operative days. At final follow-up there was no difference in the parameter of pain of the knee score between the groups. The parameter flexion of the knee score increased from a pre-operative mean of 111° (80° to 125°) to a final mean of 126.5° (95° to 135°) in group A, and from a pre-operative mean of 108° (85° to 125°) to a final mean of 116° (90° to 130°) in group B. Group A had a statistically significantly greater range of movement on the first, third, sixth and 21st post-operative days than those from group B (Fig. 7) (paired t -test, p = 0.04). It was noticeable that patients in group A reached the highest mean knee flexion much more rapidly than those in group B The mean blood loss of 613 ml (80 to 1400) collected in the drain was statistically significantly less in group A than in group B.Superficial wound healing problems due to marginal skin necrosis occurred in four knees from group A (8%) and in two knees (4%) from group B. No infection developed in any patient. Deep-vein thrombosis occurred in one knee from group A (2%) and in two knees (4%) from group B; One patient in each group (2%) complained of anterior knee pain. One patient in each group developed postoperative knee stiffness which required manipulation under anaesthesia.No significant difference was observed between the two groups in any of the parameters of Knee Society Radiological Rating System. Tibial component malalignment on the coronal plane judged by a deviation from the neutral axis of > 3° (varus placement) was present in three knees (6.25%) in group A and in nine (19%) in group B. Anterior placement of the femoral component was also found in three knees (6.25%) in group A. We observe that the total percentage of outliers in group A is 12.5% and in group B 19%. Analysis with z-test, with 95% Confidence Interval, showed that this difference is not statistically significant. ConclusionsThere was a definite, albeit temporary, functional effect up to nine months post-operatively and significantly less blood loss in those cases performed with a mini-midvastus approach. The price of this temporary functional effect was an increased operation time of approximately 20 minutes, which increases the indirect financial cost of such operations, an intra-operative conversion of the mini-midvastus to a standard approach for six patients and significantly more postoperative pain. This study shows that the MIS techniques are not related to any adverse events or increased early revision rates during the first eight years. We need to emphasize though, that seven years is not adequate time for a definite evaluation of survivorship. Patient selection is an important factor in the success of MIS techniques. The good results reported in our study have been achieved in appropriately selected patients as described in the methods section of this paper. It also needs to be emphasized that, based on its methodology, our study is rather explanatory than a pragmatic one.The authors of this study currently perform minimally invasive TKR in selected cases only, following appropriate counselling of patients. Further studies and more mid term and long term results are needed in order to investigate any possible role of MIS techniques in the era of Enhance Recovery Protocols.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Thessaly (UTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2016
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Giotikas, Dimitrios
- Γιωτίκας, Δημήτριος
Subjects
dc:subject × 10Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- BY
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/38566