University of Peloponesse
Η αξιολόγηση του σχολικού βιβλίου φυσικής αγωγής καθηγητή της Α' γυμνασίου και του μαθητή Α'+Β'+Γ' γυμνασίου
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe purpose of the present study is to evaluate the Physical Education textbook for Secondary School pupils and the P.E. guide for the first year for the teachers.Objectives of the study is firstly the evaluation of the secondary pupils’ book by teachers of Physical Education, School Advisers / Heads of P.E. Offices with regard to: a) content, b) objectives, c) presentation – illustration and, d) structure. Secondly, the evaluation of the pupils’ book by the pupils themselves, with regard to: a) contents, b) pedagogical suitability, c) structure & organization, d) presentation & illustration. And thirdly, the evaluation of the first year P.E. guide for the P.E. teachers, by School Advisers / Heads of P.E. offices and the P.E. teachers themselves with regard to: a) contents, b) objectives, c) the implementation of certain athletic activities, d) structure, e) difficulties experienced in using the guide, and f) instruction given teachers on the use of the book.The following questions were also investigated, in the form of null hypotheses: for the Secondary pupils’ P.E. textbook: a) the views of P.E. teachers on the basis of the independent variable, gender and the independently variable place of distribution with regards to the: i) contents, ii) objectives, iii) illustration of the book. b) The views of School Advisers / Heads of P.E. offices on the basis of the independent variable, gender and the independent variable place of distribution with regards to the: i) contents, ii) objectives, iii) illustration of the book. c) The views of pupils on the basis of the independent variable, gender and place of distribution with regards to the: i) contents, ii) objectives, iii) structure and organization, and iv) illustration of the book.In addition, with regard to the Teachers’ P.E. guide for first year pupils of Secondary schools, the following were investigated: a) the views of P.E. teachers on the basis of the independent variable, gender and independent variable place of distribution with regards to the: i) contents, ii) objectives, and iii) illustration of the book. b) The views of School Advisors / Heads of P.E. offices on the basis of the independent variable of place of distribution with regards to the: i) contents, ii) objectives, and iii) illustration of the book.The sampling was done on the basis of stratified analogical sampling. The division of population was done on the basis of the thirteen Greek regions. Schools were randomly selected from the various strata. Three questionnaires were drawn up for the purposes of the study: a) for teachers, b) for School Advisors / Heads of P.E. offices, and c) for pupils. The questionnaires were of open and closed forms. They were postally distributed to schools and were anonymous. The results were analysed using the descriptive statistical and ANOVA. 300 schools took part in the study. 410 secondary P.E. teachers (289 men and 121 women), 36 secondary school advisors / heads of P.E. (25 men, 11 women) and 1326 secondary school pupils from the first to the third years (567 boys and 759 girls) from every region of Greece, completed and returned the questionnaires.The evaluation of the P.E. Secondary text book by teachers and school advisers / heads of P.E. offices showed that: a) it was extremely good as far as content is concerned; aesthetically pleasing, scientifically valid, pedagogically suitable. In addition it favours an inter-disciplinary approach, helps pupils to utilize their earlier experiences, covers their educational needs and increases their knowledge of sport in general. b) These Assessors were also extremely positive as far as the objectives of the evaluation were concerned, believing that the pupils’ text book has clear educational objectives, that it is successful in encouraging and facilitating sports for life programmes, provides opportunities for pupils to take their own initiatives, promotes critical thinking and focuses on the correct performance of kinetic activities. c) As far as the illustration is concerned, the Assessors found that it was attractive to pupils and was directly related to the text. d) As for structure and weight, these were judged to be suitable. Finally, e), concerning the instruction given to teachers on the use of the book, it was judged that this could have been better organised and more thorough.The pupils responded as follows: a) As to content, they found it aesthetically pleasing, with attractive contents on interesting subjects and that it met their needs. b) With regard to educational suitability there were some negative responses to particular questions asked in the book, such as: “Have you tried to make up your own exercise programme?” or, “Have you taken the test to establish (your) physical condition?” c) As far as the structure of the book is concerned the pupils’ responses were positive and, d), both illustration and presentation were considered to be satisfactory.The evaluation of the teachers’ book by P.E. teachers and school advisors / office heads showed that: a) they rated it highly as far as content was concerned. 85.7% of them believe that the sports activities included in the book could be taught “Well enough” in relation to the material/technical provision of the schools. b) As far as the evaluation of the objectives, they were judged to be successful. c) Concerning the implementation of a number of objectives this group of assessors were very positive, judging that the book strengthened the possibility of enforcing them. d) They also judged that the book was well-structured, enabling the reader to quickly locate those areas in which he or she was interested. e) On the question of problems met in the teaching of the book, while most of the teachers believed that the most important of these was the lack of adequate material-technical provision, the P.E. school advisors / office heads believed that the main problem was that teachers were not being provided with sufficient information. f) As far as the instruction given to P.E. teachers is concerned they would like this to be given mainly by the authors. Generally the women teachers felt that they had more weak areas than the men, especially in football, equipped gymnastics and handball and would like to be instructed in them, while the men felt the need for instruction in folk dance, equipped gymnastics and handball. 35.4% of the P.E. teachers and 71.4% of the school advisors/heads of P.E. offices felt that this extra instruction should be compulsory.In relation to the null hypotheses given to the pupils’ text book, a) though there was no significant difference in the responses of male and female P.E. teachers to questions on: i) the evaluation of contents, and iii) evaluation of illustration, there were statistically significant differences in: ii) the evaluation of the book’s aims (F(1,373)=17,321, p=0,001). In addition significant differences between male and female teachers in reference to the independent variable of distribution place: i) in the evaluation of the textbook’s content (F(12,367) =3,562, p<0,000), ii) in the evaluation of objectives (F(12,362) =5,253, p<0,000), iii) in the evaluation of illustration and general presentation (F(12,382)=4,130, p<0,000). b). There was no significant difference between the school advisors / heads of P.E. offices either with reference to the independent variable of gender or in reference to the independent variable of place of distribution in all the comparisons of variables. c) With regard to gender the pupils did not present any significant statistical differences in their views on: i) contents and ii) aims, while there was a significant difference in their views on, iii) structure and organization (F(1,1300)=5,424, p<0,020) and iv) presentation and illustration (F(1,1300)=19,536, p<0,001). With reference to the place of distribution to pupils statistically significant differences were found in i) the evaluation of contents (F(12,1193)=24,777, p<000), ii) the evaluation of educational suitability (F(12,1178)=18,644, p<000), iii) Structure and organization (F(12,1289)=16,392, p<000), iv) presentation and illustration (F(12,1289)=11,888, p<000).Concerning gender in the appraisal of the teachers’ guidebook: a) there were statistically significant differences between male and female P.E. teachers over: i) contents (F(1,388)=12,058, p<0,001), and iii) structure and organization (F(1,393)=17,389, p<0,000) while no significant differences were found in: ii) the evaluation of objectivies. With reference to the independent variable of place of distribution, significant statistical differences were found in: i) contents (F(12,377)=3,808, p<0,00), ii) aims (F(12,367)=9,175, p<0,000), iii) structure and organization (F(12,382)=4,226, p<0,000). b) The school advisors / heads of P.E. offices showed no statistically significant differences over the independent variables of gender and place of distribution.Conclusions: From the responses of pupils, P.E. teachers and school advisors / heads of P.E. offices it seems that the books that we were investigating have an up-to-date objectives and contents that can bring into effect those objectives and teaching methods of a modern way of teaching. Those questioned made certain remarks about some of the difficulties involved in using the book, such as the difficulty in handling cards of pupils records during actual teaching, the lack of a technical-material foundation for the teaching of certain sports activities, as well as lack of information on the use of the book. We hope that their observations will be heeded by the state in the future.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Peloponesse
- Year dc:date
- 2016
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Pantazi, Diamantina
- Πανταζή, Διαμαντίνα
Subjects
dc:subject × 9Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/38667