Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Μελέτη, διαχείριση και αξιοποίηση λυμάτων με υψηλή συγκέντρωση θειικών ανιόντων

Abstract

dc:description

Increased sulfate concentrations in aqueous systems may lead to the production of toxic hydrogen sulfide, while health effects have been associated with sulfate concentrations in drinking water. Corrosion effects on industrial equipment have also been reported due to industrial wastewater sulfates, together with operational problems of anaerobic treatment units. Sulfate discharge limits have been established, as a result of these effects. The increased sulfate concentrations in several industrial processes wastewater are attributed to the use of raw materials, chemical agents and other streams with sulfur compounds content. The increased sulfate concentrations are related to the use of sulfuric acid solutions and the sulfur compounds content of auxiliary materials and other processes input. Neutralisation constitutes the most widely applied method for the treatment of inorganic wastewater, aiming at the decrease of the prohibiting sulfate concentrations, as well as the removal of acidity. The stringent discharge limits and the cost minimisation requirements have led to consideration of alternative approaches, like sulfuric solutions recovery, oxidation as a stage of intermediate pollution load decrease, biological treatment and membrane processes. Some of the applied organic wastewater treatment methods, like oxidation, act as a preliminary stage of the biological treatment units in place for the removal of the organic load of such wastewater. Sulfate-reducing bacteria are used in anaerobic treatment applications, so that problems related to increased sulfate concentrations can be overcome. The complexity of organic wastewater treatment has imposed the consideration of advanced treatment methods, like nanofiltration and electrodialysis, which also address sulfate removal.The objective of this thesis is the decrease of the sulfate content of industrial wastewater, the concentration of which would not allow their direct disposal, according to the relevant discharge limits. The selection and integration of actual field inorganic and organic wastewater samples from different production processes and of different sulfate content was regarded as innovative and highly recommendable. Three inorganic and two organic industrial wastewater samples were available. The highly acidic lead-acid battery recycling/production and steel pickling wastewater, with very high sulfate (> 10 g/L) and metal concentrations, together with the acidic sulfide mine wastewater with lower sulfate load, were the three inorganic samples. The organic samples were the acidic tannery wastewater and the alkaline alcohol production wastewater (vinasse), with medium (< 4 g/L) and high (> 8 g/L) sulfate content respectively, without significantly increased metal concentrations.The design of suitable treatment methods based on identification of materials or chemicals that could lead to sulfate concentrations decrease to acceptable levels, with the least potential cost burden of the process, constitutes an innovative aspect of this thesis. In this context, two approaches were formulated, the «Low Cost Media Utilisation» and the «Exploitable Treatment Product». According to the first one, the efficient treatment of industrial wastewater could be achieved by use of low cost materials as process input, like the solid industrial by-products of Greek origin, the further exploitation of which remains at low levels. The principle of the «Exploitable Treatment Product» approach was the efficient treatment of industrial wastewater leading to a potentially exploitable product.The first experiments were conducted on a sulfate-loaded acidic lead-acid battery wastewater sample. In the context of the «Low Cost Media Utilisation» approach, five treatment systems were examined with use of lignite fly ash, a by-product with proved anion and metal retention potential. The quantity of fly ash was the only variable (Fly Ash/Wastewater Ratio (g/mL): 1:25, 1:8.5, 1:5, 1:3.5, 1:2.5), under fixed treatment conditions (500rpm, 30min, 25oC). The separation of the solid residue from the treated wastewater was carried out by filtration. The behaviour of fly ash in relation to the decrease of sulfate concentrations was satisfactory, exceeding 80% at the systems with the highest fly ash quantities, while the decrease of metal concentrations was also significant. Precipitation by calcium ions was the main sulfate retention mechanism (X-Ray Diffraction), associated with the fly ash free calcium oxide content (CaOfree). Treatment systems of the same wastewater were also examined with use of two additional lignite fly ashes with lower CaOfree content. The lower sulfate retention percentages that were observed following the same retention mechanism confirmed the contribution of the CaOfree content of fly ash.In the context of the «Exploitable Treatment Product» approach, the initial evaluation for the identification of the optimum treatment medium and the corresponding final product led to an innovative treatment system that includes the sequential use of sodium hydroxide and barium hydroxide. The NaOH addition could enable the precipitation of the wastewater metal concentrations as hydroxides, while keeping sulfates dissolved, the retention of which would be effected by the subsequent addition of (Ba(OH)2), resulting in a solid product (BaSO4) with the least possible impurities (metals). Three treatment systems were examined, the variable of which was the quantity of the first treatment medium (NaOH) against the wastewater sulfates stoichiometry (Quantity (NaOH)/Stoichiometry: 0.7, 1.0, 1.5), without changing the quantity of Ba(OH)2 (Quantity (Ba(OH)2)/Stoichiometry: 1.0) and the treatment conditions. The separation of the solid residue from the treated wastewater was carried out by filtration. In order that the maximum possible availability of all sulphur ions as sulfates is ensured, a preliminary treatment stage was applied, including the addition of a strong oxidising agent (Η2Ο2). The objective of this preliminary stage was satisfied by the increased sulfate concentrations measured in the wastewater sample. During the first treatment stage (NaOH), the retention of the wastewater metals accomplished was very high (> 97%), while sulfates remained dissolved in the treatment systems with the higher NaOH quantities. The second treatment stage (Ba(OH)2) yielded significant sulfate retention (80%), the final concentrations of which were close to discharge limits. The positive results in the first experiments, in the context of the «Low Cost Media Utilisation» and the «Exploitable Treatment Product» approaches, led to the decision of their further evaluation for all available wastewater samples. Taking into account the contribution of the fly ash CaOfree confirmed in the «Low Cost Media Utilisation» approach, the evaluation focuses on the lignite fly ash with the highest CaOfree content (Ptolemais Plant), while a second solid industrial by-product with high calcium oxide content is also examined, the Electric Arc Furnace steel slag) in equivalent treatment systems for the three inorganic and the two organic wastewater samples. The wastewater oxidation stage with use of hydrogen peroxide is included, together with the leaching test of the treatment final solid residues, so that their disposal potential can be evaluated. The selected quantities of the treatment medium are significantly lower, formulating three new Solid/Wastewater ratios (Ratios (g/mL): 1:10, 1:16.5, 1:33.5).The oxidation stage proves to be beneficial, in terms of ensuring the highest possible sulfates availability and the oxidation of metal ions that eventually contribute to the behaviour of fly ash and slag. The highest sulfate retention percentages (> 80%) were observed during the treatment of most sulfate-loaded inorganic wastewater, with final sulfate concentrations close to discharge limits, accompanied with significant decrease of the main heavy metal concentrations. Slag yields higher sulfate retention at comparatively lower alkaline pH values. The main sulfate retention mechanism is calcium precipitation (CaSO4.2H2O - Gypsum, CaSO4.0.5H2O - Bassanite, CaSO4 - Anhydrite, Ca6Al2(SO4)3(OH)12.26H2O - Ettringite) and its progress is affected by the presence of metals that exhibited increased initial concentrations in the wastewater samples. The weight of the solid residues of the high sulfate retention treatment systems was increased compared to the initial treatment medium quantity, though less for the slag systems. Sulfate leaching of the solid residues does not prohibit their disposal, being comparatively less for the slag systems.The limited efficiency of the filtration treatment systems for the mining and the two organic wastewater samples and the identification of phases related to cementitious properties for some of them led to a new methodology within the context of the «Low Cost Media Utilisation» approach. Instead of the filtration applied for the separation of the solid residue from the treated wastewater, solidification was examined, which entails the use of higher fly ash and slag quantities and also the elimination of treatment effluents. As cementitious properties were identified in the filtration systems with the highest fly ash and slag quantities, larger quantities were selected for the solidification systems, formulating four treatment systems (Solid/Wastewater ratios (g/mL): 1:3, 1:2, 1:1.7, 1:1.5).The treatment systems of the inorganic mining wastewater with use of medium and higher slag quantities produce final solids with acceptable (EPA - 350 kPa) compressive strength that can be disposed of at inert waste landfills, without significant weight increase compared to the initial treatment medium, but after relatively increased solidification times. The use of fly ash yields higher weight increase. The main sulfate retention mechanism during the use of fly ash is precipitation that leads to calcium sulfate compounds and ettringite. Gypsum formation and hydrated iron (III) phases were identified in the slag treatment systems, attributed to the participation of the slag iron oxide content. The organic wastewater systems with slag exhibited increased solidification times and low compressive strength values, while the weight increase of the solidified fly ash products was comparatively higher. The sulfate concentrations resulting from the leaching test were lower for the slag systems, allowing the disposal in non-hazardous landfills for most solidified products. Sulfates retention takes place mainly through precipitation mechanisms that lead to the formation of gypsum and ettringite.Regarding the «Exploitable Treatment Product» approach, the sequential use of NaOH-Ba(OH)2 is examined for the wastewater samples with higher initial sulfate concentrations, the decrease of which could lead to increased final product quantities. Given the availability of sodium and hydroxyl ions in the treatment systems effluents in the first experiments, the method includes an additional cycle for the treatment of a new wastewater sample, during which the use of the first cycle effluent replaces the addition of a new NaOH solution. The treatment systems are the same with the ones examined in the first experiments, in terms of the first treatment medium (NaOH) quantity that remains the sole variable (Quantity (NaOH)/ Stoichiometry: 0.7, 1.0, 1.5) and the oxidation preliminary stage with hydrogen peroxide.After completion of the two treatment cycles for all wastewater samples, the overall sulfate retention percentages are significant (>80%) and the final sulfate concentrations meet the relevant discharge limits for the lower NaOH quantity systems. The main sulfate retention mechanism is barium precipitation, as barium sulfate is the only sulfate compound detected in the solid products of the two treatment cycles for almost all wastewater samples. Compared to the theoretically expected barium sulfate, the weight percentages of the solid products are generally higher after the first treatment cycle. After completion of both treatment cycles, the lower NaOH quantity systems yielded the highest percentages. The contribution of barium ions to the retention of carbonate ions is also significant, as the latter may affect the purity of the final solid products. High metal concentrations decrease is recorded, due to the increased pH values prevailing in most treatment cycles. The sodium and hydroxyl concentrations in the final treatment effluents would not be adequate for the efficiency of a third treatment cycle. Following the results of the «Low Cost Media Utilisation» and the «Exploitable Treatment Product» approaches, optimum sulfate retention solutions are recommended for the examined industrial wastewater. Specifically, for the Lead-Acid Battery and Pickling wastewater (SO42-> 10 g/L), the recommended approach is the «Exploitable Treatment Product» (NaOH-Ba(OH)2, Quantity (NaOH)/Stoichiometry Ratio (g/mL): 0.7, Treatment Cycles: 2). For the Mining wastewater (SO42-< 3 g/L), the recommended approach is the «Low Cost Media Utilisation» (Filtration-Slag, Solid/Wastewater Ratio (g/mL): 1/10). For the Tannery wastewater (SO42-< 4 g/L), the recommended approach is the «Exploitable Treatment Product» (NaOH-Ba(OH)2, Quantity (NaOH)/Stoichiometry Ratio (g/mL): 0.7, Treatment Cycles: 2). For Vinasse (SO42-> 8 g/L), the recommended approach is the «Low Cost Media Utilisation» (Solidification-Fly Ash, Solid/Wastewater Ratio (g/mL): 1/1.7).

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2013

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Κορκολής, Απόστολος

Subjects

dc:subject × 20

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/38674

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Κορκολής, Απόστολος. Μελέτη, διαχείριση και αξιοποίηση λυμάτων με υψηλή συγκέντρωση θειικών ανιόντων. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2013. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/38674