Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Έρευνα μέσω φασματοσκοπίας Raman της σταθερότητας δομής δύο κεραμικών υλικών ζιρκονίας Y-TZP μετά από εργαστηριακές διαδικασίες κατασκευής αποκαταστάσεων και κυκλικής φόρτισης

Abstract

dc:description

Introduction: The increasing need for more aesthetic dental restorations and to the development of CAD/Cam systems for restorations that can withstand occlusal forces at the posterior area, have led to Y-TZP zirconia ceramic materials. However crucial disadvantages of this material involve structural instability and transformation of the tetragonal grains to the monoclinic phase, with parallel increase of the grains volume. That structural transformation can be noticed in low temperatures with the presence of water and is known as low-temperature degradation, LTD. The transformation from the tetragonal to the monoclinic phase can also be activated by high temperatures or by various lab procedures such as grinding. The transformation zone is related to the failure of the restoration. If the transformation to the monoclinic phase extends not only on the surface of the zirconia ceramic but also in depth, the increase of the grains size that follows can lead to the formation of microcracks and the failure of the restoration.Purpose: The aim of this study was to identify and calculate of the monoclinic zirconia volume fraction (Vm%) using Raman spectroscopy in two different Y-TZP ceramic materials, commonly used for the fabrication of ceramic frameworks for fixed partial dentures (FPD’s).Material and methods: Two different Y-TZP ceramic materials were used: a) zirconia blocks ZrO2 with Y2O3 as stabilizer (In-Ceram YZ, Vita Zahnfabrik, Bad Sackingen, Germany) for use at a pre-sintered stage with Cerec InLab CAD/CAM system (Sirona Dental Systems GmbH, Bensheim, Germany) (groups YZ) and b) zirconia blocks (Hint-ELs TZP HIP, Hint-ELs GmbH Griesheim, Germany) used as sintered with the DentaCAD CAD/CAM system (Hint-ELs, Griesheim, Germany) (groups H) for the fabrication of three unit ceramic frameworks for FPD’s. The frameworks of all groups had an occlusal and axial wall thickness of 0,5 mm and connector dimentions of 3 Χ 3 mm between premolar and the pontic and 3 Χ 4 mm between the pontic and the molar. The mesio-distal width of the pontic was 11 mm. In total seven frameworks were fabricated using InCeram zirconia material and eight using HintELs. The frameworks were examined by using Raman spectroscopy before porcelain veneering in three different areas (occlusal O, connectors C and margins M) for the calculation of the fraction of the monoclinic phase (Vm%). Following porcelain veneering of the zirconia frameworks the fraction of the monoclinic phase (Vm%) was calculated again. Five of the InCeram ΥΖ and six Hint-ELs FPD’s were artificially aged through dynamic loading in water at a stable temperature of 37 0C with applied load of 80 N for 2.000.000 cycles at a frequency of 2 Hz (120 loads/min). A three point bending test followed with a crosshead speed of 0,5 mm/min.A Raman microscope was used operated under the following conditions: Ar+ laser (λ0=514,5 nm), 10 mW power at sample, 50X LWD objective, 2400 lines/mm grating, 1000 μm space confocal hole. In total 20 different groups for both zirconia ceramics materials were analyzed for the calculation of the fraction of the monoclinic phase (Vm%): at the surface of the ceramic frameworks (groups YZ and H), at the occlusal area (YZO, HO), at the connector area (YZC, HC) and at the marginal area (YZM, HM). After porcelain veneering the Vm% was calculated at both the external (YZE, HE) and internal (YZI, HI) areas of the zirconia frameworks. Finally the Vm% was calculated from the fractured surfaces (YZF, HF), the compressive sides of the fractured surfaces (YZFC, HFC), the middle sides (YZFM, HFM) and the tensile sides (YZFT, HFT) after cyclic loading.Results and conclusions: The results of this study were as follows:1)The percentage of the monoclinic volume that was found on the external surfaces of the zirconia frameworks was quite low (1,90%) on the Hint-ELs specimens but statistically higher than the percentage (0,15%) on the In-Ceram YZ specimens (p˂0,0001).2)The monoclinic phase that was calculated on the external surfaces for the frameworks made by both materials did not show a uniform pattern as there were found statistical differences of the Vm% between groups C, O and M (p˂0,05). At the Vita In-Ceram YZ frameworks measurements at the marginal area (group YZM, 0,28%) showed higher Vm% compared to the other two groups (YZC and YZO). On the contrary the Hint-ELs frameworks showed lower Vm% measurements on the marginal area (HM, 0,99%) compared to the other two groups (HC and HO).3)After porcelain veneering, the Raman analysis showed that the monoclinic phase was developed on both ceramic zirconia materials (p˂0,05). The Vm% was increased from 0,15% to 8,94% (group YZE) for the VITA In-Ceram YZ specimens and from 1,90% to 13,47% (group HE) for the Hint-ELs specimens.4)Confocal Raman spectroscopy showed that the Vm% in a depth of 25 μm for both Y-TZP materials was not higher that 2%.5)After cyclic loading of the veneered zirconia frameworks the fracture load for the Hint-ELs FPD’s (3851,75 N) was found statistically higher than the fractrure load of the In-Ceram YZ FPD’s (2720,05 N) (p˂0,05).6)The percentage of the monoclinic phase on the fracture surface after 3-point bending test was found to be significantly higher on the Hint-ELs ceramic (group HF, 18,52%) than the In-Ceram YZ (group YZF, 4,35%) (p˂0,05). The Vm% on the fractured surface did not show any statistically significant differences regardless of the areas (compressive, middle, tensile) (groups YZFC, HFC, YZFM, HFM, YZFT, HFT) (p˃0,05).

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2012

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Papanagiotou, Haris
  • Παπαναγιώτου, Χαράλαμπος

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/39459

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Papanagiotou, Haris; Παπαναγιώτου, Χαράλαμπος. Έρευνα μέσω φασματοσκοπίας Raman της σταθερότητας δομής δύο κεραμικών υλικών ζιρκονίας Y-TZP μετά από εργαστηριακές διαδικασίες κατασκευής αποκαταστάσεων και κυκλικής φόρτισης. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2012. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/39459