Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Η προσωρινή δικαστική προστασία στις φορολογικές διαφορές

Abstract

dc:description

This doctoral thesis attempts to approach for the first time the subject of the system of the request and implementation of temporary judicial protection in disputes with the taxation authorities in Greece, as this system is set up, and in particular since the year 2010, in the context of the ongoing budgetary and financial crisis, notably through full implementation of the Financing Memoranda. The doctoral thesis’ overall aim is to enhance the deficits of the protection of the Greek taxpayer in tax cases before the Greek administrative courts and the Greek tax administration in pursuing his legal protection at a provisional and urgent stage before settling the dispute with the relevant taxation authority on a definitive basis with the intermediation of the competent judicial authorities. For this purpose, a very high-level frontier scientific research was conducted -namely an in-depth, serious, exhaustive, transparent and independent investigation was carried out into this complex aspect of the temporary judicial protection and in addition to this, information was also drawn from other sources, as over and above theoretical texts, from all relevant documents and the most up-to-date, advanced articles, judicial texts and judgements of the competent administrative courts examining applications for temporary judicial protection in tax disputes. The process of the scientific research led us, moreover, to the combined study of the complicated legislative system and the current judicial application of the right of temporary judicial protection in tax law, in the light of the undeniable need to ensure that the objectives of the quick and efficient collection of public -mainly fiscal- revenues will be fulfilled. The above is strongly required for the achievement of the stringent budgetary targets that need to be underpinned by concrete measures which more efficiently could contribute to an increase of government revenue, a further narrowing of the general government deficit and a rigorous fiscal consolidation and restructuring of the financial sector to step up macroeconomic stability, in other words to specific objectives and commitments taken deliberately and in full awareness of the consequences by the Hellenic Republic in the context of Memoranda of Understanding. Furthermore, it was examined thoroughly the current protection of the individual ‘s fundamental right to apply for and enjoy temporary judicial protection in tax law, in particular concerning the enforcement of the aforementioned right in international law, European law and constitutional law as well, in connection with the current situation of serious economic and financial crisis, and the analysis of the exact nature and development of the contested right of temporary judicial protection of taxpayers within its institutional framework of the Financing Memoranda. After the combined study of all the collected material and the research portfolio, which required a continuous and lively dialogue in a multidisciplinary environment between the sciences of law, finance, philosophy, political science and public administration, with regard to the right of the judicial protection in the particular sense of the temporary and urgent judicial protection in the tax disputes, the doctoral thesis interlinks in the one hand, the obligations imposed by the Memoranda including the timely achievement of economic objectives through the efficient raising of the level of total tax revenue with, in the other hand, the final configuration from a procedural viewpoint of the right of the taxpayer to temporary judicial protection against the taxes and the tax penalties that are charged to them. Apart from that, in particular, the doctoral thesis concludes that due to the sword of Damocles hanging over this debate, in the shape of the major demands of the present deep economic crisis in Greece since 2010, the quick clearance of tax affairs and the acceleration of the special procedure for the recovery of public revenues, mainly the tax revenues, is now directly related to the qualitative and quantitative extent of the infringement of the right to temporary judicial protection in tax cases. The above unjustified and disproportionate restriction on the right at issue is mainly reflected in the adoption of unprecedented strict procedural conditions and legal premises on the admissibility and the validity of the application to suspend the operation of the decisions of the tax authorities in conjunction with the special too burdensome procedural status of the taxpayer while he is pursuing his permanent judicial protection with a final decision. Moreover, it was detected that the real current transformation of the contested fundamental right -that deals with the delicate economic rights and rights in property of the taxpayers- does not constitute an individual problem of the Greek legal system, but, even more importantly than that, it poses new dilemmas concerning the survival of typical institutions of the administrative and constitutional law. In addition, it is noted that as Greece is also a long-standing member of the European Union, the infringement of the right of requesting and delivering temporary judicial protection in tax cases becomes a problem of the EU legal order due to the intensity of the violation as well. That thus is contributing with a negative sign to a further regression of the European ideals and is also forming a threat to what has been achieved by the elder generations and the European idealists. The doctoral thesis also highlights the sicknesses and weaknesses in terms of the system of the temporary judicial protection in tax law as an extreme political risk-taking for the entire European project while taking into consideration the apparent lack of ability of the administrative structures of the European Union and its operational practices to oppose effectively any effort of such types of violation. In conclusion, the doctoral thesis puts forward proposals for the rescue and restructuring of the right of temporary judicial protection in tax cases, particularly towards the suggestion of legislative, and in substance political choices, in order to find a new middle way between the budgetary consolidation, which requires a security in public revenues, and the necessity of conferring substantial judicial protection to the taxpayers. After all, pointing out the decisive importance of the role of the administrative judge for complete, timely and efficient temporary judicial protection in tax law, the doctoral thesis proposes alternatives for the consolidation of the principle of the legal certainty and the stability of the tax procedural system whilst avoiding distorting effects for the taxpayers when they seek protection to the administrative justice and the security of the substance of his right. Nevertheless, as discussed in all the chapters of this doctoral thesis, it is outlined as a pioneering crucial element of the overall study that even under the current extreme economic and budgetary conditions, the limits set by the Rule of Law and the institutional underpinnings of our democracies, must not in any circumstances be exceeded.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2016

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Micheli, Panagiota
  • Μιχελή, Παναγιώτα

Subjects

dc:subject × 36

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • BY_NC_ND
Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/39592

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Micheli, Panagiota; Μιχελή, Παναγιώτα. Η προσωρινή δικαστική προστασία στις φορολογικές διαφορές. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2016. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/39592