Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Αναπνευστική λειτουργία-εργοσπιρομετρία σε μονωδούς, χορωδούς και μουσικούς πνευστών οργάνων

Abstract

dc:description

Introduction: Current studies have not yet reached any definitive conclusions regarding the impact of choir singing and professionally playing wind instruments on an individual’s respiratory function. A thorough estimation of the cardio-respiratory function of wind instrument players and opera singers, including cardiopulmonary exercise testing (ergospirometry) has not been performed yet. Objective: The purpose of this research was to investigate the respiratory function of wind instrument players, choristers and opera singers in comparison with a control group of healthy individuals. Methods: The experimental group comprised forty-four (45) men and thirty-five (35) women, of whom fifty-eight (58) people were opera singers and vocal soloists, whereas the rest twenty-two (22) were wind instrument players. The control group consisted of eighty (80) participants, who all were non-smokers, healthy individuals, matched for age and sex with the experimental group members. The spirometry was performed by the means of a dry spirometer, on the basis of the American Thoracic Society recommendations. The respiratory function was further studied through cardiopulmonary exercise testing in a group of seven (7) men and eight (8) women and compared with a control group of eight (8) men and seven (7) women. In the experimental group, all men were wind instrument players, while five (5) women were opera singers and three (3) were wind instrument players.Results: The mean age in the experimental group was 47.9 (15.5) years old for men and 46.6 (16.8) for women. There was a significant statistical difference regarding the FVC and FEV1 values (p<0.01) as well as the PEFR values (p=0.001) between the control and the experimental group. Regarding the FEV1/FVC ratio, statistically significant differences were detected only in women (p=0.001, for predicted values). In the cardiopulmonary testing study, the mean age of the control group subjects was 33.6±7.4 years, while the mean age in the experimental group was 36.0±7.7 years. Regarding the purely spirometric findings in men, the participants in the control group performed better than the wind instrument players in all the parameters, while the FEV values in the two groups marginally differed in terms of statistical significance (p = 0,046). The results obtained for women were exactly the opposite: in all spirometric values, the wind players/singers performed better than those in the control group and there was a significant statistical difference in the FEV1 values (p=0.038). Conclusion: The spirometry findings of the present study provide evidence that the professional involvement with a wind musical instrument or monody may have a beneficial impact on the respiratory function. The cardiorespiratory testing findings indicate a worse performance during exercise in male wind players/singers compared with the control group members and a slightly better performance in female wind players/singers compared with the respective members in the control group. In an attempt to interpret these apparently conflicting results, the musicians’ smoking habits (who all were regular smokers) and the mean age of the groups should be taken into account. If any noticeable differences regarding the cardiorespiratory function (i.e a clear decline) actually exist, these might become evident after many years and not at present, while any protective action of wind playing/singing may not be detected at all. The results for females could support the previous speculations about the beneficial impact of wind instrument playing or opera singing on the respiratory function, provided they are confirmed on a longitudinal basis. On the contrary, the deteriorating effect of smoking on the respiratory function may reverse any beneficial effect of wind instrument playing in men. The results are indicative of the necessity to further study the cardiorespiratory function of wind players and opera singers in large cohorts and on a long-term basis. A detailed examination of the musicians’ cardiorespiratory function may provide valuable information on how certain physical exercises could affect respiration and physical fitness. What should also be examined is whether any future treatments as well as a better respiratory function could possibly conduce to the musicians and singers’ improved performance.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2017

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Ksinopoulou, Eleni-Marina
  • Ξυνοπούλου, Ελένη-Μαρίνα

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/39902

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Ksinopoulou, Eleni-Marina; Ξυνοπούλου, Ελένη-Μαρίνα. Αναπνευστική λειτουργία-εργοσπιρομετρία σε μονωδούς, χορωδούς και μουσικούς πνευστών οργάνων. University of Thessaly (UTH), 2017. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/39902