Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Η ενδοδερμική ραφή στον σκύλο: συγκριτική μελέτη με τις απλές χωριστές ραφές και διερεύνηση του ρόλου της σύνθεσης και της διαμέτρου του ράμματος
Abstract
dc:descriptionSuturing of the skin is the most common surgical intervention, as at the termination of most surgical procedures the surgeon sutures the cut skin edges. It is generally considered of low difficulty, especially when performed in clear incisions made by scalpel blade. However, despite the fact that surface scars are considered by the surgeon to be of secondary importance to the successful outcome of any surgical intervention, the animals' owners usually judge the overall quality of a surgical procedure by its visible component i.e. the quality of the skin closure.The role of sutures in primary wound closure is to approximate tissue edges, with the ultimate goal of achieving a functional and aesthetically acceptable scar. Many novel suture materials are described in the literature for their specific benefit in wound closure. The most commonly used technique of skin closure is the simple interrupted suture pattern, whilst the continuous intradermal suture pattern has been latterly popularized as an aesthetically superior method of skin closure.However, controlled studies comparing the continuous intradermal with the simple interrupted suture pattern have not been performed. Few studies aimed to assess these suturing techniques mainly by relying on clinical evaluation of the sutured wounds either by the human patient or by the surgeon, without the use of objective criteria or histological evaluation. Furthermore, there are minimal studies on the effect of suture material used and no study on the effect of the suture's diameter on skin healing and scar formation.The aim of the present study was to compare the aesthetic, clinical and histopathological outcome of: a) the continuous intradermal with the simple interrupted suture pattern used for skin closure, b) the polyglecaprone 25 with the polyglytone 6211 suture used for intradermal suture pattern and c) the 3/0 with the 4/0 polyglecaprone 25 suture used for intradermal suture pattern.The study was conducted in two phases, the second taking place 6 months after the first one. Ten purpose-bred neutered male Beagles, aged 2-4 years and weighting 12.5-15.5 kg were included in both phases of the study.In the first experiment, a 12 cm long incision was made on the skin of the outer surface of each animal's both thighs, parallel to the femur, which was sutured by either continuous intradermal pattern with buried knots or by simple interrupted pattern. For both patterns, 3/0 polyglecaprone 25 suture was used.In the second experiment, a 12 cm long incision was made on the skin of the outer surface of the same animals' both thighs, parallel to the femur, 7 cm anteriorly to the incision of the first experiment. The incisions were sutured by continuous intradermal pattern with either 4/0 polyglecaprone 25 or 4/0 polyglytone 6211 suture.The aesthetic appearance of the wounds was blindly evaluated by two surgeons by assessing wounds’ photographs taken on the 7th, 14th, 28th, 180th, 360th, 730th and 1095th postoperative day (po.d.).Clinical evaluation was performed on the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th, 7th, 8th, 9th, 10th, 11th, 12th, 13th, 14th, 15th, 18th, 21st, 25th, 28th, 32nd, 35th, 42nd, 49th, 60th, 90th, 120th, 150th, 180th, 240th, 300th, 365th, 730th and 1095th po.d. The following parameters were evaluated by the same investigator: oedema of the skin at the incision site, erythema, scar width, abscesscation, exudation, comedones, scar pigmentation, hypotrichosis, missing of stitches, wound dehiscence, and cross scaring formation.Histopathological evaluation of the healing process was performed on the 7th, 14th, 28th, 180th, 365th, 730th (in 5 of the 10 animals) and 1095th (in 5 of the 10 animals) po.d. The following parameters were evaluated: necrosis, epithelial gap, oedema, inflammation, presence of suture, tissue reaction around the suture, epidermal thickness, scar width, collagen production, presence of fibroblasts, and angiogenesis. In order to compare the differences between the techniques over time, the experimental period was divided into 4 time periods: Time period A (1st-28th po.d.), when inflammation, debridement, proliferation and repair take place, time period Β (32nd-60th po.d.), when the early stage of maturation takes place, time period C (90th-300th po.d.), when the median stage of maturation takes place, and time period D (365th-1095th po.d.), when the late stage of maturation takes place.In order to find a representative score for the aesthetic, the clinical and the histopathological evaluation, at each time period, separate scores of the parameters of each category were added.Furthermore, in order to compare the techniques during time, the total representative score of each technique was evaluated, on the 7th, 14th, 28th, 180th and 365th po.d, by adding each time the aesthetic, clinical and histopathological scores.In general, skin healed normally without any major complications. The overall conclusions or this study are:1. Irrespective of the technique used, the aesthetic, clinical and histopathological appearance (score) of the incisions improves over time. The same applies to the total appearance of the incisions.2. The aesthetic and histopathological differences between the techniques are major at the early stages, i.e. during the first month, of wound healing, but become minor over time. On the contrary, clinical differences persist even after a long time period.3. The most substantial complication, i.e. wound dehiscence, was noticed only with the simple interrupted suture pattern.4. The clinical appearance of the intradermal suture pattern is initially very good, but it worsens during the 4th to 8th postoperative week, and improves again afterwards.5. The fact that polyglytone 6211 suture is absorbed earlier than polyglecaprone 25 suture does not seem to have a positive effect on wound healing and scar appearance.6. Comparing the techniques used in this study, the intradermal pattern with 4/0 polyglecaprone 25 suture seems to be the best, followed by the intradermal pattern with 4/0 polyglytone 6211 suture, and this by the intradermal pattern with 3/0 polyglecaprone 25 suture; the simple interrupted pattern with 3/0 polyglecaprone 25 suture seems to be the worst. The differences between the first two techniques are due to the different suture material, between the first two and the third technique are probably due to the different suture diameter, and between the three first and the last technique due to the different suture pattern.7. The intradermal suture pattern, sutures of small diameter (4/0) and polyglecaprone 25 suture should be considered better choices than the simple interrupted suture pattern, sutures of larger diameter (3/0) and polyglytone 6211 suture for skin closure in the dog.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2014
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Gouletsou, Pagona
- Γκουλέτσου, Παγώνα
Subjects
dc:subject × 12Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/40108