Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Numerical & theoretical study of the static response of coated microbubbles subject to uniform and distributed load: application on the estimation of the shell elastic properties

Abstract

dc:description

The static response of contrast agent microbubbles is investigated by means of theoretical and numerical formulation. The shell coating is biocompatible and provides mechanical strength, thus renders the microbubbles as excellent enhancers in medical imaging and drug delivery vectors (in vivo). Characterization of shell parameters, namely stretching and bending moduli, is of great importance for the above applications. Two major families of coated microbubbles are normally employed, namely those coated by polymeric and phospholipid shells. The former type of shells is characterized by larger elasticity modulus in comparison with phospholipid shells. Lately, the atomic force microscope (AFM) has emerged as a powerful tool for estimation of the above properties through force-deformation curves. In this context, one of the major targets of the present doctoral dissertation is the modelling of the static response of coated microbubbles as they are compressed by the AFM cantilever. In addition, a methodology is proposed for the estimation of the elastic properties for both types of shells.Two theoretical and numerical models have been developed in order to describe the contact between the cantilever and the shell. The cantilever is considered as a flat and rigid surface, while the shell as an elastic membrane and the encapsulated gas is treated as compressible. In the first model is a simple representation of the loading, which is assumed as a point at the end of the contact line, while in the second the shell is loaded by the disjoining pressure as a result of the thinning of the liquid phase between the shell and the cantilever. The degree of thinning describes the resulting force between the two surfaces, attraction or repulsion, depending on their relevant position. In any case, the normal and tangential force balances along with the isothermal compression are solved via finite elements. The elastic tensions are described by appropriate constitutive laws, the disjoining pressure by the derivative of an adhesive potential and the deformations are considered as axisymmetric. Benchmark calculations against analytical results verify the validity of modeling. The results of each model are presented in force-deformation curves, where the possibility of buckling near the contact is investigated. In the first model, the response is initially linear (Reissner regime) and when buckling takes place (Pogorelov regime) the response in non-linear curved downwards. The linear solution is still an option after the buckling point, but has higher energy than the buckling solution. A third non-linear curved upwards regime is detected in relative high values of deformation in the post-buckling solution, as a result of significant increase of the internal pressure in comparison with shell rigidity. The above regimes are recovered also in the intermolecular forces model. In both models, the dimensionless bending stiffness, kb , which defines the relative importance of bending rigidity in comparison with stretching, specify the position of the bifurcation point. Microbubbles coated with polymer have usually a relative small dimensionless bending resistance kb~10^(-5), which explains the buckling behavior of experimental AFM force-deformation curves, while in shell covered with lipid the dimensionless bending resistance is higher kb~10^(-3) , thus buckling is not the energetically favorable solution, because the resistance to bending is high. In addition, when adhesion is strong, the local buckling is translated to higher values of force and deformation or in extreme cases postponed, because the shell is in significant attraction with the cantilever, thus tensile tensions are developed which prevent buckling. The internal pressure tends to increase when surface tension is accounted for, while the opposite happens when the shell has residual compressive tensions, which also tend to low the buckling point. The above aspects are studied via parametric analysis.In addition, upon appropriate modification of the equilibrium equations, a similar study is also conducted for free microbubbles, which are not covered with elastic material and they response is governed by the surface tension and the internal pressure. In this case, buckling was not detected, as it was expected, and their response in force-deformation curve is almost quadratic. This study is usufull for nano-bubbles, which usually are not covered.Employing the analytical equations for the linear and non-linear regimes, Reissner and Pogorelov, respectively, on the experimental force-deformation curves of microbubbles coated with polymer the Young modulus and the shell thickness are calculated simultaneously. The results are in very good agreement with the experimental estimates. In addition, the force –deformation curves of microbubbles covered with lipid monolayer are almost linear and in high values of deformation a regime dominated by the gas pressure is detected. Combination of Reissner equation with a Lulevich et al and Shanahan analytical results can provide the area dilatation and the bending moduli. Perfoming simulations with both models the experimental response is recovered.The second problem that the present thesis studies is the buckling of the above microbubbles subject to a uniform and normal static load in order to construct the bifurcation diagrams for both types of materials. The same equations are solved, but the loading is known and it is applied across the generative curve. Benchmark calculations against similar numerical calculations and recovering the theoretical buckling load verify the validity of modeling.In this problem, as the pressure increases, the shell is compressed, but remains spherical, which is considered as the basic solution. When the load reaches the buckling threshold, the jacobian matrix has one more unstable eigenvalue, where disturbing the spherical shape with the corresponding eigenvector, the buckling curve emerges, with shapes that are asymmetric or symmetric with respect to the equator.In polymers, when the first instability is dominated by an asymmetric eigenmode, the solution evolves only subcritically. The second instability on the spherical solution is dominated by a symmetric mode and evolves transcritically. The shapes corresponding to supercritical symmetric branch are prolate, while the shapes of the subcritical symmetric branch are oblate. On the contrary, when the first instability is dominated by symmetric mode is still a transcritical bifurcation, but the second instability on the sphere, characterized by an asymmetric mode; it was not possible to evolve. However, the subcritical symmetric branch very soon exhibits a new unstable eigenvalue, which lead to an asymmetric branch. In any case, the subrcritical branches as evolve exhibit a limit point, which turns the solution to loads, which are higher than the buckling threshold. In the regime after the limit point, each branch has one less unstable eigenvalue in comparison with the bifurcation point and additionally their total energy is less than the sphere. The volume is reduced significantly and the poles tend to form a contact zone. In the microbubbles covered with phospholipid, the above trend is similar, but when the first instability is dominated by symmetric shapes, the asymmetric solution is not evolving from the sphere, but either from the symmetric branch.In the context of the present thesis, parametric analysis was contacted in order to understand how the dimensionless bending modulus, kb , defines the shape of the first instability. The first instability for a microbubble with a relative small kb is symmetric with prolate and oblate shapes, but as the dimensionless bending stiffness decreases the first instability is asymmetric, thus forming one dimple of indentation in order to relax the compressive tensions. Decreasing further the one dimple is not enough for the relaxation of the tensions, thus a second dimple is formed. It should pointed out, that when both post buckling solutions coexist in the regime of relative small volumes and before the contact zone, the asymmetric is always the solution with the lower energy. In addition, in shell covered with lipid, where the gas compression is important in comparison with the elasticity, the limit point of the subcritical branch leads to sharp change of the required loading, without significant reduction of the volume, while in polymers after the limit point the volume must be reduced significantly in order to form a contact line.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2017

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Lytra, Alkmini
  • Λύτρα, Αλκμήνη

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/40137

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Lytra, Alkmini; Λύτρα, Αλκμήνη. Numerical & theoretical study of the static response of coated microbubbles subject to uniform and distributed load: application on the estimation of the shell elastic properties. University of Thessaly (UTH), 2017. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/40137