Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Διαχείριση υδατικών πόρων: υπό συνθήκες έλλειψης νερού

Abstract

dc:description

The objective of this Thesis was to develop and validate a methodological and computational framework for: (a) the systematic analysis of water management options and water management plans to reduce the vulnerability of water systems; (b) their assessment on the basis of technical, environmental, and socio-economic indicators; (c) the estimation and the allocation of the total cost of water services to individual water uses, and (c) the formulation and analysis of alternative mechanisms for the adequate recovery of the total cost of water services.The Thesis focuses on areas facing water scarcity. In such areas, the peak water demands, in combination with limited freshwater availability, often require the development of high-cost infrastructure that is almost exclusively used during peak periods. In addition, the uncertainty associated with climate variability and future climate changes requires the development of flexible solutions, with ancillary social, environmental and economic benefits.The developed framework is based on the principles of Integrated Water Resources Management and of the Water Framework Directive (2000/60/EC). In 2000, the Water Framework Directive introduced integrated water management at the river basin level, and called for the definition of environmental objectives and suitable measures to achieve good ecological status of water bodies across the EU. A key element of the WFD was the introduction of economic principles and the use of economic tools as means to achieve the set-out environmental objectives. Currently, the WFD runs its 2nd implementation cycle, and the second River Basin Management Plans (RMBPs) have been completed in most EU Member States. In Greece, the development of the first RBMPs was completed in 2015, and their revision was initiated in June 2016. Despite progress made, in Greece and in the EU there is substantial delay in the implementation of Art. 9 (i.e. in achieving the adequate recovery of the total cost of water services and in using water pricing as a means to achieve the Directive’s objectives). The main reasons behind this delay are the unclear definition and ways of estimating the different components of water service costs (particularly environmental and resource costs), difficulties in correctly allocating costs to individual use(r)s and the lack of metering systems for water abstraction and use, particularly in the agricultural sector. The computational framework of the Thesis includes a Decision Support System, the WSM DSS. The WSM DSS is a hydro-economic tool that can be used to simulate the allocation of water resources under conditions of water scarcity. Hydro-economic tools and modelling frameworks comprise a distinct category of models that combine technical and economic approaches for the modelling and analysis of water systems. The WSM DSS is a simulation tool, which runs at a monthly time step. Through its modular structure, the DSS integrates sub-models for the estimation of water availability and demand, the assessment of water balances, the economic analysis of water systems, and the evaluation of management interventions and integrated water management plans. The main features of the WSM DSS, which differentiate it from other, similar tools, entail: (a) the assessment of the different components of the total cost of water services, using different methods for the estimation of environmental costs according to the objectives of the assessment and data availability; (b) the allocation of costs to individual water use(r)s on the basis of the ‘polluter-pays’ principle, which allows for the formulation and analysis of alternative pricing schemes; (c) the non-static consideration of water demand, which is useful for assessing the impact that price changes may have on the water balance; (d) the assessment of sustainability indicators for the water system, which can be used to cross-compare different scenarios, water management options and integrated plans. Similarly to other modelling frameworks, the modelling of water systems in the WSM DSS is based on their schematization in terms of ‘nodes’ and ‘links’, whereby ‘nodes’ represent water uses, supply sources, treatment facilities and ‘links’ stand for the interconnections between nodes. At the level of individual nodes and links the DSS assesses water availability, demand, flows and eventually overall water balance, environmental and economic indicators, which can be used to compare and evaluate the performance of individual measures and integrated management plans. The methodological framework developed in the Thesis refers to the formulation and evaluation of water management measures and integrated plans in areas facing water scarcity, and is based on the EU recommendations for the development of River Basin Management Plans in the framework of the WFD. The methodological framework comprises four stages. The first Stage involves the definition of the modelling baseline for the analysis, the formulation of quantitative targets and the selection of appropriate indicators for the analysed water system. The second Stage concerns the formulation of scenarios and the definition, simulation and evaluation of individual water management options for achieving the targets initially set out. At the third Stage, and depending on the evaluation results for the individual measures, alternative water management plans are formulated, simulated and evaluated. The final Stage concerns the definition of quantitative targets for full cost recovery and the analysis of alternatives for their achievement. The defined cost recovery targets are used to define a set of preliminary average water supply prices, which, in turn, affect water demand and the size and/or timing of interventions included in the integrated water management plans. The same indicators are used throughout the assessment of measures and plans and include: (a) effectiveness, expressed as the sustainability index for water demand coverage for individual water uses, and calculated on the basis of statistical criteria for reliability, resilience and vulnerability, (b) external environmental costs incurred due to the pollution or overabstraction from water bodies; (c) economic assessment indicators for individual water uses (economic benefit-to-financial cost ration and total economic value from water uses); (d) economic assessment indicators for the entire water system (economic benefit-to-total cost ratio and social welfare surplus from water use). So far, the methodological framework and the WSM DSS developed in this Thesis have been applied to 12 Case Studies in Greece, Cyprus, Italy, Portugal, Israel and Egypt. The Thesis presents relevant results for two Case Studies, for the water systems of Syros and Paros, Greece.The Case Study for Syros refers to the application of Stages A and B of the methodology, towards the assessment of individual water management measures for the adaptation of the water system to long-term (50 years) climate changes and socio-economic developments. Measures comprise technical solutions for water supply enhancement (desalination and water reuse), traditional measures for water demand management (such as cisterns for rainwater harvesting) and restrictions of groundwater abstractions to develop strategic reserves for use during droughts. Individual measures are assessed for combinations of climate projections and socio-economic scenarios. Results illustrate that the most effective solutions would be desalination and water reuse. Rainwater harvesting can also improve the resilience of the water system, particularly for crop irrigation. The use of treated wastewater directly for irrigation or for groundwater recharge also has positive effects on economic terms, and could possibly be the only measure that can sustain the agricultural sector in light of climate change. Long-term positive impacts are also calculated for temporary restrictions to groundwater use, while economic impacts are low. On the contrary, rainwater harvesting is not assessed as cost-effective overall, particularly due to high implementation costs in relation to impacts on the total water balance.The case study for Paros refers to the application of the entire methodological framework for assessing water management measures and integrated plans for a mid-term time horizon (up to 2030). In total, seven (7) measures were assessed, enhancing either water supply or efficiency in water use (water network unifications, desalination, new boreholes, run-off exploitation, water saving in the domestic sector and tourism, improvement of irrigation methods and distribution network rehabilitation). Results indicated that water management planning cannot be based on one type of interventions only. Desalination and run-off exploitation can be effective in meeting water demand and improving environmental sustainability, but the high financial costs limit their cost-effectiveness. As a result, such supply enhancement measures should be combined with other, smaller-scale technical and non-technical solutions which improve the efficiency of the overall system (e.g. network unifications, small-scale options for run-off exploitation and distribution network replacement). On the basis of these results, two alternative water management plans were formulated, one referring to water supply enhancement and the second focusing mainly on water efficiency improvements. The preliminary (i.e. without cost recovery) evaluation of the two plans showed that the second water management plan is more economically efficient, combining lower financial and environmental costs and higher economic benefits for the agricultural sector. The formulation of schemes towards adequate cost recovery aimed at the full recovery of financial costs and the partial recovery of external environmental and resource costs, on the basis of volumetric fees. The impact of price changes on water demand was assessed on the basis of elasticity values from the pertinent literature. On the basis of the final results it was evident that, despite the small price increase, cost recovery had positive impacts both on the water balance and on the economic and environmental indicators. Overall, the Thesis contributes to the development of a holistic and integrated methodology for water management planning for a medium to long-term time perspective, considering both climate change and socio-economic development scenarios. The combination of a technical and economic approach, which is the basis of the developed methodology and of the WSM DSS, allows assessing the productivity of water use and sets the basis for selecting suitable water management measures. On practical terms, the Thesis contributes to the application of Art. 9 of the Water Framework Directive, which faces several implementation issues both across Europe and in Greece, as well as to the assessment of potential measures for adapting to climate change and mitigating climate-related risks.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2017

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Manoli, Eleni
  • Μανώλη, Ελένη

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • BY
Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/40350

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Manoli, Eleni; Μανώλη, Ελένη. Διαχείριση υδατικών πόρων: υπό συνθήκες έλλειψης νερού. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2017. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/40350