Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Μελέτη της διαδικασίας λήψης νοσηλευτικών κλινικών αποφάσεων σε μονάδες εντατικής θεραπείας

Abstract

dc:description

Introduction: Clinical decision-making is considered a core process of clinicalsciences, as it involves deliberate management of information engaged in solvingclinical problems. However, no research evidence exists with regard to Greekintensive care nurses’ clinical decision-making practices.Aim: The identification of clinical decisions made by nurses in Intensive Care Units(ICU) of Greece, the investigation of the decision-making process and theinvestigation of factors that influence them.Methods: The study employed a mixed - methods approach and was conducted inthree phases. During phase I, content analysis of daily entries of clinical decisionsrecorded during nursing work by 23 purposefully selected intensive care nurses wascarried out. During phase II, four focus groups with 22 purposefully selected ICUnurses were used and content analysis was also performed on discussion transcripts.In phase III, a descriptive, cross-sectional design of correlation comparisons wasapplied in a convenient sample of ICU nurses (n=381). Participants filled out aquestionnaire consisted of: a) demographic, professional and working features, b) theshortened version of Nursing Decision Making Instrument (NDMI_sv) by Lauri &Salantera (2002), which was comprised of 24 items and its total score was between24-120 and c) a newly developed 60-item questionnaire evaluating “FactorsInfluencing Nurses’ Decision-Making” (F.I.N.DE.M), which was scored between 60-300. SPSS v17.0 and AMOS were used for the statistical analysis.Results: Eight categories of nursing clinical decisions emerged in phase I includingdecisions related to: 1) evaluation, 2) diagnosis, 3) prevention, 4) intervention, 5)communication with patients or/and their families, 6) patient information seeking, 7)clinical priorities setting, 8) communication with ICU health care professionals. PhaseII data analysis demonstrated that nurses’ clinical decision-making process consists ofsix stages: a) recognition of the need for a decision, b) collection of information, c)data processing, d) planning of action, e) choice of action and f) feedback. It has alsohighlighted that ICU nurses can make clinical judgments by means of: 1) analyticthought, 2) intuitive thought, and 3) combination of both analytic and intuitivethought. The aforementioned cognitive process is grounded on Hammond’s CognitiveContinuum theoretical framework (1980). Factors that influence nursing decisionswere coded into three core categories: 1) task factor, 2) decision-maker factor and 3)context factor. Quantitative data analysis of phase III showed that most clinicaldecisions typically involve both analytic and intuitive thought (total score=71.6±5.2 inNDMI_sv scale). Multiple linear regression analysis demonstrated that the factors which correlate with the choice of cognitive decision-making strategy are theeducational level (p=0.041), ICU nursing staffing level (p=0.001) and clinicalexperience (p=0.003). Exploratory and confirmatory factor analysis of F.I.N.DE.Mvariables indicated an 8-dimensional model that explained 51.8% of the totalvariance:1) task complexity & task conditions, 2) knowledge & knowledgeawareness, 3) accountability, 4) attributes of ICU management, 5) knowing thepatient, 6) attractive ICU work environment, 7) patient’s characteristics, and 8) clearprofessional responsibilities. Among participants task complexity & task conditionswere negatively associated with high educational level (p=0.006); decision-maker’sknowledge and knowledge awareness were valued most by nurses with a great deal ofICU experience (p<0.001); nurses’ accountability with nursing staffing level(p=0.042) and their clinical experience (p<0.001); no correlations were foundbetween attributes of ICU management and decision-maker’s characteristics; knowingthe patient was associated with low nursing staffing (p=0.034) and clinical experience(p=0.001); attractive work environment with ICU level (p=0.028); patients’characteristics with nursing staffing level (p=0.021) and nursing ICU experience(p<0.001) and clear professional responsibilities with educational level (p=0.002) andICU staffing levels (p=0.05).Conclusions: Intensive care nurses make multiple clinical decisions that seem toinvolve both analytic and intuitive thought through a six-stage decision-makingprocess. Knowledge and knowledge awareness, accountability, clear professionalresponsibilities and “knowing the patient” are considered as the most influentialfactors by ICU nurses.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2014

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Karra, Vassiliki
  • Καρρά, Βασιλική

Subjects

dc:subject × 12

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/40369

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Karra, Vassiliki; Καρρά, Βασιλική. Μελέτη της διαδικασίας λήψης νοσηλευτικών κλινικών αποφάσεων σε μονάδες εντατικής θεραπείας. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2014. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/40369