Back to search

Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)

Advertising creativity: a friction point between advertising agencies and clients

Abstract

dc:description

The present dissertation aims at investigating the different perceptions and approaches of advertising agencies and clients, regarding advertising creativity and its dimensions. Their perception of agreement (PoAg) on what constitutes advertising creativity (meaning in what extent the two parties of interest believe they agree on the concept of advertising creativity) is another point of investigation. The influence of this perception of agreement on key elements describing the agency-client relationship (trust, commitment, satisfaction and conflict) is also examined. The review of relevant literature suggests there is a bulk of research on advertising creativity, exploring its dimensions and the perceptions that individuals from different backgrounds hold regarding advertising creativity (indicatively: White and Smith 2001; Koslow, et al. 2003; El Murad and West 2004; Smith et al. 2007; Lehnert 2013). However, it is interesting to note that extant research examining advertising creativity in the broader context of ad agency–client relationship is markedly scarce. There are few studies investigating divergent beliefs from both sides of the relationship (indicatively: Michell 1984; Wackaman et al. 1987; Michell et al. 1992). It is further observed that, to the best of the author’s knowledge, there appear to be no prior attempts at examining the perception of agreement (of both ad agency and client) on what constitutes advertising creativity as a single variable or regarding trust, commitment, and satisfaction (as key components of this relationship). Nonetheless, the influence of creativity on the agency-client relationship is a topic meriting investigation, given that previous research has pointed out that different perspectives on what constitutes advertising creativity may cause conflict between ad agencies and clients (Beard 1996, 1999). The term “advertising creativity” is widely referred within the literature, but there has been no consensus on a single definition of the term by the authors. It has been variously referred to as something novel, divergent from the norm, unique, original, meaningful, value added, piece of art etc. (indicatively: West et al. 2003; Smith and Yang 2004). This dissertation follows a more holistic view of advertising creativity following Koslow et al. (2003), who suggest three major dimensions of advertising creativity: originality (novel, different, etc.), strategy (relevant, adequate, etc.) and artistry (piece of art, well-crafted, etc.). Following the statement that ad creativity is a key issue on agency performance that reflects on the relationship between ad agency and client, it is theoretically proposed that the different perceptions each part has will have an effect on their relationship. Creating long-term relationships requires that clarity exists concerning the dimensions (factors) contributing to the establishment of a relationship. Consistent with the above statement, in the present study, it is theorized that trust, commitment, satisfaction and conflict are key elements in relation exchanges. This theoretical proposition also derives from the commitment-trust theory of relationship marketing which indicates that commitment and trust are key factors in on-going exchange relations (indicatively: Morgan and Hunt 1994; Grayson and Ambler 1999). Satisfaction in a relationship is considered in the marketing literature as an important result of a marketing relationship (indicatively: Johnson and Grayson 2005; Geyskens et al. 1999; Kumar et al. 1992), and as a key component of relationship as well (indicatively: Theron and Terblanche 2010; Anderson and Narus 1990). Conflict in the relationship represents the overall level of disagreement in the working partnership (indicatively: Anderson and Narus 1990; Kumar et al. 1992; Labahn and Kohli 1997). Following the Literature Review and the Theoretical Background, Research Questions, reflecting the scope and the objectives of the study, are also presented and guide hypotheses formulation. It is hypothesized that perception of agreement on what constitutes advertising creativity positively influences trust, commitment and satisfaction, while it negatively influences conflict. To test the hypotheses, quantitative research in the form of a survey using a questionnaire was conducted. The data collection derived from a census regarding the ad agencies, and from a convenience sample regarding the clients. Prior to questionnaire design, six in depth interviews were conducted with high positioned individuals from both sides of the sample, so that the questionnaire will be more complete and adjusted to the Greek context and the requirements of the present dissertation. The questionnaire contained existing scales to assess the key constructs, as well as two open-ended questions regarding definitions of advertising creativity. A qualitative analysis was conducted in order to analyze answers to the two open-ended questions of the final questionnaire. Quantitative data was analyzed statistically, using techniques to assess the reliability and dimensionality of the scales (Cronbach alpha, KMO and Bartlett’s test, Principal Components Analysis) and t-tests, correlations, linear and multiple regression and mediation analysis were used to test the hypotheses. The findings of this study contribute to a better understanding of how agencies and clients perceive advertising creativity and in what extent the involved parties believe that they agree on what constitutes advertising creativity. Simultaneously, the results offer additional insight about how major constructs of their relationship such as trust, commitment and satisfaction can affect or be affected from their perception of agreement on what constitutes advertising creativity. The role of conflict is also investigated in this study and its interaction with the aforementioned variables was tested as well. Regarding the definition of creativity, the qualitative data revealed that participants from both groups deliver definitions which fall under the three dimensions provided by the literature: originality, strategy and artistry. However, both groups underlined mainly the strategy dimension. Findings also indicated that, as hypothesized, there were notable differences between the perceptions of executives in advertising agencies and their counterparts on the side of the client, as suggested by Michell (1984) and Hirshsman (1989). Nonetheless, these differences regarded only the dimensions of originality and strategy; perceptions of creativity in terms of artistry were not found to differ significantly. Findings regarding perception of agreement on what constitutes advertising creativity between the involved parties seemed to be quite similar. Ad agencies and clients tend to believe that they share common beliefs on what constitutes advertising creativity but as revealed from the analysis of the open-ended questions, in reality their perceptions regarding creativity actually differ.From the ad agencies side results indicated that indeed trust and commitment are positively associated, confirming previous findings (Moorman et al. 1992; Grayson and Ambler 1999). Surprisingly enough from the clients’ side the corresponding hypothesis is not supported and shows a negative correlation between trust and commitment. Perception of agreement on what constitutes advertising creativity regarding ad agencies seemed to have no significant correlation with commitment, but for clients’ side does have a positive effect. Commitment indicated a strong influence on satisfaction according to the results from ad agencies, but for clients trust and commitment designated a negative correlation with satisfaction. It is important to consider, however, that all relationships are not likely to display similar characteristics. Concerning advertising agencies, perception of agreement does have a positive effect on satisfaction. From clients’ perspective, perception of agreement regarding the concept of advertising creativity has negative correlation with satisfaction. As far as ad agencies are concerned, trust and commitment do have a negative correlation with conflict but overall only trust can be said that influences conflict in the relationship. Commitment plays no significant role on conflict. On the other hand, from the clients’ point of view both trust and commitment have negative influence on conflict. Overall it is also believed, in line with Geyskens et al. (1999) that conflict seems quite distinct from the other constructs of relationship. Both ad agencies and clients seemed to agree on negative influence of conflict on satisfaction, as indicated from previous literature (indicatively: Michell 1984; Anderson and Narus 1990; Beard 1999). Concerning ad agencies and clients’ point of view, perception of agreement does have a negative influence on conflict. Trust was shown to mediate the relationship between perception of agreement on what constitutes advertising creativity and conflict, regarding ad agencies. On the contrary, commitment did not meet the criteria of the mediation, thus commitment could not be considered as mediator between PoAg and conflict. Regarding the clients side, opposite findings were reported, with commitment mediating the effect of PoAg on conflict, while trust did not. The results of this study must be examined within the context of their limitations. Several restrictions, including the nature and size of the sample, measures, variables and constructs, should be taken into consideration when interpreting the study’s results and developing future research to extend and expand its scope. However, this study integrates the existing research on advertising agency–client relationships with recent research in marketing into a comprehensive theoretical framework. The set of interrelationships specified, tested, and supported between factors, such as advertising creativity, perception of agreement on what constitutes advertising creativity, trust, commitment, satisfaction and conflict and clarified certain intricacy of advertising agency–client relationships. This study’s outcomes have direct impact on advertising agencies-clients relationship and cooperation. Reporting this relationship, between ad agencies and clients will be also useful in order to understand other similar relations. Concluding the abstract of this dissertation, it should be noted that the present dissertation is undertaken in the Greek context. The deep crisis which has hit the last five years the country has its repercussions in every economic aspect of the everyday life. Unavoidable had also a serious impact in the ad agency-client relationship, while at the same time shaped the framework, in which this research effort had to be executed. It worked as a magnifying glass which made clear friction points of a very sensitive relationship. The ad agency-client relationship was influenced by various factors among them the most important is the competition for finding scarce resource for operating their businesses. In this direction, as primary concern for the development, and maintaining this relationship, is to understand the different views and perceptions of the individuals involved on key issues of their relationship.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
Year dc:date
2015

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Zotou, Athina
  • Ζώτου, Αθηνά

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/40531

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Zotou, Athina; Ζώτου, Αθηνά. Advertising creativity: a friction point between advertising agencies and clients. Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB), 2015. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/40531