Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
Implementation process success: the role of employee consensus and context
Abstract
dc:descriptionStrategy implementation process is a research domain with important implications to individuals, firms and societies. However, it has received limited attention and existing knowledge is fragmented across management disciplines. This lack of research relative to its importance may be attributed to the inherent complexity of the implementation process, the lack of valid measures to assess its elements, the impact of various factors that influence this process, its outcomes and the difficulty to design large scale research to acquire such information. To address the calls for more research on strategy implementation, this thesis initially presents a thorough review of prior studies on strategy implementation. Such systematic review helped to identify major gaps in the literature and then to propose and empirically test a model of strategy implementation that integrates multiple streams of research (e.g., TMT consensus, organizational politics, implementation strategies, environmental constraints). Specifically, this thesis focuses on the role of four implementation strategies (i.e., edict, participation, intervention, and persuasion) on different measures of implementation success (i.e., implementation speed, non-financial performance, quality of the implementation process, perceived implementation success). It also highlights the role of employee consensus (i.e., the shared understanding and commitment to a strategic decision among employees or groups within a company) as the main mediating mechanism through which implementation strategies result in successful implementation outcomes. In addition, organizational politics and TMT consensus are proposed as moderators on the implementation strategies-employee consensus relationship and indirectly on implementation success. However, given the limited theory and the difficulty to understand the complex nature of strategy implementation, a qualitative study (16 interviews with CEOs or members of the TMT) was initially conducted to refine the conceptual model, extend existing theory, and gain important insights and arguments to support the underlying hypotheses. This qualitative study aimed to develop an updated account of how top executives perceive and pursue strategic implementation, identify whether implementation strategies as a starting base and employee consensus as an explanatory mechanism increase the likelihood of achieving strategy implementation success, and understand in what ways organizational politics and TMT consensus influence the effectiveness of implementation strategies. The outcome of this process led to the formulation of twelve hypotheses. However, the lack of an established measure to assess implementation strategies led to the development and validation of a four-dimensional measure of implementation strategies comprising of twenty-one items. Results indicated that this four-dimensional measure is valid and reliable. Then, a quantitative study was designed to examine whether the data would provide support to the twelve underlying hypotheses. These data were collected from private companies with more than 100 employees and three different sources (one member of the TMT, two middle managers, and objective data from financial reports). The final sample consisted of 120 firms (NTMT = 120, Nmiddle managers = 228).The analysis of the data showed that participation implementation strategy was positively related to perceived implementation success and non-financial performance, while edict was negatively related to implementation speed. Additionally, a positive relationship between intervention and perceived implementation success (as rated by the TMT member) was found. Results also indicated that these four implementation strategies may be used in pairs producing interesting outcomes. Also, the results of this thesis stressed the role of employee consensus as a mediator and critical role of organizational politics and TMT as moderators of the effectiveness of implementation strategies. Overall, the findings clearly highlight the importance of participation implementation strategy and its powerful positive effect on implementation success, the importance of combining different implementation strategies, and the crucial moderating role of organizational politics and TMT consensus. Finally, from this multi-study investigation, it was found that employee consensus is a critical precondition for achieving implementation success.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
- Year dc:date
- 2017
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Lampaki, Antonia
- Λαμπάκη, Αντωνία
Subjects
dc:subject × 12Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- BY
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/40583