Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Η συμβολή της προεμφυτευτικής διάγνωσης αριθμητικών χρωμοσωμικών ανωμαλιών στην υποβοηθούμενη αναπαραγωγή

Abstract

dc:description

Chromosome aneuploidy is a major cause of pregnancy failure and loss and is detected in 50% of first trimester spontaneous miscarriages (Hassold and Hunt, 2001; Spandorfer et al., 2004). 70% of chromosome aneuploidy mostly involves chromosomes 13, 22, 16, 18, 21, 15, X and Y. Aneuploidy rates is higher in embryos (70%) from in vitro fertilization cycles (IVF) compared to spontaneous miscarriages. This implies that embryos in IVF with aneuploidies might be rejected before or after embryotransfer, thus reducing implantation frequency. For this reason, preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) of human embryos following IVF, by either polar body or cleavage stage embryo biopsy and fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) of 5-9 chromosome specific probes to the single metaphase or interphase nuclei, had, until recently, been used extensively in women of advanced maternal age and other indications associated with a higher incidence of aneuploidy (Verlinsky et al., 1996; Munne et al., 2002). The aim of PGS is to select embryos with normal copy number of chromosomes in order to transfer and thereby increase implantation and clinical pregnancy rates, reduce the incidence of miscarriage and avoid abnormal pregnancies and live births. In the current thesis the first aim was to standardise the protocol for nucleus fixation at the level of a single cell in order to clinically use it in preimplantation genetic diagnosis for aneuploidy screening. 50 embryos, at cleavage stage, were donated to research by consent from patients undergoing in vitro fertilization treatment (IVF). Modified Tarkowski’s protocol (1966) with Carnoy’s (3:1 methanol:acetic acid) was selected as clinically advanced method since it resulted in nuclei with larger diameter and less percentage of cross hybridization FISH signals compared to Coonen et al., (1994) protocol with Tween-20 HCl. Following fixation of single cells with the most appropriate method, FISH was selected as the method of chromosome analysis since it can be applied efficiently in interphase nuclei. FISH analytical sensitivity and specificity was estimated at 83.3% and 91% respectively, by analyzing 34 embryos at cleavage stage. Misdiagnosis rate due to technical issues was calculated at 3%. Furthermore, mosaicism rate at cleavage was estimated at 8.37% and the risk of classifying an embryo as aneuploid or euploid and vice versa due to mosaicism was 6.37% and 2% respectively.During the second phase of the current thesis 4442 embryos and blastomeres from a consecutive series of controlled ovarian stimularion cycles were analyzed for their chromosome complement by FISH. To investigate the concordance rate and the accuracy of single blastomere analysis at the chromosomal level, a detailed retrospective analysis of 496 embryos at blastocyst stage, that were either estimated as aneuploid or euploid but with poor development, was perfomed. Chromosome follow up of embryos revealed a 3.7% false positive and 14.6% false negative rate for single cell analysis. Τest accuracy regarding representation of the exact embryo chromosome complement was low, predominantly due to mosaicism. Therefore, among reanalyzed embryos only 34.3% (154/449) had identical genotypes between day 3 and day 5 of development. Consequently, accurate copy number analysis of all 24 chromosomes in single blastomeres was performed with microarray based comparative genomic hybridisation (array CGH) in 226 and 121 embryos at cleavage stage from patients with normal and structural abnormalities in their karyotype respectively. Misdiagnosis due to techniqal issues was significantly higher when FISH (11.4%) was applied compared to arrayCGH (4.5%). Normal/balanced embryos frequency in patients with balanced translocations was not significantly different between the two sexes of carriers. However, clinical pregnancy rate was increased in case of female carriers (♀ 12/26, 46%, ♂ 9/22, 41%) but non significantly, which can be attributed to the possible effect of balanced translocations to male fertility. Overall, 2:2 alternative and adjacent-1 were the predominant modes of chromosome segregation in the first meiotic division. 3:0 type of chromosome segregation was extremely rare. 2:2 alternate type of segregation frequency, that generates normal/balanced gametes, was decreased when acrocentric chromosomes were involved in translocation which could be due to the fact that acrocentric chromosomes are less stable than meta- and submetacentric chromosomes throughout chromosome segregation in meiosis. Finally, polar body biopsy and analysis was perfomed with the advantages of being less invasive, since polar bodies do not contribute to the developing embryo, and avoid any possible diagnostic errors caused by chromosomal mosaicism at later stages of preimplantation development. Chromosomes were analyzed in 104 polar bodies in order to detect the ploidy status in the reflecting oocyte. To investigate the concordance rate and the accuracy of polar body analysis at the chromosomal level, we report here a detailed retrospective analysis of copy number changes detected by array CGH in the first (PB1) and second polar body (PB2) and corresponding cleavage stage embryos. Euploid/aneuploid status of polar bodies was efficient in detecting maternally derived aneuploidies in the corresponding embryo at cleavage stage as detetced by reanalysing 30 of the 52 analysed oocytes. Detection rate of aneuploidies of maternal origin were detected at 68 out of 69 (98.5%) copy number changes. However, 17/100 (17%) copy number changes in the polar bodies of these embryos had to be categorised as unclassified segregation errors since they did not predict the outcome in the corresponding embryo accurately, mainly in PB1 and possibly due to artefacts of whole genome amplification from single cells. Analysis of segregation error pattern of the chromosomes in the two polar bodies and corresponding zygote, demonstrated that almost all errors in first meiotic division are caused by premature predivision of sister chromatids rather than non-disjunction of whole chromosomes and many oocytes have multiple meiotic errors. This is consistent with increasing evidence that meiosis specific cohesins which bind the homologuous chromosomes together in oocytes arrested in prophase in the fetal ovary before birth, do not turn over and may be gradually degraded. Also, because half of the MI errors were balanced in the second (MII), the proportion of maternal aneuploidies in embryos originating in MI was much less than MII. In this small series of embryos, there were almost twice as many gains as losses in PB2 resulting in an excess of monosomies in the corresponding embryos.In a specific case of a female carrier of balanced and reciprocal translocation array CGH analysis of the first (PB1) and second polar bodies (PB2) and follow up of the corresponding cleavage stage embryos showed that in 55% of analysed oocytes unbalanced segregation of the translocation chromosomes in the first meiotic division was balanced in the second by the reverse pattern of gain and loss resulting in balanced embryos. Therefore, aneuploidy testing of both polar bodies is essential for accurate prediction of translocation chromosome imbalance in the corresponding embryo.In conclusion:Α) Single cell chromosomal analysis by FISH at cleavage stage could detect aneuploidy but not the exact genotype of an embryo at cleavage. Β) Misdiagnosis due to techniqal issues was significantly higher when FISH was applied compared to arrayCGH at single cell level. C) The frequency of balanced/normal embryos did not differ between two sexes of carriers with structural chromosome abnormalities in their karyotype. However, the clinical pregnancy rates were higher for the female rather than male carriers and this could be attributed to possible effect of translocation to male fertility. The most frequent mode of segregation was the 2:2 alternative type. The rate of balanced/ normal embryos was decreased when translocations involved acrocentric chromosomes and this could be attributed to the fact that acrocentrics are less stable than metacentric and submetacentric chromosomes during meiosis. The rate of balanced/ normal embryos was not decreased when the breakpoints were close to telomeres.D) Aneuploidy testing of both polar bodies is essential for accurate prediction of translocation chromosome imbalance and sporadic aneuploidies in the corresponding embryo. Follow up of embryos at cleavage stage after polar body analysis revealed that aneuploidies detected at polar body biopsy were confirmed in the majority (98.5%) of the corresponding embryos. However, 17/100 (17%) of specific chromosome copy number changes identified at polar bodies were not detected at the corresponding embryos which should be mentioned when counseling patients undertaking aneuploidy screening of their polar bodies. Close inspection of the array CGH plots revealed that many of these unclassified errors involved copy number changes which, by comparison with the ratio for the X chromosome versus sex mismatched control male DNA, were smaller than expected for either whole chromosome or chromatid imbalance. These small copy number changes are likely to be artefacts of whole genome amplification from single cells and therefore should not be reported.Ε) Almost all errors in the first meiotic division are caused by pre-mature pre-division of sister chromatids and not non-disjunction of whole chromosomes and many oocytes have multiple meiotic errors. This is consistent with increasing evidence that meiosis specific cohesins which bind the homologous chromosomes together in oocytes arrested in prophase in the fetal ovary before birth, do not turn over and may be gradually degraded. This is likely to be as a result of the prolonged arrest of the chromosomes at the dictyotene stage of first meiosis.F) Therefore polar body biopsy and analysis of 23 pairs of chromosomes with arrayCGH predicts which oocytes will most probably lead to either nonviable or viable embryos which can lead to miscarriages with complex and single chromosome abnromalities respectively. This will assist in counselling of women about the possibility of a viable pregnancy in subsequent IVF cycles with their own oocytes. Thus, polar body biopsy and array CGH analysis is efficient as it predicts most aneuploidies at cleavage stage embryos. However, whether this method can be an alternative way of analysis is unclear and randomised multicenter prospective studies are needed in order to determine whether current method of analysis performed in this actual study can increase clinical pregnancy rates.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2013

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Christopikou, Dimitra
  • Χριστοπίκου, Δήμητρα

Subjects

dc:subject × 19

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/40697

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Christopikou, Dimitra; Χριστοπίκου, Δήμητρα. Η συμβολή της προεμφυτευτικής διάγνωσης αριθμητικών χρωμοσωμικών ανωμαλιών στην υποβοηθούμενη αναπαραγωγή. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2013. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/40697