Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Μελέτη ιδιοτήτων προϊόντων αρτοποιίας εµπλουτισµένων µε λειτουργικά συστατικά και υποκατάστατα λιπαρού ή ζάχαρης

Abstract

dc:description

Nowadays consumers show growing preference to low calorie or reduced fatproducts, so as to prevent or deal with health threatening diseases of the metabolicsyndrome (diabetes, obesity, cardiovascular disease). Substances that can replacecaloric ingredients, can be used as a valuable tool against obesity, whereas dietaryfibres as well have significant contribution to the dietary value of the product due totheir physiological effects and their technological functionality.The objective of the present thesis is to study the sugar and fat replacement, as wellas the enrichment with dietary fibre of a highly preferred bakery product, the cake.The cake was selected as it is broadly consumed product by adults and children,which in the recent years has attracted the scientific interest as a product suitable forenrichment. In the present research a shortened-style cake was selected, which wasprepared with the sugar batter mixing method.The selection of the materials which were used for the replacement of sucrose andfat was based on literature data. Sugar and fat replacers which have been theobjective of previous studies were selected in order to investigate their effect oncharacteristics which have not been extensively studied, as well as materials whichhave not been studied thoroughly. The research was not limited only to theinvestigation of the effect of the replacers on the quality characteristics of cake(specific volume, texture, colour, sensory characteristics) but it included the batter characteristics (rheological behaviour, air incorporation, bubble size distribution,starch gelatinization) as well, in order to draw conclusions on the interactionbetween the properties of the batter and those of the final product. Also thecomparative study between the sucrose or fat replacers, led to conclusions regardingtheir performance.The total replacement of sucrose was investigated, so that the product would be lowcalorie, and/or suitable for diabetics. Polyols (sorbitol, maltitol, mannitol, lactitol),polydextrose, oligofructose and fructose were used to replace sugar by an equalamount and their incorporation in the batter was conducted with the same procedureas with the control sample (cake with sucrose). In the cake samples containing sugarsubstitutes (except for the fructose preparations), a commercial blend of aspartameand acesulfame-K was added for sweetening purposes. The batter characteristics andthe cake properties of the cakes containing sugar substitutes were compared with therespective attributes of the control cake. The best results were obtained by usingoligofructose, lactitol and maltitol as sugar replacers. More specifically theyexhibited similar behaviour to sucrose in terms of batter rheology (consistencycoefficient: 17.7, 26.2 και 23.7 Pa*sn respectively compared to 21.9 Pa*sn ofcontrol) and also exhibited similar or even higher ability to increase the starchgelatinization temperature compared to sucrose (onset temperature: 85.5, 82.8 και83.2 ºC compared to 82.5 ºC of the control). They did not exhibit significantdifference compared to control in terms of specific volume and hardness. They didnot present significant difference in most sensory properties, in accordance with theinstrumental measurements of textural properties, while some differences whichwere detected in the darker crust colour of the oligofructose cake was not perceivedby the panelists. Sorbitol and polydextrose did not differ significantly in most batterand cake compared to sucrose, but ranked low in terms of taste and consequently inoverall acceptance.On the other hand mannitol and fructose led to cakes of poor quality. Morespecifically mannitol present the highest hardness, which was attributed to thehigher batter consistency coeeficient (52.0 Pa*sn) and to the lower starchgelatinisation temperature (56.6 ºC) compared to control (21.9 Pa*sn, 82.5 ºCrespectively). Fructose provided a product of the lowest specific volume, which canbe attributed to its lack of ability to set gelatinisation of starch to higher temperature(73.9 ºC).Therefore the effect of the replacers on the batter characteristics and on starchgelatinisation (which is a crucial factor of the appropriate setting of the batter) are controlling factors on of the volume development and of the textural attributes of theend product. Hence at sugar replacement, the effect of the replacers on the batterrheological behaviour and air incorporation, combined with their ability to set starchgelatinisation to higher temperature, could predict the textural characteristics of theend product, and hardness in specific:Hardness= 5.8413+0.00485*Kcp-0.0763*Tonwhere Kcp is the consistency coefficient and Τon is the onset temperature of starchgelatinization.Fat was replaced at 35% to 100% by carbohydrate-based (maltodextrin, inulin,pectin, oligofructose) and protein-based (microparticulated protein) replacers. Thefat replacers were incorporated in the form of gel. They were dissolved in water, inthe minimum concentration that was required for gel formation after their storage at4 ºC overnight. More specifically inulin HP (with polymerization degree>23), inulinGR (with polymerization degree>10) and maltodextrin were dissolved in water atconcentration 20%, microparticulated whey protein at 35%, oligofructose at 70%and pectin at 4.5%. Furthermore the effect of the degree of polymerization and ofthe degree of esterification on the performance of inulin and pectin respectively, wasinvestigated. Fat replacement by 35% did not exhibit significant differencecompared to control. Above 65% fat replacement resulted in significantly decreasedviscosity (except for pectin of high esterification degree), that was followed bysignificant decrease in air incorporation and broader bubble size distribution.Significant difference on the starch gelatinization temperature was observed in thecase of fructans (91.10 ºC and 86.25 ºC for oligofrustose and inulin withpolymerization degrees <8 και >10 respectively, compared to 83.69 ºC of thecontrol), resulting in significantly higher volume of the end product.The effect of fat replacers on the batter characteristics appeared to be controllingfactor of the textural properties and the development of the cake volume. Thesamples with 65% fat replacement exhibited significant increase of hardness,elasticity and decrease of volume development. Similar results were obtained by thesensory analysis. More specifically the differentiations of the sensorial properties oftexture can be estimated by a mathematical model which describes the stress-strainrelationship, which is obtained through the subjection of the product to forcecompression:[ ( )] 3 where σ is the stress, ε is the strain and C1, C2, C3 are constants related to the shapeof the sigmoid curve. C1 is correlated to hardness and C2 to elasticity andcrumbliness.At fat replacement above 65% the cakes received lower scores in terms of taste andflavor, whereas at total replacement all samples were evaluated as not acceptableregardless of the fat replacer. Nevertheless at 65% fat replacement, the samplespresented acceptable textural, physical and sensorial characteristics. Pectin andinulin proved the most efficient fat replacers.Based on the results of the comparative study between the fat replacers, the level offat replacemet (65%) and the fat replacer (inulin) were determined, for the furtherinvestigation of fibre enrichment. More specifically the effect of the carrot fibreenrichment of fat reduced cake was studied, and the enhancement of the enrichedproduct by the use of emulsifiers was also investigated.Carrot fibres have significanthealth beneficial effects, however their compatability to cakes has been investigated.Moreover, the commercial exploitation of carrot fibres could be beneficial to theindustry and the environment since they comprise a by-product of the carrotprocessing industry. Inulin was selected, since it performed better compared to therest of the fat replacers which were studied, and because of the significantphysiological effects it exerts.Carrot fibre was added to the full fat product (control) as flour replacement at 10%to 30%. Flour replacement by 10% led to significant difference in terms of the batterrheological characteristics (34.8 Pa*sn compared to 31.8 Pa*sn of control), howeverno significant diffence was observed compared to control on volume and hardness ofthe end product. The replacement of flour by 20% and 30% increased batterviscosity and decreased air incorporation, providing harder cakes with densestructure, which also presented lighter crust color. Since the samples with 10% flourreplacement did not exhibit significant difference compared to control in terms ofvolume and hardness, carrot fibre was incorporated as 10% flour replacer for theenrichment of cake with 65% fat replacement by inulin. The 20% replacement offlour in cake with total fat replacement provided unacceptable product. Thecombined flour and fat replacement (10% and 65%, respectively) counteracted theeffect of each replacer in terms of batter rheological characteristics and bubble sizedistribution, nevertheless it led to further decrease of the air incorporation, resultingto further decrease of volume compared to the 65% fat replacement and to furtherincrease of hardness compared to the sample with 10% carrot fibre. The samples with carrot fibre (10%) and inulin were evaluated as significantly harder (6.0)compared to the control (3.7).The enhancement of the enriched product by the use of three emulsifiers, whoseaddition is established by the EU Legislation, was investigated. Emulsifiers(monoglycerides, SSL, DATEM) with different HLB values, varying from lipophilicto hydrophilic character, were selected and the levels of their incorporation werebased on legislative regulation and literature data. The incorporation of theemulsifiers facilitated air incorporation, due to their stabilizing effect on bubbleformulation, resulting in increased volume development and decrease of hardness.SSL exhibited the best result, since it appeared to be the most effective in terms ofvolume and porosity increase and hardness decrease.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2015

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Psimouli, Vassiliki
  • Ψιμούλη, Βασιλική

Subjects

dc:subject × 20

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/40728

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Psimouli, Vassiliki; Ψιμούλη, Βασιλική. Μελέτη ιδιοτήτων προϊόντων αρτοποιίας εµπλουτισµένων µε λειτουργικά συστατικά και υποκατάστατα λιπαρού ή ζάχαρης. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2015. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/40728