Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Επαναχρησιμοποίηση νερού: περιβαλλοντική προστασία και δείκτες μέτρησης επίδοσης

Abstract

dc:description

Current water related challenges and water scarcity problems, caused by imbalances between supply and demand, increased pollution of water bodies and/or inadequate funds for the exploitation of available resources, have rendered integrated water resources management a necessity. Treated wastewater has been proven to be a reliable alternative water resource that can play a vital role in integrated water resources management, addressing both water demand and supply, wastewater disposal and environmental protection. Reclaimed water is receiving growing attention worldwide as an effective integrated solution for addressing water scarcity, with numerous benefits (e.g. locally controlled and constant water supply unaffected by climatic conditions, reduced wastewater discharges and decreased water abstractions, energy savings). So far, however, the potential for treated wastewater reuse has not been widely exploited in Greece and Europe, even though these regions have been subject to growing water scarcity. This is mostly due to specific policy, economic, social, technical, legal and institutional barriers which inhibit the implementation of water reuse and recycling (WR&R) schemes.The present thesis focuses on the contribution of WR&R in environmental protection and sustainability of water resources systems, and the use of metrics to assess the performance of these systems.The aim of the thesis is to develop a methodological framework for estimating the contribution of WR&R in environmental protection and sustainability of water resources systems. It provides a comprehensive approach towards integrated water resources management, by diagnosing water related problems, evaluating and identifying appropriate interventions, and promoting the implementation of these interventions at the local level.The proposed methodological framework consists of four steps, and aims to:a. Assess water systems’ vulnerability to water scarcity (STEP 1)b. Estimate the anticipated contribution of alternative WR&R interventions to vulnerability mitigation (STEP 2)c. Develop an enabling environment (recommendations of suitable enabling instruments and arrangements) to enhance the implementation of WR&R interventions at the local level (STEPS 3 & 4).STEP 1 focuses on the vulnerability assessment of water systems to water scarcity. Vulnerability is considered a function of a system’s exposure to hazards, its sensitivity and its adaptive capacity. The vulnerability assessment is conducted at river basin scale, through the use of ten proxy indicators, expressing natural, physical, socio-economic and institutional attributes of water systems, and a composite vulnerability index (VI). Through the proxy indicators the vulnerability profiles of the analyzed systems are formulated, describing the significant water resources pressures, and the aspects that need to be improved in each case. The ten selected indicators fall under the three vulnerability aspects, i.e. exposure, sensitivity and adaptive capacity: Renewable water resources per capita - Falkenmark indicator (F) Untreated wastewater discharge as percentage of available water resources (WW) Water Exploitation Index (WEI) Water self-sufficiency (SELF) Population Density (DENS) Vegetation cover of the area (VEG) Consumption of alternative water resources (ALT) Economically active population (EC) Population who did not proceed to secondary education (ED) Gross Regional Domestic Product per capita (GDP)The ten proxy indicators combined formulate the VI (Equation 3), which can be used to rank and benchmark areas as to their vulnerability status, as well as for the comparative assessment of the same area in different time periods. Weights are assigned to the respective vulnerability indicators using the Principal Components Analysis.In STEP 2 potential WR&R interventions are assessed according to the anticipated vulnerability reduction, using the VI. Five broad WR&R intervention types are defined based on the water use sectors that could be supplied with reclaimed water: Type #1: Use of reclaimed water in crop irrigation Type #2: Use of reclaimed water in the urban environment Type #3: Use of reclaimed water in industrial processes Type #4: Use of reclaimed water for environmental protection & enhancing ecosystem services Type #5: Use of reclaimed water in several water use sectors (multipurpose WR&R schemes)Alternative interventions can be identified for each type depending on the required and available quantity and quality of reclaimed water. Different WR&R interventions affect certain parameters of the analyzed water systems and induce changes in specific indicators of the VI. The VI is calculated for each WR&R intervention and compared to the VI of the current conditions. The potential WR&R interventions are, thus, ranked according to the anticipated vulnerability reduction achieved through their implementation (ΔVI). Through the conducted assessment, effective WR&R interventions are identified to alleviate existing water scarcity conditions in the examined areas (interventions with the highest ΔVI in absolute values, ΔVI <0).STEPS 3 & 4 aim at developing an enabling environment for enhancing the actual implementation of the identified WR&R interventions. In STEP 3 22 policy, economic, social, legal and institutional factors of potential influence on WR&R implementation are identified, using the PESTL analysis. These factors are assessed to identify the driving forces / drivers that enhance, and the barriers that inhibit, the integration of WR&R schemes in the regional water systems. An on-line PESTLE questionnaire was developed for the assessment of the 22 factors, through interaction, consultation and active participation of local stakeholders of the examined areas. In STEP 4 the barriers identified in STEP 3 are further analysed following a Cross-Impact/System analysis. Through the conducted analyses the key barriers, i.e. those barriers that obstruct the implementation of WR&R schemes the most, are identified. On the basis of key barriers the enabling instruments and arrangements that are needed to boost WR&R implementation at the local level are recommended. Key barriers are useful for policy formulation towards an enabling environment, and should be given priority by the decision-makers for the successful implementation of WR&R interventions.The four steps of the proposed methodology were applied in the 46 River Basins of Greece (STEPS 1 & 2) and in the Copiapó River Basin in Chile (STEPS 3 & 4). The Copiapó River Basin is a Study Site of the European Union (EU) funded research project COROADO (duration: 2011-2015), which was seeking to promote WR&R technologies in Latin America, and it was chosen for the application of the proposed methodology because of data availability. The vulnerability assessment of the 46 Greek River Basins (RB) to water scarcity was conducted using 10 individual indicators and a composite index (VI) developed for these specific areas.According to the analysis, Attica is the most vulnerable RB to water scarcity (VI = 0.49), while the RB of Thassos and Samothrace is the least vulnerable out of the 46 RBs (VI = -0.27). Therobustness of VI was also assessed following Uncertainty and Sensitivity analyses. Then,potential alternative WR&R interventions were identified for the Attica RB, on the basis of theproposals presented in the “Master Plan for Reusing the Effluents of the Wastewater Treatment Plants (WWTP) of Attica” (Greek Ministry of Infrastructure, Transport and Networks, 2009). The WR&R interventions that involve multipurpose WR&R schemes - use of reclaimed water in several water use sectors - are the most effective in terms of vulnerability mitigation, because they provide the RB with greater supply of reclaimed water covering greater percentages of demand. As expected, the larger quantities of reclaimed water used the greatest vulnerability reduction achieved. The greatest vulnerability reduction (ΔVI = -10.10%) occurs in the case of maximum utilization of the effluents of the WWTPs of Attica in the near future, i.e. if all the proposed WR&R interventions of the first implementation phase of the Master Plan are applied.The Copiapó RB also faces severe water scarcity conditions, mainly due to strong populationgrowth, high temporal variation of rainfall and absolute dependence of agriculture to irrigation. Urban WR&R interventions are considered to have an essential contribution in the mitigation of water systems vulnerability in the area. The proposed methodology supporting the development of an enabling environment for the implementation of WR&R schemes was applied in the Copiapó RB. The political, economic, social, technical, legal and institutional factors that may influence WR&R implementation in the regional water system positively (drivers) or negatively (barriers) were identified through the mapping of local stakeholder perceptions. Through the analysis it was observed that barriers outweigh drivers for the implementation of urban WR&R schemes in Copiapó River Basin (10 barriers and 5 drivers), while the key barriers, which could be useful for policy formulation towards an enabling environment in the area, concern:The unclear legal framework regarding the ownership of treated wastewater, The lack of environmental policies focusing on pollution control, The limited integration of reclaimed water use in the current land use and development policies, The lack of public awareness on WR&R, and The limited availability of governmental funding sources for WR&R.The synthesis of these four steps in a unified framework is an innovation for the water resources management sector, as such a framework provides a unique tool that combines the assessment and monitoring of the status of water resources systems with the identification and enhancement of suitable interventions for its improvement. Different methods and tools have already been proposed in the literature for the individual steps of the proposed framework. Through the comparison of the methods proposed in the present thesis with those found in the literature, the main advantages and limitations of the proposed methodology are identified and analyzed. Taking into consideration the results from the application of the proposed framework in the 46 Greek RBs and in the Copiapó RB, and the identified limitations, specific issues and ideas are put forward for further investigation for the future enhancement of the proposed framework.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2017

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Stathatou, Patritsia Maria
  • Σταθάτου, Πατρίτσια-Μαρία

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/41267

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Stathatou, Patritsia Maria; Σταθάτου, Πατρίτσια-Μαρία. Επαναχρησιμοποίηση νερού: περιβαλλοντική προστασία και δείκτες μέτρησης επίδοσης. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2017. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/41267