University of the Aegean
Spatial and temporal patterns of fish assemblages in a Mediterranean intermittent river
Abstract
dc:descriptionFreshwater fish species are amongst the most highly threatened species around the globe. Freshwater fish inhabiting stream and rivers around the Mediterranean basin are predominantly threatened, due to their restricted distributional ranges and elevated anthropogenic pressures. Specifically, in the last updates of the worldwide IUCN Red List, freshwater fish species are amongst the most highly threatened species, registering alarming percentages: 37% worldwide, and 56% when only the Mediterranean endemic species are considered. Decelerating this dramatic biodiversity loss is still possible through intensified, coordinated conservation efforts, however, a deeper knowledge of biodiversity patterns and the factors affecting this biodiversity change is urgently needed. The current dissertation aims to advance the knowledge of fish population and fish assemblage dynamics in a Mediterranean intermittent river. Specifically, the study was designed to identify the distributional and structural patterns of an endemic and endangered fish assemblage on multiple spatiotemporal scales and to evaluate the role of environmental factors affecting these patterns. The entire study was conducted during the period of 2010-20161 at the Evrotas River, a Mediterranean-type river located in Southern Greece. Overall, six separate research activities were conducted in order to:i) describe the ichthyofaunal assemblage compositions and distributions along the longitudinal river gradient and attempt to interpret fish assemblage types in a hydrologically disturbed Mediterranean intermittent riverii) identify the early summer habitat use (i.e. prior to the launch of the drought period) of the three endemic cyprinids in reference sites, in order to set the baseline for future conservation actionsiii) identify and compare the habitat use patterns by the three endemic fish species in reference and pollution impacted sites, in order to test how intermittency and pollution could affect in combination local fish assemblagesiv) assess how fish assemblage and population attributes (species composition, density, abundance, size structure and mortality) of the three endangered cyprinids are affected by the drying process at the reach and habitat scale and how the recolonization process evolves after flow resumptionv) attempt to elucidate the fish metacommunity patterns observed in the study area, and if spatial or local scales are responsible for these patternsvi) identify methodological drawbacks for assessing fish population status in intermittent streams.In the Evrotas main corridor, we observed a general trend over a three year period, with an increase of fish density and species richness along an upstream–downstream gradient. Fish assemblages from upstream to downstream were characterized by a decrease of the most rheophilic species (Squalius keadicus) and an increase of the most stagnophilic species (Tropidophoxinellus spartiaticus). Three river segments characterized by a high degree of homogeneity were delineated. Habitat and environmental preferences for the studied fish species were identified, with elevation and water velocity being the most important environmental factors affecting fish distribution patterns. The current study provides evidence that, even in an intermittent river, an assemblage pattern following a longitudinal gradient can be identified, mainly due to the lack of instream barriers in the case of the Evrotas River, allowing recolonization after flow resumption.Moreover, the early summer habitat use (i.e. prior to the launch of the drought period) of the three endemic and endangered Greek cyprinids, the Evrotas chub (Squalius keadicus), the Spartian minnowroach (Tropidophoxinellus spartiaticus) and the Evrotas minnow (Pelasgus laconicus), in terms of depth, water velocity, substrate and macrophyte cover were delineated in two reference sites. In the case of the chub, habitat use by juvenile and adult fish was assessed separately. All three target species had their highest densities in deeper habitats with low water velocities and depositional substrata, such as pools and runs. A high overlap in habitat use was evident for the three species. Μinnowroaches, minnows and large chubs actively selected deep habitats. Minnowroaches and minnows favored slow flowing, vegetated habitats with fine substrate located close to the river bank, whereas chubs had no clear affinity for particular velocities or substrate types. However, size class comparisons in chub indicated differences in both water depth and velocity. Overall, the results of this study provides the first detailed report of habitat use by these endangered fish species.When assessing the habitat use of the three endemic cyprinids at a reference reach and at a reach impacted mainly by pollution, differences in habitat use were indicated. Fish distributions and densities indicated that depth and flow were the most relevant factors in habitat use by the three species. More specifically, in the reference reach, habitat use reflected the differences between the more generalist (capable of occupying equally fast and slow flowing habitats) Evrotas chub and the other two limnophylic species, Spartian minnowroach and the Evrotas minnow. In the impacted reach, Evrotas chub indicated a tendency to abandon lentic habitats (pools and glides), concentrating mostly in fast flowing habitats (runs and riffles). This shift of Evrotas chub away from the slower flowing pools and glides to runs, is possibly related to the disturbance of this reach. The Spartian minnowroach and the Evrotas minnow were positively associated with depth and negatively with flow at both reaches. Overall, the differences observed in the abiotic and habitat parameters between the two reaches during this study hamper the possibility to actually identify the cause-effect relationship of how the effluents of the wastewater treatment plant of Sparta affects the fish assemblages and the habitat use of the three cyprinids of Evrotas River, due to the fact, that these observed differences, may actual reflect other factors (e.g. spatial factors). Thus, the tentatively suggested shifts in habitat use by the Evrotas cyprinids requires further investigation in order to clarify whether these shifts can be attributed to the impact of pollution and /or the impact of other factors.When assessing fish community attributes’ variation (abundance, density, and size-structure of the three endemic cyprinids), during the drying and the recolonization processes, both at the reach and habitat scale, we observed that the progressive environmental deterioration, led initially to the confinement of the three species to the deepest habitats. The two smaller, limnophylic species, the Spartian Minnowroach and the Evrotas Minnow, exhibited higher resistance, attributed to their life-history strategies, while the larger, habitat generalist Evrotas Chub, presented lower resistance and high mortality rates, already at the onset of drought. Upon flow resumption, fish rapidly recolonized the affected area, a sign of high resilience of all species.Furthermore, we investigated the compositional structure of fish assemblages along the longitudinal axis of the Evrotas River attempting to unravel whether species sorting and/or dispersal processes shape metacommunities. Our analysis that explored community similarity with geographical distance indicated a high correlated distance decay relationship. When using community similarity with environmental conditions, in contrast, there was no significant correlation, leading to the conclusion that the degree of similarities of nearby sites (regardless of their intermittent or perennial status) were not significantly affected by environmental conditions. Nearby perennial and intermittent sites displayed similar fish communities mainly contributed to dispersal rather than similar local environmental conditions, while, in addition, a gradual species turnover was evident along the longitudinal axis, with chub dominance in the upstream reaches being replaced by minnowroach dominance in the lower reaches. Thus, we conclude that our results provide support for the dispersal mass effects hypothesis rather than the species sorting hypothesis, with mass effects most likely dominating summer metacommunity dynamics in the Evrotas River. The limited temporal scale of our study, however, does not allow us to derive safe conclusions about the progress of metacommunity mechanisms.Finally, we evaluated whether sampling density, as well as other population attributes, is concordant to estimate population size during drought years. Our findings suggest that the shrinkage of the wetted area is much higher than the decrease of “segment” population size, and local densities increase, despite the substantial reduction of absolute abundance. We suggest that when river drying is a recurring condition, the results of site-based surveys should be interpreted with caution, as local fish densities may provide a misleading indication of population status and result to unrealistic inferences for population or ecosystem integrity. Less variable site features (mean base flow width / mean active channel width) and/or initial site characteristics (initial wetted width) should instead be used to estimate local densities, in order to minimize errors associated with water contraction and crowding effects. Similarly to density, other quality metrics (e.g. abundance, biomass, size structure and richness) can potentially be affected by crowding effects during seasonal drying.Overall, it was evident that the high spatial and temporal variability of all environmental parameters of Evrotas River is the basic component that affects the structure and function of its freshwater fish. Under these variable conditions, any research effort aiming either to interpret / define ecological patterns or to diagnose the ecological integrity of such ecosystems, presents several difficulties in drawing out safe conclusions following the classic ecological approaches. The underlying cause of the failure of the classical methodological approaches is mainly attributed due to the constantly changing environmental conditions that do not allow a clear cause / effect relationship on several occasions.In a more general context, the present study recognized these difficulties and attempted to explore the ecological patterns and ecological processes of the fish faunaof Evrotas River using also macroecological approaches. During this study, it was observed that the recovery and ultimately the survival of the endemic fish of Evrotas is mainly attributed to a biological factor (high fertility) as well as to an ecological mechanism (dispersion during the re-establishment of flow). From a conservational point of view, these two factors are crucial to the survivorship of the unique and highly threatened endemics of the Evrotas River. In addition, efforts should be focused in maintaining population connectivity to support depleted populations through the removal of barriers (e.g. dams, weirs, road crossings, etc.) that disrupt longitudinal connectivity, and thus increasing the possibility of survival and/or recolonization.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of the Aegean
- Year dc:date
- 2017
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Vardakas, Leonidas
- Βαρδάκας, Λεωνίδας
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/41450