National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Contribution to the evaluation of the compaction characteristics of asphalt mixtures
Abstract
dc:descriptionAsphalt mixture compaction has been well recognized as one of the most critical factors affecting the pavement behavior, providing all desirable mixture design characteristics are met. This poses a challenge the laboratory compaction to simulate the field compaction, so that a reliable assessment of the on-site asphalt mixture’s characteristics, both mechanical and surface, is enabled to ensure proper asphalt pavement behavior. Comparative evaluation between the commonly available laboratory compaction methods has reached inconclusive results as to which method is the best in terms of simulating the field compaction conditions. However, it is widely acknowledged that compaction method has direct impact on the aggregate structure within the compacted mixture, and hence studying this can lead to understanding of the mechanism of the aggregate inter-particle arrangement. It is believed that linking this to the changes in asphalt mixture performance-based characteristics can thus lead to better understanding of the dominant compaction parameters and the resulting mechanical response. Furthermore, the pavement surface shall provide adequate skid resistance, which is vital for the safety of the driving public. This implies that pavement engineers shall be able to precisely evaluate and quantify before construction the field compaction-based surface texture characteristics of asphalt mixtures, which so far has been investigated to a limited extent. Hence, a practical methodology shall be developed to allow the prediction of the on-site asphalt surface characteristics of the mixture with respect to the compaction process from laboratory produced specimens. The aim of this Thesis was to contribute to a better simulation of in-situ conditions through laboratory compaction methods, so that reliable results can be obtained to assess, as accurately as possible, the on-site characteristics of field-compacted asphalt mixtures. To reach this aim, extensive laboratory (based on impact, gyratory and roller compaction methods) and field experiments were designed and performed, including the implementation of modern Non Destructive Testing (NDT) technologies for rigorous evaluation purposes. A holistic approach, including investigations for both the compaction dependent surface and mechanical characteristics of asphalt mixtures, was adopted. In this methodology, at first the compaction factors affecting significantly the compactability, stiffness and rut resistance characteristics of asphalt mixtures are identified, characteristics which have been found to be strongly influenced from compaction methods. Secondly, evaluating the internal structure of asphalt mixtures by means of 2-D image analyses understanding the compaction factors controlling the formation of aggregate skeleton, in terms of aggregate ‘contact points’, orientation and segregation, is obtained. This is important to understand the interplay between the internal structure and mechanical performance of asphalt mixtures and relate this to the compaction methodology. Based on the experimental findings, a clear understanding of the key compaction parameters for each compaction method has been reached. For instance, the compaction temperature, (initial) diameter and angle of gyration, compaction temperature and effort were found to be the dominant parameters for the impact, gyratory and roller compaction, respectively. These factors eventually form the basis for laboratory compaction regimes to contribute to bridge the gap with the field compaction-based mechanical characteristics, which will have a significant influence when using mechanistic-empirical pavement analyses methods to improve the pavement analysis outcome towards better representing the actual pavement behavior. This research’ findings also indicated that the laboratory compaction testing during mixture design process cannot reliably reflect the compactability of asphalt mixtures in the field and hence provide essential input to be used for the construction process. In practice, achieving on-site the target compaction degree is still a heuristic process, mainly, on the basis of installation of a trial section. Within this procedure, contractors seek to establish the rolling pattern to achieve the target density by determining the compaction density curve with number of roller passes without however taking into consideration dominant parameters controlling the compaction process, such as mixture temperature properties. In this Thesis, attempting to maximize the benefits from the installation of a trial section, an improved and practical NDT-based methodology to establish effectively the rolling pattern has been developed making due allowance for the mixture temperature properties and the variability in construction conditions. Furthermore, an integrated GPR-based methodology to assess reliably the in-place density was introduced, which enable within production rolling to verify the effectiveness of the established rolling pattern to fulfill the compaction requirements. Both these methodologies can benefit contractors and agencies to improve not only the on-site compaction methodology to ensure a proper pavement initial condition, but also the compaction quality control procedures offering the benefit, compared to more traditional destructive test methods, of full coverage nondestructive evaluation of the pavement mat. Particularly, through enhanced field compaction a proper pavement initial condition, according to design criteria, will be ensured and the positive influences will therefore be not only a substantial decrease in needs for maintenance works and thereby in the total life cycle cost, but also less disruption to road users. Moreover, in this Thesis a simple, yet, and practical methodology has been developed, which allows to estimate the field compaction-based surface texture characteristics of asphalt mixtures. With this methodology, which includes the roller compaction method for producing laboratory specimens to be subjected to typical laboratory tests (namely the sand patch and British pendulum), it was demonstrated that the performance of different mixtures in terms of skid resistance and the efficacy of the various compaction modes may be effectively evaluated. Also, the preliminary experimental results indicated a good correlation between the skid resistance characteristics of laboratory - and field compaction-based asphalt surface. Hence, this methodology can benefit pavement engineers offering them the possibility to quantify and optimize the skid resistance-related properties of asphalt mixtures during the laboratory design process, as well as helpful information that may be potentially used to assess the safety of road users at the early stage of asphalt pavement in service. Further, this methodology offers essential information for contractors to establish an effective field compaction mode to achieve conformity with construction requirements.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2016
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Georgiou, Panagiotis
- Γεωργίου, Παναγιώτης
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Συμπύκνωση
- Ασφαλτομίγματα
- Ανάλυση εικόνας
- Συμπυκνωσιμότητα
- Μηχανικές ιδιότητες
- Χαρακτηριστικά υφής
- Μη καταστρεπτικές δοκιμές
- Compaction
- Asphalt mixtures
- Image analysis
- Compactability
- Mechanical properties
- Texture characteristics
- Non destructive testing (NDT)
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη Πολιτικού Μηχανικού
- Engineering and Technology
- Civil Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/41674