National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Η μελέτη του εκφραζόμενου συναισθήματος (expressed emotion) στις μητέρες παιδιών και νεαρών εφήβων με κατάθλιψη σε σχέση με την πορεία της θεραπείας τους
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe discovery and therapeutic use of psychotropic drugs, during the fifties, allowed for many chronic hospitalized psychiatric adult patients to return to their families. The fact that some of them, despite their drug medication, soon after relapsed, while others did not, shifted the specialists’ focus to the family environment and how it might influence the course of the psychiatric illness. In consequence, the family atmosphere and its aspects were primarily studied in relation to adult schizophrenia and its relapses, but soon after, the research field was enlarged in order to include other psychiatric disorders.In the context of a particular research direction which examined the quality of the relations between patients and their relatives in relation to the course of the psychic disorder, the index of “Expressed Emotion” (EE) was accrued. EE indicates a number of central aspects of interpersonal relations. It includes measurements of critical attitude, hostility and emotional over-involvement on the part of a significant other, usually a family member, towards the psychiatric patient. Vast research work in this field has shown EE as a predictive index for the outcome of schizophrenia as well as for a number of other psychiatric and somatic conditions (depression, obsessive compulsive disorder, agoraphobia, anorexia nervosa, mental retardation, epilepsy, inflammatory bowel disease etc.)Regarding adult’s depression, the research findings indicate that high level of EE in the family is related to a negative outcome of the patient’s illness (prolonging of the depressive episode, relapses) as well as to the severity of the depressive episode. Comparatively, few studies have been conducted in samples of children and adolescents, though they also provide the same strong findings of correlation between parental EE and parental psychopathology (especially maternal depression) as well as depression in children. The investigation of the family factors in relation to the incidence or course of childhood depression has special clinical interest for two basic reasons: a) because children are psychically integrated within the family relationships and the connection between family dysfunction and the child’s psychic disorder is specifically strong, and b) because, in comparison to adults, the use and effectiveness of anti-depressive drugs is very restricted in the case of children and adolescents.It is in this scientific field that the present study attempts to contribute: that is, to investigate the family factors in relation to childhood depression. Its aim, in particular, is to study maternal EE and its correlation to the course of therapy in children and young adolescents (age 9-15), who suffer from Major Depressive Disorder or / and Dysthymic Disorder. This was investigated by means of a number of questions that examine variables from a relatively large field of research. That is, maternal EE was studied: a) in relation to mother’s clinical-psychiatric and social-demographic factors, b) in relation to the severity of the child’s clinical picture or social adjustment, and c) in relation to the changes of the child’s clinical picture in the course of its therapy.The study has been based on research material from a multi-center European research on the psychotherapy of children with depression, conducted by Trowell et al. (2007): “Childhood Depression: a place for psychotherapy: An outcome study comparing Individual Psychodynamic Psychotherapy and Family Therapy”. The children and young adolescents of the sample, together with their parents were randomly allocated to two different but equally established forms of psychotherapy: the Systems Integrative Family Therapy (SIFT) and the Focused Individual Psychodynamic Psychotherapy (FIPP), accompanied by Supportive - Counseling Therapy for the parents. The therapies lasted 9-12 months and the sample was re-evaluated after 6 months.In the present study, cross-sectional measurements were carried out of our variables at three phases of therapy (baseline - end of therapy - follow up) and also measurements were carried out of the changes in between. The 5MSS was used for the measurement of maternal EE, while for the rest of the variables, report questionnaires and diagnostic interviews.Results showed that high EE mothers, in comparison with low EE mothers: are of a lower educational level, attribute more severe depressive symptomatology to their children, are in more disagreement with their children’s self-evaluations, and their children -according to the teachers’ views- show more withdrawn/ internalizing behavior (introversion) in the school environment.Our results converge to an understanding of high maternal EE in the context of a disturbed mother-child interaction. Its correlation with an exaggerated evaluation of the child’s problems, imprints on the mother an attitude of bias in relation to her child. In the clinical research, the dimensions of high EE (“criticism”, “hostility”, “emotional over-involvement”), along with other characteristic attitudes that have been described of mothers (intrusiveness, anger, inflexibility, low tolerance and non-acceptance of the illness, causal attributions of the child’s behavior) can explain their less composed and objective attitude, a bias, regarding the severity of their children’s symptoms. Mothers’ educational level, which was found to correlate with their EE, might influence the formulation or transformation of these attitudes. University level studies, which have been correlated with low EE, seem to cultivate in them a composed scientific consideration of the illness and, consequently, a greater acceptance and tolerance of their children’s symptoms.The psychoanalytic approach to relatives’ high EE attitudes, based on the unconscious psychic mechanism of “projective identification”, can also explain the fact that high EE mothers attribute excessive depressive symptomatology to their children. Melanie Klein (1946) described projective identification as an early defense mechanism, which characterizes primary aggressive object relationships. Undesirable (painful, catastrophic, hostile etc) psychic contents are projected in fantasy from the subject (mother) to the object (child), exerting, at the same time, pressure, so that the object identifies with them. In this case, a fusion occurs of the self with the object, which ceases to be psychically independent. According to its definition, projective identification contains qualities of psychic functions comparable with high EE: aggressiveness - hostility, blurriness of limits - fusion - emotional over-involvement). Such psychic functions are also described in the clinical, as well as the theoretical psychological considerations of separation anxiety, at the core of which, a pathological relation of mutual hostile dependence between mother and child is noted. From this point of view, the correlation between high maternal EE and the child’s withdrawal and introversion in the school environment, according to the teachers, can also be explained.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2013
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Χάρη, Αικατερίνη
Subjects
dc:subject × 10Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/41743