National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Μεθοδολογία επιλογής και αξιολόγηση υλικών χρήσης σε σχολικές μονάδες
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis doctoral dissertation aims at: a) developing an original research tool and conducting research on the opinions of school users in regards to the school built environment, sustainable construction and the selection and use in schools of materials that are friendly to the environment and human health, with a focus construction on construction products, and b) developing and applying an original methodology for criteria-based selection and assessment of construction products for use in schools, so that, amongst alternative solutions, the selected solution is that which is most environmentally-friendly, whilst incorporating into the assessment procedure findings from the school research as school users’ input data that expresses their opinions in the decision-making. In Part A΄ of the dissertation, there is a review of research literature on the effect of school facilities on the educational process and the performance and well-being of school users, and on the development of “sustainable schools” and related issues. The development and the administration of the Panhellenic survey of school spaces, materials and environment-comfort conditions in secondary schools and perceptions, stances and attitudes of pupils, teachers, principals and parents towards sustainable construction and the selection and use of materials in schools that are friendly to the environment and human health (Pa.E.S.X.A.K.Y.) is presented. Four original questionnaires were developed, respectively for: pupils, teachers, principals and parents/guardians. The survey was conducted in a representative sample of 170 public day-functioning Lower Secondary Schools (Gymnasia) and General Upper Secondary Schools (Genika Lykeia) and Vocational Upper Secondary Schools (Epaggelmatika Lykeia) obtained through stratified random sampling from each of the 13 Regions of the country. 167 school principals, 342 teachers, 905 pupils and 822 parents participated. SPSS was used for descriptive and inferential statistical analysis, for investigating variables’ independence and for conducting Analysis of Variance and Principal Components Analysis. Part Β΄ of the dissertation concerns the design and application of an original methodology for criteria-based selection and assessment of construction products for use in schools, which combines: a) Comparison of alternative solutions’ Environmental Product Declarations (EPDs) issued according to the same European standard, EN 15804, with Life-Cycle Analysis, b) Utilization of the Analytic Hierarchy Process as the multi-criteria decision-making method and c) Appropriation of Pa.E.S.X.A.K.Y. questions as comparison criteria of EPDs, and use of calculated criteria weights, representing the four user groups’ participation in decision making. With the methodology, the most environmentally-friendly solution is selected, and alternative solutions are ranked. The methodology was applied for stone wool products intended for thermal and sound insulation in: a) an internal wall between two standard school classrooms (assessment of four stone wool insulation products), and b) internal wall between two studios for individual piano or other musical instrument lessons in the context of a Music School (assessment of four stone wool insulation products). For application b), a review and investigation was made of design and functional principles and the influence of acoustical and other parameters of studios on piano and instrumental teaching. Microsoft Excel spreadsheets were used for both applications of the selection methodology and both decisions were investigated. Additionally, weights were calculated for other environmental issues, based on Pa.E.S.X.A.K.Y. results, for use in decision-making. Discussion is carried out of the results of the Pa.E.S.X.A.K.Y. survey as well as the applications of the selection methodology of materials (stone wool products). Through the Pa.E.S.X.A.K.Y. survey, it is primarily ascertained that: the questionnaires functioned very well as research instruments, most results can be generalized for the statistical population and a body of evidence-data on a nation-wide level has been produced regarding the issues under study. All four user groups rate their school and most environmental parameters as being medium or good. With numerous variables, statistically significant differences were found in the opinions between user groups, and in general pupils are more critical of school conditions than the other user groups. It was also ascertained that quite a few parameters are not independent of certain factors regarding users, e.g. sex, but also the facility, e.g. school building age et al. Most school users think that issues regarding sustainable construction of schools and the selection and use in school of materials that are environmentally friendly and human health friendly, are extremely important or very important, as well as that special measures and criteria in this direction should be utilized and that the school community should participate in planning and selecting ‘ecological solutions’ for school facilities. The main conclusions reached, in regards to the material selection methodology developed, are that the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) with the specific five-level hierarchy structure devised, in conjunction with the comparison of the EN 15804-based Environmental Product Declarations (EPD’s) of alternative solutions for stone wool insulating products and the use of Pa.E.S.X.A.K.Y. survey results constitute a methodology that assesses and selects with consistency construction products under comparison. The methodology incorporates users’ opinions for the selection of the most amongst environmentally-friendly stone wool product for thermal and acoustic insulation in internal walls between school classrooms, and resulted in selecting the best solution as well as ranking the other alternative solutions, in regards to the central goal. The methodology’s consistency is ascertained in both applications, in the first of which comparison is made of the environmental performance of the four products as estimated in their EPD’s with Life-Cycle Assessment based on the Production Stage (A1-A2-A3). In the 2nd application, comparison is made of the environmental performance of the two products as estimated in their EPD’s with Life-Cycle Assessment based on the Production Stage (A1-A2-A3) and Module C2 (Transport) and Module C4 (Disposal) of the End-of-Life Stage. Directions are pointed out for further investigation and utilization of the present research findings and conclusions.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2017
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Zepatou, Vasiliki
- Ζεπάτου, Βασιλική
Subjects
dc:subject × 24- περιβαλλοντική ποιότητα σχολείων Δευτεροβάθμιας εκπαίδευσης
- εκπαίδευση και περιβαλλοντικές συνθήκες σχολικού χώρου
- αειφόρος κατασκευή και αειφόρα σχολεία
- έρευνα απόψεων Διευθυντών, εκπαιδευτικών, μαθητών, γονέων
- προϊόντα δομικών κατασκευών και ανάλυση κύκλου ζωής
- μεθοδολογία επιλογής περιβαλλοντικά φιλικών προϊόντων
- Αναλυτική ιεραρχική διαδικασία
- επιλογή πετροβάμβακα εσωτερικού τοίχου σχολικής αίθουσας
- Μουσικά σχολεία
- διδασκαλία πιάνου/μουσικών οργάνων και ακουστική στούντιο
- environmental quality of secondary schools
- education and school environmental conditions
- sustainable construction and sustainable schools
- survey of principals', teachers', pupils', parents' opinions
- building construction products and life-cycle analysis
- selection methodology of environmentally friendly products
- Analytic hierarchy process
- rockwool selection for internal classroom wall
- Music schools
- piano/instrumental teaching and studio acoustics
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη Χημικού Μηχανικού
- Engineering and Technology
- Chemical Engineering
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- BY_NC_ND
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/42599