Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Η παιδαγωγική του οπτικού πολιτισμού και η έννοια της παιδικής ηλικίας: αντιλήψεις περί παιδικής ηλικίας και δεξιότητες ανάλυσης οπτικών αναπαραστάσεων παιδικής ηλικίας μαθητών/τριών Στ΄ Δημοτικού

Abstract

dc:description

Visual Culture Pedagogy (V.C.P.) is an emerging educational paradigm for art education. It seeks to satisfy the new educational needs caused by the changes in contemporary everyday life, in the postmodern art and in the considerations for the explanation of reality and culture (Visual Cultural Studies-postmodernist theory, critical theory). It proposes visual culture’s works (works of high art and of popular culture) to be studied based on concepts such as the concept of childhood. Visual works are considered as visual representations of the social discourses of a society which constitute the content of the concept. Social discourses are thought systems, ideologies that give to the concept specific features, boundaries, commonly accepted truths and practices. Also, they affect the conceptions and attitudes of all society’s members, they are distributed in a variety of ways and are changed over time. The vast range of visual works depicting childhood are visual representations of various social discourses such as inherently innocent child (romantic discourse) or evil (puritan discourse) or competent child and influence students’ thinking and perceptions of the self (individual and collective subjectivity) and the world. To uncover the social discourses underlying the cultural works, it is necessary to critically examine and decode their visual semiosis, that is, knowledge and skills of analysis of visual culture’s works are required. We investigated of sixth-grade primary students (a) their pre-existing conceptions about childhood, (b) their pre-existing skills in the analysis of visual representations of two different social discourses about childhood, particularly towards three levels (descriptive, interpretive, technical) of image analysis and (c) their pre-existing skills in the decoding of a print advertisement concerning three semiotic structures (ideational-representational, interpersonal, multimodal) that constitute the meaning of the advertisement. In particular, we examined their skills for nine visual signs (space, action, age, type and color of clothing / eye contact of represented persons and viewers, distance and angle of the scene / synergy of word and image). An exploratory survey of qualitative orientation was carried out on a sample of one hundred and twelve (112) 6th grade students of five elementary schools in the urban area of the Municipality of Volos, which were selected by a simple random sampling procedure. The data collection tool was an individual questionnaire with twelve open questions (some of which included sub-questions), the individual visual work created by the students and their response to printed photographic material (advertisement and painting) which correspond to visual representations of two different social discourses of childhood (romantic discourse and its oppositional one). We proceeded a qualitative content analysis, and in parallel -for the exploration of students’ perceptions- a critical discourse analysis of the data. For validity and reliability testing, a two-phase pilot research (participating and undeclared) was proceeded. We also conducted data triangulation by multiple methods (verbal, visual), triangulation of data between different questions, and examination of ratings by external evaluators. The conceptual categories induced by the data were quantified and statistically processed using descriptive statistical methods (percentages, median, interquartile range). We found that students' conceptions are characterized by a one-dimensional perspective that corresponds to the predominant social discourse of romantic child (general conclusion). We found that their skills in analyzing both visual representations of the two different social discourses of childhood corresponded to low-performance (i.e. accountive response stage, interpretation in the denotation level) for all three levels of image analysis (overall conclusion). However, regardless of the skill level, the image’s theme seems to have a positive or negative effect on pupils' response depending directly on the positive or negative content of the depicted scene. The effect was either in terms of variety/non-variety of the meaning making (descriptive level of analysis) as to the relevance/non-relevance of the meaning (interpretive level) or the ability to recognize one (or any) visual sign for the communication of meaning (technical level). We found that their media literacy skills concerning the decoding of the signs which realize all three structures of the advertisement’s meaning, corresponded to low level (i.e. sign decoding at denotation level, detection of figurative-narrative rather than symbolic elements, fragmentary use of the slogan’s many concepts and monotropic meaning making). However, their performance, regardless of the skill level, varies according to the structure of advertisement’s realization of meaning. Namely, their performance was better in decoding the ideational-representational codes, as the majority of students referenced to them (overall conclusion) compared to those of the interpersonal ones that they were not referenced (general conclusion). They were also differentiated according to the code. Namely, better performances were observed in decoding the depicted persons’ age and the color of their clothing (the majority decoded them at high level of connotation) compared to the action or the action’s space (decoding at low level of denotation), compared to attire’s style that it was not at all decoded. The above findings were used to offer suggestions for the teaching of the concept of childhood based on the aims of the Visual Culture Pedagogy. With the ultimate goal of empowering students and their active participation in the learning process and in society to, it is proposed the critical examination through the systematic teaching of semiotic analysis of various visual culture’s works that represent different social discourses of childhood. It is proposed as the starting point of the study to be define the romantic discourse compared to other social discourses. Also, the analysis of codes that realize the ideational-representational meaning of the images in relation to those of the interpersonal structure. Finally, to study printed advertisements that their slogan includes a concept concerning the past compared to others that include more (memories, timelessness). Expected learning outcomes are suggested the students’ reconstruction of childhood conceptions (adoption of multiple perspectives) and their skills development in the analysis and decoding of the visual semiosis of the visual representations of the various childhood discourses (i.e. decoding in connotation level, revelation of the social discourses that conceal under images, recognition of the synergy of the different modes that realize the meaning of the advertisements, and the symbolic value given by the semiosis to the product).

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2018

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Fakidou, Anastasia
  • Φακίδου, Αναστασία

Subjects

dc:subject × 30

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/42683

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Fakidou, Anastasia; Φακίδου, Αναστασία. Η παιδαγωγική του οπτικού πολιτισμού και η έννοια της παιδικής ηλικίας: αντιλήψεις περί παιδικής ηλικίας και δεξιότητες ανάλυσης οπτικών αναπαραστάσεων παιδικής ηλικίας μαθητών/τριών Στ΄ Δημοτικού. University of Thessaly (UTH), 2018. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/42683