Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Φυτοαπόσπαση βαρέων μετάλλων από ρυπασμένα εδάφη με ενεργειακά φυτά

Abstract

dc:description

The objective of the PhD thesis was to contribute to the investigation of the possibility of using the bioenergy plants maize (Zea mays), sunflower (Helianthus annuus), sweet sorghum (Shorgum bicolor) and soybean (Glycine max), for the extraction of Pb and Cd pollutants from polluted soils in the region of Lavrio. For this purpose a sample of a topsoil, approximately 1 m3, was taken from the area Neraki of Lavrio and after its homogenization, the concentrations were determined for Pb and Cd, 6990 mg/kg soil and 24 mg/kg soil respectively. The cultivation of the four energy crops took place in a greenhouse, using pots with a capacity of 5 kg and with four retries per studied parameter. Each plant was grown in a soil control (without pollution) in the polluted soil of Lavrio "as is" and in the polluted soil of Lavrio after adding modifiers to assist the extraction of the pollutants. As modifiers were selected commercial products widely used on farms. Specifically, a chelate of iron (EDTA-Fe-13) and a formulation for the adjustment of the pH soil, containing various aminoacids (codasting) were chosen. Three dosages were applied for each modifier, which were selected using the following criteria. For the EDTA-Fe-13 the criterion was for an equimolar amount of the chelate reagent with the amount of Pb to be added, as well as in an excess of 15% and 30%. Consequently, since the concentration of Pb in the soil corresponding to 33 mmol/kg, the additions of EDTA were adjusted to 33, 38 and 43 mmol/kg. In determining the dosage of codasting, preliminary tests were made to determine the amounts required to reduce the pHfrom the initial value of 7.9 to 6.5, 6.2 and 6.0 respectively. These quantities were 14.4, 15.0 and 15.6 ml codasting per kg soil.Greenhouse tests included a total of 128 pots (32 per plant). "Traditional" cultivation practices wereapplied with the intended lubrication and the regular watering of plants. Throughout the course of the plants development measuring and recording of the morphological and physiological parameters of the plants were carried out, including the determination of the concentration of chlorophyll, the net photosynthesis and the chlorophyll fluorescence induction. After the completion of the growth of the plants, theharvest, the determination of the produced above soil phytomass and the measuring of the concentrations of Pb and Cd therein were carried out.Main results The processing of the results focused on the following:(a) determination of the production of phytomass and the phytoaccumulation of the two pollutants into the four energy plants with and without modifiers,(b) quantification of the effect of the addition of the modifiers in the produced of the shoot dry weight,(c) determination of the relationship between the measured morphological and physiological parametersand the produced phytomass,(d) comparison of the results of this experimental work with published results and were determinedempirical equations that relate the phtoextraction with the levels of the pollution,(e) evaluation of the efficiency of the plants for the possibility of reducing soil contamination levels,(f) evaluation of the potential for the use of the plants as energy crops, given the weakness of other farms. The following paragraphs summarize the main results.Corn showed the best performance in all parameters, either by adding or without adding modifiers.The sunflower, after the sweet sorghum and soybean followed in that sequence (Figure 1). Specifically:(a) The amount of above soil phytomass per plant was equivalent to 603-790 g in corn, 499-693 g insunflower, 401-592 g in sweet sorghum and 302-494 g in soyabean.(b) The Pb concentrations in plant tissues of four plants ranging from 900 to 1050 mg/kg in corn, 750 to 930 mg/kg in sunflower, 560 to 730 mg/kg in sweet sorghum and 410 to 590 mg/kg in soybean.The corresponding range for Cd is 3.0-3.6 mg/kg in corn, 2.5-3.0 mg/kg in sunflower, 1.9-3.0 mg/kg in sweet sorghum and 1.3-1.7 mg/kg in soybean.(c) The extraction of Pb from the soil with the corn reached in the range of 124-134 mg/kg soil, while the sunflower at 96-100 mg/kg soil, with sweet sorghum at 58-63 mg/kg soil and with the soybean at 37-40 mg/kg soil. Respectively, for the Cd, it was achieved extraction from the soil 0.43-0.45 mg/kg soil with corn, 0.30-0.31 mg/kg soil with sunflower, 0.15-0.19 mg/kg soil with sweet sorghum and 0.10 mg/kg soil with soybean. It is noted that these values of the extraction of pollutants from the soil are referred per plant.As to the effect of the modifiers, it was found that both the addition of EDTA and the addition of codasting increase the phytoaccumulation, i.e. the concentration of the two pollutants, Pb and Cd, in plant tissues. As it was expected, the addition of chelating agent to the soil, and the reduction of the soil pH, increased the phyto availability both pollutants and facilitate their extraction by the plants. It was observed, indeed, that the phytoaccumulation was higher using codasting than using EDTA.For example, in the case of the corn, the Pb concentration in tissues was 901 mg/kg in the soil of Lavrio, without modifier, 958-996 mg kg in the tests by adding EDTA and 1017-1056 mg/kg in the tests by adding codasting.And in the four plants it was found that increasing the concentration of Pb in plant tissues accompanied by a reduction of the produced phytomass. A particularly interesting finding of the study was that there is a strong linear correlation between the phytoaccumulation of Pb and the reduction of phytomass.Based on this linear relationship, it was estimated that there is a limit value of the concentration of Pb in plant tissues, above which there is a considerable reduction of the produced phytomass (Figure 2).It was determined that the limit concentration of Pb in shoot dry weight is 327 mg/kg in corn, 222 mg/kg in sunflower, 103 mg/kg in sweet sorghum and 3.3 mg/kg in soybean. It seems that the corn, the sunflower and the sweet sorghum are relatively resistant to the phytoaccumulation of Pb, while in soyabean the extraction of Pb, even in small concentrations, is associated with the decrease of the phytomass. Apart from the reduction of the produced phytomass, the toxicity due to the increased extraction of pollutants, mainly of Pb, appeared in all the morphological and physiological parameters of the plants.Significant linear correlation was observed between the phytomass and the price of the physiological parameters that were measured and specifically the chlorophyll concentrations in top leaves or base and the net photosynthesis. Greenhouse tests showed that the extraction of Pb and Cd from the soil per plant is higher in the case of the corn, followed from the sunflower, the sweet sorghum and the soybean in that order. However, in field conditions the efficiency of the plants will vary, primarily due to the different density of plants per acre. Due to the high density of the soybean plants, which amounts to 30000 plants per acre, compared with 8000, 6000 and 10000 plants for corn, sunflower and sweet sorghum respectively, calculated that the cultivation of soyabean can remove higher amounts of pollutants per acre. Specifically, with the soyabean it was estimated that about 6.1 kg Pb per acre can be extracted annually, while with the corn it was 57 kg, 3.1 kg with the sunflower and 3.3 kg with the sweet sorghum. The corresponding amounts for Cd is 20 g with the soybean and the corn and about 10 g per acre with the sunflower and the sweet sorghum This extraction rate of Pb and Cd was calculated by the phytoaccumulation of pollutants from the soil sample of Lavrio, which contains Pb 6990 mg/kg soil and Cd 24 mg/kg soil. In order for the levels of phytoaccumulation at lower concentrations to be assessed, it was undertaken a thorough literature review and from the entire data were identified empirical correlation equations of soil contamination with phytoaccumulation of Pb and Cd. Illustrative diagrams, which shows the correlation of concentrations of Pb in soil with the corresponding concentration of Pb in shoot dry weight of corn from the available data is given in Figure 3. Based on these equations, the time required in order to reduce the concentrations of Pb and Cd below the environmental limits of 500 mg/kg soil and 3 mg/kg soil respectively was determined (Figure 4). The times that were calculated were too high, from 800 up to 36000 years, which suggests that this technology is not realistic as a method of decontamination, at least in cases of high levels of pollution in specific elements. Although the phytoextraction doesn't not constitute an effective technology of remediation ofcontaminated soils, the cultivation of energy plants in contaminated soils is a selection of possibleexploitation of these specific soils, since every other farm for producing edible products is excludedbecause of this pollution. These plants are used either for the production of bioethanol (the grains of corn and the stems of the sweet sorghum) or for the production of biodiesel (the seeds of sunflower and the soybean). From the results of the PhD thesis it was determined that the expected yield per hectare in usable parts of plants, seeds and stems, depends on pollution levels. Then, based on published cost data, a preliminary assessment of the potential of economic efficiency of specific energy crops was attempted.These calculations showed that the cultivation of corn and of sweet sorghum for bioethanol production is economically inefficient regardless of Pb levels in the soil (Figure 5). The cultivation of sunflower can yield profit in the territories in which the concentration of Pb is less than 6600 mg/kg soil, when there isn't rent for the land, while when rent is paid the concentrations of the pollutants, which "determines" the marginal effective soil productivity, is 3600 mg/kg soil. The most profitable cultivation is that of soyabean which can used for the production of biodiesel. The marginal levels of pollution which constitute the cultivation of soyabean non profitable correspond to 9300 mg/kg without rent for the land and 6500 mg/kg when rent is applied. The most profitable crop is that of soybean, which can be used for the production of biodiesel. Threshold levels of pollution that makes this cultivation as uneconomic corresponding to 9300 mg/kg without therent of land and 6500 mg/kg with the rent of land. Of course, to draw firm conclusions, some crucial limiting factors should be taken into account:a) The development of a similar farming requires the installation and the proper operation of a biodiesel production unit, which is adapted to the characteristics of the plant species, which will be located at a relatively short distance from the growing location.b) It should be investigated to what exact percentage are pollutants transferred to the corresponding vegetable oils and then to the produced biodiesel, through the production process. It is likely that additional processing steps are required in order for the pollutants to be removed from the biofuel, up to the prices that are imposed by the environmental standards.c) Appropriate management of the solid residue of the crop, e.g. burning, with the possibility of recovery of heat content and the disposal of ashes, are additional processing steps and costs, which are not evaluated in the case of energy crops in non-polluted soils

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2015

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Kappatos, Napoleon
  • Καππάτος, Ναπολέων

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • BY
Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/42714

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Kappatos, Napoleon; Καππάτος, Ναπολέων. Φυτοαπόσπαση βαρέων μετάλλων από ρυπασμένα εδάφη με ενεργειακά φυτά. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2015. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/42714