Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
Design of electronic services employing gamification: the impact of game elements on user behaviour and motivation
Abstract
dc:descriptionGamification of electronic services has received over the past decade increased attention by both the industry and academia and various industries have introduced it in their offering as a medium to enhance their core offering with playful affordances. In the gamification phenomenon, different game elements, such as points, badges, leaderboards and other elements traditionally found in electronic games are infused in electronic services, that were not games themselves, as means to enable a playful interaction with the end-users. Examples of gamified electronic services can be found in education, health, employee productivity and sustainability, among others, with various goals pertaining to motivating users to engage with the service, adopt new behaviours and learn whilst playing. Previous research on gamification, stemming mainly from digital media, marketing and IS, aims to demystify the phenomenon and understand the effect of introducing game elements in different non-game contexts. However, most researchers examine fully fledged gamification designs leading to incomparable results and insights that remain confined in the non-game context or even to the examined gamified service. As the gamification research matures, the need for isolated and combined examination of different game elements has been identified by several researchers in the field, as well as the need to examine the effect of different game elements on the goals of gamification. Furthermore, as gamification is evangelized as a medium that motivates people to conduct activities and tasks in a playful manner, research is sought after the underlying psychological mechanisms that are involved in the process. This doctoral research is focused on examining the isolated and combined effect of game elements on psychological and behavioural outcomes. The doctoral thesis is based on two initial exploratory qualitative studies and two explanatory quantitative studies. Following the review and examination of the current state of gamification in the pertinent literature and motivated by the results of two different cases of gamification of electronic services, the design of a gamified electronic service in the non-game context of environmental awareness and consumption is utilized to identify the potential of game elements to affect the outcomes of gamification. Firstly, the initial exploratory qualitative studies aimed to identify the game elements that presented potential to be introduced in the gamified services as well as the game elements that presented ambiguous results and needed further research in the process of designing the gamified service. The outcome of the initial studies, consisting of a set of interviews and two focus groups, was that game elements were identified alongside with the potential content of the gamified service to be further examined. The first empirical experimental study is based on a laboratory experiment where 118 end-users experienced interactive mockups of the to-be gamified service, holding a set of identified game elements and the goal was to examine the effect of the game elements in the perceptions of enjoyment and intrinsic motivation to engage with the gamified service. Motivated by the results of this study, the second empirical experimental study, following the development of the gamified electronic service, utilized the smartphone application named POOLL in a field experiment to examine the effect of game elements in a real setting. With the participation of 153 end-users the field experiment had the purpose to investigate the direct effect of game elements on behavioural and psychological outcomes during participation, by taking into account the mediating effect of Perceived Competence as found in the Self Determination Theory. Based on the multidisciplinary nature of gamification, results of this doctoral research contribute to the literature and practice in several ways. Initially, it explores the individual effects of game elements and presents that besides the individual effects, combined game elements effect differently the psychological and behavioural outcomes of the gamified electronic service. Secondly it proposes the examination of gamification under the lens of Self Determination Theory, a prominent motivation theory for gamification. Furthermore, through the introduction of lead users in the design process, it proposes a new method for designing a gamified electronic service targeted to end-users. Fourthly, the results of this doctoral thesis enable managers to have an informed decision both on a set of game elements as well as on the process to examine additional game elements for introduction in their gamified electronic service. Lastly, as the gamified electronic service developed is designed to support gamification experimentation, irrelevant to the non-game context selected, this can be utilized by academics and managers as a tool for the experimentation towards the development of their respective gamified electronic services.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
- Year dc:date
- 2017
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Lounis, Stavros
- Λουνής, Σταύρος
Subjects
dc:subject × 8Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- BY_NC
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/42783