National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Ηθικά δικαιώματα, οριακές καταστάσεις και σύγχρονες ηθικές θεωρήσεις
Abstract
dc:descriptionMy doctoral dissertation is in the field of Applied Ethics, and in particular in the domain of Bioethics, which is unquestionably by far the most up-to-the-minute philosophical branch. Nonetheless, I am confident that to address in detail major bioethical dilemmas, my first task would consist in briefly examining the history of the concept of ‘right’, emphasising on some crucial moments of that history. Thus, I am trying to unravel the major stoic contribution to the establishment of human rights, to mention the severe differences between two important and opposed traditions (to wit natural law and legal positivism), as well as to describe the tight connection between human rights and human dignity, since dignity is presented as the justificatory basis for human rights. After that, in the second chapter I shed light on the widely discussed ‘right to self-ownership’, which if related to bioethical issues, such as abortion and the ethics of paid organ transplantation, may lead to morally controversial conclusions. Also, in the same chapter I briefly comment on John Rawls’ implicit approval of genetic engineering as a means of smoothing the genetic inequality, which appears in his emblematic Theory of Justice. Next, in the third chapter my research questions the adequacy of the conceptual framework of the current bioethical debates, since both classical and new-emerging bioethical dilemmas seem radically different from the traditional philosophical problems humanity has tackled till now. For this reason, I am trying to enrich our terminology with the notion of marginal situations, describing its core characteristics and putting at the forefront of attention the many meanings that can be simultaneously attributed to what is called ‘margin’.Of course, the effort for originality presupposes deep acquaintance with tradition. For many, autonomy is synonymous to bioethics, since this overarching principle is invoked in every single bioethical debate. In the fourth chapter, I analyse how Mill’s notion of autonomy is at war with Kant’s demand that the principle of our will be universalizable. On the other hand, my analysis includes medical approaches to autonomy, which emphasise on the tension between quality and quantity of life, since many patients explicitly rank dignity higher than mere extension of life. In the next two chapters I critically discuss the liberal bioethical view of Ronald Dworkin in comparison with the more conservative one of Tristram Engelhardt Jr. My goal is to give prominence to the fact that all crucial bioethical dilemmas are contingent on our worldviews; namely with our deeply held convictions about the origin and the meaning of life, the existence of God etc. This remark is not to be overlooked, since it can be helpful in regulating the disputes in the public sphere. Last but not least, in the seventh chapter I turn my attention to specific bioethical dilemmas that have already provoked heated debate. For example, should sex selection be allowed or not? Is it morally accepted to predetermine the character and the talents of our offspring or such a practice diminishes their future autonomy? Based on the views of renowned scholars and philosophers, I am trying to critically present this vast region of hard questions, hoping that the philosophical examination may offer the necessary context for independent and responsible meditation.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2017
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Chorianopoulou, Maria
- Χωριανοπούλου, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/42798