National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Δημόσιος χαρακτήρας του δικαίου των παιδιών χωρισμένων γονέων: η ανάδυση ενός νέου μοντέλου καθορισμού της δημόσιας αρμοδιότητας επί προβληματικών οικογενειακών υποθέσεων, όπως κατοπτρίζεται στο παράδειγμα του ευρωπαϊκού εποπτικού μηχανισμού του Στρασβούργου
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis work is divided in two parts. In the first part it is introduced a three-fold methodology for the analysis of the legal system. This methodology includes an approach to the legal system under three angles: (1) The first of them is based on Thomas Kuhn’s theory on the “structure of scientific revolutions” (first edition: 1962). This methodology, when it is transferred from the field of “positive sciences”, where Kuhn first developed it, to the legal science, corresponds to a “behaviouristic” model for analyzing the legal system. Under this aspect, the legal system is considered a legal Paradigm, and its analysis is typified through a “protocol”. An analysis of the legal Paradigm is labeled “Paradigm analysis”. Paradigm analysis corresponds to a “descriptive” approach of the legal system. (2) The second of them is based on the distinction promoted by Niklas Luhmann between “dogmatic” and “theory”. “Dogmatic” is the elaboration of the items of a system of sentences, which produces new sentences which postulate validity within the same system. On the contrary, “theory” is analyzing the system from an external point of view. By virtue of its dogmatic, a legal system is organized to a “legal dogma”. Dogmatic analysis, being itself a “theory”, corresponds to a “hermeneytic” (interpretative) approach to the legal system. Legal Paradigm and legal dogma are correlated to each other through a “postulate of correspondence”, i.e. through the hypothesis that a certain legal dogma displays a certain Paradigm behaviour and vice-versa. (3) The third analysis views the legal dogma as a part of a wider system, which is the “administrative system”. The “administrative system”, in its turn, is typified as an “administrative dogma” or, correspondingly, as an “administrative Paradigm”. Administrative analysis is also typified through a respective “protocol”. Administrative analysis corresponds to a “normative” approach to the legal system. The legal system is correlated to its corresponding administrative system, being a “projection” of the latter to a “field of legal notions”. Thoughout the first part, each method of approach introduced is followed by applications in the evolution of the Greek family law system. In the frame of Paradigm analysis, three family Paradigms are been discerned: the “traditional”, the “libertarian / individualistic” and the “emerging” ones. Each one of these three family Paradigms is been considered as a legal system, and is subject to three analyses: a Paradigm, a dogmatic and an administrative one. In this way, the 1rst part of this work includes 3X3=9 analyses, which illustrate fully the methodology witch is introduced in this same part. The second part deals with the European Court of Human Rights, viewed as a system of European control of the observance of a series of human rights by the State-members of the Council of Europe. This subject-matter is also developed in three chapters. In the first of them, a “General Part” of the whole mechanism of the Strasburg control mechanism is deployed, following the guidelines of the protocol of a “dogmatic”, which have been typified in the first part. In the second of them, it is analytically observed the historic process of forming a brand-new “right to family life” which, as a right of supra-legislative order, is equally applied in cases of public care and of family disputes. In the third of them, the whole system of the European Court of Human Rights is subject to a Paradigm, a dogmatic (as a "theory") and an adimistrative analysis. As a general conclusion from the analyses of this work a tendency is established of the judicial function to be turned to an “administration” of ist subject-matter unde judicial mantle. In the case of the family law, a judicial-like administration of the divorced family is at stake. In the case of the control mechanisms of Strasburg, it is the uniform observance of a standard of human rights within the European legal area. In this work, the need is stressed for the enshrining of the legislative and the judicial functions, not as “empiric”, but with a well-clarified “formal” element, which – and only which – may re-introduce the meaning of “justice” in a field in which the latter risks to be substituted by notions of expedience.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2016
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Demertzis, Konstantinos
- Δεμερτζής, Κωνσταντίνος
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Μεθοδολογία του δικαίου
- Αλλαγή νομικού Παραδείγματος
- νομικό δόγμα
- θεωρία της διοίκησης στα νομικά
- Οικογενειακό δίκαιο
- Ευρωπαϊκό Δικαστήριο των Δικαιωμάτων του Ανθρώπου
- δικαίωμα στην οικογενειακή ζωή
- Law methodology
- legal Paradigm shift
- legal dogma
- a theory of administration in law
- Family law
- European convention on human rights
- family life: right to
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Νομική Επιστήμη
- Social Sciences
- Law
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/42823