National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Σχεδιασμός πρότυπου διαμεσολαβητή εποπτείας και διαχείρισης ηλεκτρικού δικτύου με την προσέγγιση της μηχανικής γνωσιακών συστημάτων
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe subject of the doctoral thesis is the analysis, design, and evaluation of a Prototype Interface for electric network supervision and control, with Cognitive Systems Engineering (CSE) approach, and more specifically with Ecological Interface Design philosophy. At a theoretical level, the doctoral thesis aimed at generating knowledge about the suitability and effectiveness of ecological design in a domain that has not been tested before. It also aimed at enhancing knowledge on how to integrate in the interface design process, the technological and organizational changes that are in progress in the work system, through the CSE approach. On a practical level, the doctoral thesis aimed at designing an ecological interface that will effectively support operators’ cognitive work, especially during critical operational conditions (e.g. high energy demand periods, timeframes before and after a blackout event) when industrial interfaces designed with conventional approaches, exhibit inefficiencies.First, the theoretical and methodological background of the doctoral thesis is presented, i.e. Cognitive Systems Engineering and Ecological Interface Design Approach. Selected cases of major disturbances in electric networks, along with the incorrect actions performed during their management and restoration, are discussed. Furthermore, major technological and organizational changes that are in progress in contemporary networks, are presented.Operation and restoration of electric networks in a deregulated environment, demands more active control at distribution level, and suitable design of Distribution Management Systems. The interfaces of those systems are cognitive artifacts that must suitably support complex cognitive activities of operators. The doctoral thesis focused on the development of an ecological interface for a medium voltage distribution network, through an integral cognitive engineering cycle that involves Ethnographic Analysis, Cognitive Work Analysis, Prototypes Design, and Analytical Evaluation. Ethnographic Analysis was performed in order to study: the workers’ cognitive and cooperative work in the context of routine and critical operational conditions, the distributed cognitive system, the work practices during familiar and unfamiliar situations, as well as the interventions performed by the operators on traditional artifacts (Mimic Diagram, Transformer Diagram, Control Panel, Control Desk, etc) and procedures, in order to better support their work. Furthermore, the assimilation of former technological and organizational changes was examined.Cognitive Work Analysis was performed in order to define the requirements for operators’ cognitive support, and explore the consequences of the implemented technological and organizational changes. First a primary “Abstraction Hierarchy model” of the technological system was developed. Then, multiple “Abstraction –Decomposition Models” (Model of energy stakeholders, Model of operational subsectors, Model of cooperating control rooms, Model of operator-external crew cooperation, Model of transformer structure, Model of supervisory control systems) were developed, mapping out different views and aspects of work system operation and structure that determine activity in the domain. Context-aware Activity Analysis followed, based on real incidents analysis on suitably selected Models, in the light of four work parameters (control tasks, strategies, social organization of cooperation, individual factors). Integration of detailed requirements defined by the four analysis stages, produced design specifications for operators support under critical operational conditions which are cognitively more demanding.Prototypes Design, started with existing prototypes, proceeded with paper prototypes, and completed with electronic prototypes, while exploring the impact of alternative design solutions on operators cognitive and cooperative work. The requirements and specifications were “translated” to specific design solutions (“Semantic Mapping” process) through an appropriate coupling of ecological design principles with other principles, techniques, and templates.Analytical Evaluation of the final prototype of “PIGMENTUM” ecological interface was done with the “Skills-, Rules-, and Knowledge-based taxonomy” of cognitive behavior, in order to illustrate the way in which operators’ cognitive work is supported for all three levels of cognitive behavior, as well as for the shifts between them, under critical operational conditions of the network. The contribution of the doctoral thesis is summarized in the following points. The selection, adaptation, and combinatorial application of methodological frameworks, tools, and techniques, enriches CSE with elements appropriate for its use in designing interventions on large-scale systems that are subject to constant change. The developed prototype System of Symbols, Relational Geometric Representation Forms, Aggregate Representation Structures, Views, and Windows of “PIGMENTUM” interface, can act as a model when designing interfaces for electric networks and other critical infrastructures that are governed by similar control principles. Finally, the results of the individual stages of analysis and design can be used in the future to apply Integrated Systems Design (i.e. design with a unified philosophy all the elements of the control environment: decision support systems, automation, alarms, training programs, etc.) in order to maximize the impact of ecological interface design.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2018
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Drivalou, Sotiria
- Δριβάλου, Σωτηρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 31- Εργονομία
- Μηχανική γνωσιακών συστημάτων
- Οικολογικός σχεδιασμός διαμεσολαβητών
- Εθνογραφική ανάλυση
- Ανάλυση νοητικής εργασίας
- Συμμετοχικός σχεδιασμός και ανάπτυξη πρωτοτύπων
- Αναλυτική αξιολόγηση νοητικής υποστήριξης
- Ηλεκτρικά δίκτυα
- Συστήματα διαχείρισης ενέργειας
- Τεχνολογικές και οργανωτικές αλλαγές
- Διαταραχές λειτουργίας
- Ergonomics
- Cognitive systems engineering
- Ecological interface design
- Ethnographic analysis
- Cognitive work analysis
- Participatory design and prototyping
- Semantic mapping
- Analytical evaluation of cognitive support
- Abstraction–decomposition hierarchy
- Skills-, rules-, and knowledge- based taxonomy
- Electric networks
- Energy management systems
- Technological and organizational changes
- Disturbances and blackouts
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη Ηλεκτρολόγου Μηχανικού, Ηλεκτρονικού Μηχανικού, Μηχανικού Η/Υ
- Επιστήμη Μηχανολόγου Μηχανικού
- Engineering and Technology
- Electrical Engineering, Electronic Engineering, Information Engineering
- Mechanical Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/42991