Back to search

Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)

Design and impact assessment of green information systems: the case of energy and carbon management systems in the supply chain

Abstract

dc:description

Firms in several industries nowadays implement various practices in order to develop more environmentally sustainable supply chains, under the pressure of stricter regulatory requirements, energy costs’ inflation, increasing requests of supply chain partners and mounting environmental awareness of consumers (Abbasi &Nilsson, 2012; Ashby et al., 2012; Sarkis et al., 2012; Srivastava, 2007). In this context, measuring and managing environmental impacts and, more specifically, the energy consumption and carbon emissions at the different stages of a supply chain, has been recognised as a main issue in the development of sustainable supply chains (Hervani et al., 2005; Lee, 2012; Seuring & Müller, 2008; Seuring & Gold, 2013; Veleva et al., 2003). Despite the fact that organizations have made continuous advances towards energy and carbon management, the benefits have not been fully exploited yet. The lack of standardized environmental performance measures that incorporate both environmental and non-environmental aspects, the absence of systems that gather non-traditional information relating to supply chain performance and the integration of these different types of information have been recognized as the most prevalent factors that lead to the low implementation of energy and carbon management (Hervani et al., 2005).Moreover, the environmental data are either completely absent or merely available at high aggregation levels (Bjorklund et al., 2012; Melville & Whisnant, 2014; Veleva et al., 2003), thus preventing firms from accurately evaluating internal and external performance in environmental terms. While economic and operational data are available in internal systems, various integration issues regarding information technology remain to be tackled before incorporating both environmental and non-environmental aspects (El-Gayar & Fritz, 2006; Lee, 2003). Furthermore, in the realms of supply chain, streamlining the different types of supply chain parties (Hassini et al., 2012) and efficient information sharing and collaboration among supply chain partners must be effectively developed to enable an end-to-end information flow (Banker et al., 2006). The above suggest that the implementation of energy and carbon management in the supply chain is a challenging process and Information Systems (IS) have a strong potential by acting as a tool for managing energy and carbon across the supply chain (Dao et al., 2011; Melville, 2010). Mindful of this potential, a new class of information systems emerges, the Energy and Carbon Management Systems (ECMS) (Melville & Whisnant, 2014, 2014). ECMS is a type of enterprise information systems that "take as inputs various types of environmental data (e.g., electricity and fuel use, furnace combustion, emission factors, employee commuting, and air travel), process that data into usable information, (e.g., megajoules of energy, GHG emissions), and provide enhanced functionality (e.g., automated reporting, managerial dashboards, supply-chain analytics, and workflow management)" (Melville & Whisnant, 2014, 2014). More specifically, these systems should be able to capture energy and carbon-related information from energy-consumption measurement infrastructures, integrate and interoperate with a company's existing enterprise systems (e.g., ERP), interpret and integrate the data received from various sources, and, finally, exchange data with the enterprise systems of supply chain partners. This kind of information systems are being rapidly adopted by firms (Liu & Stallaert, 2010) and represent a growing market that is projected to reach $5.7 billion by 2017 (Melville, 2012; Pike, 2011). Except for supporting energy and carbon management, these systems are expected to impact the enablement of environmental sustainable supply chains by supporting the implementation of sustainable supply chain practices (Seidel et al., 2013) and enhancing environmental-aware decision-making and knowledge creation in terms of environmental impacts within organizations (Butler., 2011; vom Brocke & Seidel, 2012; Seidel et al., 2013; Shrouf & Miragliotta, 2015). Despite the growing interest for this kind of systems, there is little empirical knowledge on phenomena related to them (Melville, 2012), such as factors associated with their adoption, design guidelines or implementation issues that should be tackled (Melville, 2013). The major stream of research focuses on conceptualization and analysis of IS (Malhotra et al., 2013) and further work should be done on the rigorous artefact design, demonstration and evaluation (Malhotra et al., 2013, Melville, 2013; Seidel et al., 2013). Previous studies imply general design principles for environmental reporting and monitoring tools (Hilpert et al, 2014; Seidel, 2013), identify the different implementation challenges that these systems face, such as enterprise system integration and real-time data acquisition, and highlight the importance of integrating information from different sources (El-Gayar & Fritz, 2006). However, these studies remain rather superficial in their design principles, which remain non-explicitly related to contextual implementation settings, such as the level of technological maturity, data availability-acquisition and integration, or even the organizational aspects motivating the use of such tools and not take into account the supply chain context. Going a step further, researchers must not only work on the actual design of these systems but also establish the “in-field” impact, in order to investigate how these systems impact the implementation of environmentally-sustainable supply chains. Motivated by the above, this research aims at advancing the design of energy and carbon management systems in the supply chain and elaborating on the contextual implementation settings that affect their design. Moreover, it presents an effort to investigate the impact of these systems on the implementation of environmentally sustainable supply chains, by measuring energy and carbon emissions, supporting environmental-aware decision-making in the supply chain (Butler, 2011) and sustainable supply chain practices (Seidel et al., 2013). Given the aforementioned research objective and research questions, we adopt the design science paradigm as methodological backbone, as it is a recommended approach for addressing the issues related with the prescription of a new class of information systems such as Energy and Carbon Management Systems. The ‘design-science research methodology process model’ (Peffers et al., 2007) is used, contributing to the development of the ECMS artifact and the systematic formulation of the basic components of ISDT (Gregor & Jones, 2007) based on an incremental approach. More specifically, initially we define the design’s purpose and scope. Then we derive a set of design requirements from justificatory knowledge, which give guidance to the subsequent specification of the design, and we identify the theory’s core constructs. Moreover, we develop a set of testable propositions that inform the evaluation of the proposed design and which we test during the evaluation step. By using as starting point the above, we work closely with four companies in order to design and develop Energy and Carbon Management System artifacts and to inform the theory’s purpose and scope, design requirements, principles of form and function, and core constructs. Subsequently, we demonstrate the two artifacts, concluding with a set of design and implementation principles that inform form and function and components of the design theory. To sum up, the two main outcomes of this thesis include an ECMS artifact and an Information Systems Design Theory for ECMS that prescribes this new class of Information Systems. The artifact generation and the ISDT formulation is based on an incremental and iterative refinement approach that switches between construction phases and evaluation (Markus et al., 2002). More specifically, Demonstration & Evaluation in real-world settings was conducted in two phases, so that the first phase could give feedback to the second round of design and development. During this iterative process, a list of implementation challenges have been identified, imposed by the environmental data availability, the different data granularity levels, the poor data quality, the dependencies and coordination problems due to the need of aligning inputs from multiple partners, the technical integration issues and the absence of automation mechanisms. Evidently, these challenges reveal specific features to be implemented in order to ensure the efficacy of such systems in a real-world context. By following this process, new design and implementation principles have derived from the actual implementation of the artifacts, to inform ISDT components and enhance its validity. In order to investigate the in-field impact of an ECMS, we conducted the demonstration and evaluation phase by employing a field study in four different cases that cover a broad scope of the energy and carbon management, ranging from the supplier of raw materials to the point of sales. Our cases include two representative textile organizations interested in energy-efficiency (a leading textile manufacturer and an international clothing company) and for supply chain issues with two representative fast-moving-consumer-goods (FMCG) organizations interested in sustainability (a retailer and a multinational food manufacturer, global leader in its domain). The final main outcomes of this thesis also include empirical evidence that reveals the impact of ECMS on the enablement of environmentally-sustainable supply chains, through the measurement of energy and carbon emissions, the support of environmental-aware decision-making and the implementation of sustainable supply chain practices.One of the main strengths of this thesis is its interdisciplinary nature, as it interweaves three different disciplines: Information Systems (IS), Operations Management and Environmental Science. Therefore, the contribution of this thesis from a theoretical perspective is found across these three disciplines and focuses on the research streams of IS Design, IS for Sustainability and Energy and Carbon Management. The contributions of this thesis are summarized in the following list: •IS Design: 1.The formulation of an Information Systems Design Theory (ISDT) that prescribes Energy and Carbon Management Systems in the Supply Chain. 2.A set of design and implementation principles that correlate generic energy and carbon management implementation challenges with the design of ECMS, in order to show how these challenges affect the ECMS Design.3.The definition of generic data-models describing the information flows that are required for Energy and Carbon Management.4.A proof-of-concept (two artifacts) for Energy and Carbon Management Systems in the supply chain, that provide insights into how ECMS operate in practice, how they are implemented, and recommendations for their effective implementation and use.5.Providing an exemplar of applying the Design Science research approach in the case of ECMS in the supply chain. 6.Using a more holistic approach that correlates the outcomes of each step of the Design Science approach with the components of the ISDT theory. More specifically, we show how the application of the ‘design-science research methodology process model’ suggested by Peffers et al. (2007) could support the development of the ISDT theory and inform its respective components (Gregor & Jones, 2007). •IS for Sustainability 7.Explore the role of IS on the development of environmental sustainable supply chains by investigating in-depth the emerging class of ECMS and position them in the broader context of information systems addressing sustainability challenges (Green IS research area).8.Provide empirical evidence on how ECMS contribute to the implementation of environmentally sustainable supply chains, by supporting energy and carbon management, environmental-aware decision making and the implementation of environmentally-sustainable supply chain practices.•Energy and Carbon Management9.Frame the Energy and Carbon Management in the supply chain, by identifying a set of various dimensions related to them and the respective Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), information flows and required data.10.Identify important Energy and Carbon Management implementation issues and challenges and provide empirical evidence on how to address them.11.Explore the role of IS on supporting Energy and Carbon Management in the Supply Chain, by presenting how the required energy and carbon management data can be collected, integrated, processed and presented in the form of KPIs by an ECMS.On the other hand, this thesis offers support to software engineers/ developers and vendors and organizations want to implement ECMS aspiring energy and carbon management benefits and more sustainable supply chains. The suggested ECMS design theory and the developed artifact can inform software engineers in their efforts to design IS to be used for energy and carbon management in the supply chain. Furthermore, the suggested conceptual model supports componentization and can improve the reusability and integration of the systems, providing benefits for both software engineers and software vendors. Moreover, the identified implementation issues (e.g. data and technical) and the respective implementation principles could constitute ECMS implementation guidelines and facilitate the implementation process. With the outcomes of this thesis regarding the impact of the ECMS, supply chain managers have empirical evidence on the impact of ECMS that could support their future investment decisions. With the various levels of energy and carbon management identified, the supply chain managers can approach the implementation of ECMS as a gradual process, by implementing the energy and carbon management dimensions that are more aligned with the company maturity, measurable data, available information systems and tools, as well as the expected benefits.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
Year dc:date
2015

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Zampou, Eleni
  • Ζάμπου, Ελένη

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/43092

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Zampou, Eleni; Ζάμπου, Ελένη. Design and impact assessment of green information systems: the case of energy and carbon management systems in the supply chain. Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB), 2015. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/43092