National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Ανάπτυξη διεργασιών σταθεροποίησης της ιπτάμενης τέφρας από μονάδες θερμικής επεξεργασίας αποβλήτων
Abstract
dc:descriptionOne of the main problems arising from the operation of modern waste incineration plants is the management of produced fly ash, which requires high costs and a careful assessment of the methods to be selected due to its high toxicity. Moreover, the very strict limits the European Union (EU) has laid down in recent years for the landfill of waste, make it necessary to treat the fly ash prior to disposal. The present PhD thesis investigates the treatment of fly ash from the incineration of waste in order to limit the release of pollutants and compliance with the boundaries of landfills for non-hazardous waste.Two fly ash samples were studied, one from a municipal solid waste (MSW) incineration plant in France and one from a medical waste (MW) incineration plant in Greece, as there is no MSW incineration plant in our country. Initially, the physicochemical characterization of the fly ash samples was performed and the results were compared with literature data for similar samples. The physicochemical characterization includes measurements of moisture, pH, density, specific surface area, particle size distribution, X-ray fluorescence (XRF) elemental analysis, X-ray diffraction (XRD) mineralogy analysis, thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and scanning electron microscope (SEM) morphology analysis. According to the results, the two ashes are typical samples of each kind, while the comparison between the two ashes revealed significant similarities but also some differences.For ashes classification, the standard leaching test EN 12457/2 was applied in accordance with European legislation. Leachate analysis includes measurements of pH, conductivity, Total Dissolved Solids (TDS), Dissolved Organic Carbon (DOC), ions concentration (Cl-, F- and SO42-) determined by ion chromatography, and metals concentration (As, Ba, Cd, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mo, Ni, Pb, Sb, Se, Zn) determined by Inductively Coupled Plasma Atomic Emission Spectrometry (ICP-AES) and by Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS). The leaching test results for the ash from MSW incineration indicate that the leachate concentration of Pb, TDS, chlorine and sulphate ions exceed the legal limits for non-hazardous waste landfills. For the ash from MW incineration, leachate concentration of Pb, TDS, chlorine and fluoride ions exceed the limits for non-hazardous waste landfills. According to the European Council Decision (2003/33/EC), both ashes are hazardous wastes that have to be disposed of in a hazardous waste landfill or should be properly treated so as not to exceed the limits of the non-hazardous waste landfills.Fly ash treatment was experimentally investigated to highlight a method that would reduce the leachability of pollutants from ash below the limits of non-hazardous waste landfills. To reduce the leachability of Pb, chemical stabilization with phosphates was chosen as a treatment technique, while the water washing technique was chosen to remove the salts. The phosphate stabilization method reduces the leachability of Pb and other metals by a simple technique and without producing a liquid waste. The basic principle is to bind and immobilize pollutants in the residue matrix as phosphate minerals. However, because no water extraction is used, the treated product retains the salts contained in the original residue. The water washing technique is used to remove the soluble salts from the ash. Washing with water is commonly used in conjunction with other methods. An important goal for the method is to use the smallest possible Liquid to Solid (L/S) ratio and the shorter agitation time. Finally, one of the main problems of water washing is the management of the wastewater produced, as not only the readily soluble salts are removed from the residues but also significant amounts of heavy metals.The two treatment techniques were initially studied separately and then combined. The influence of various processing parameters, such as the phosphate and ash ratio, the liquid to solid ratio, the pH, the sequence of the two techniques, and the use of a different phosphate source were investigated experimentally to highlight the optimal method. After the treatment each sample was tested with the EN 12457/2 leaching test and the leachate was analyzed in order to evaluate the efficacy of each treatment method. Additionally, the liquid waste generated by each treatment method was analyzed.According to the results for each technique separately, chemical stabilization with phosphoric acid effectively stabilizes Pb, however the TDS of the leachate still exceed the limit value. In addition, water washing leads to a significant removal of salts, resulting in a 12% reduction in ash weight. When HNO3 is used to adjust the pH during washing, salt removal is even higher, resulting in a 22% reduction in ash weight. The two techniques separately are not sufficient to stabilize the ash in order to comply with the legal limits of the leaching test.Exploring the combination of the two techniques, has led to the design of a method leading to the successful stabilization of the MSW incineration ash and compliance with the legal limits of non-hazardous waste landfills. In this method, chemical stabilization is first carried out with a small amount of water along with 7% phosphoric acid (w/w% of the raw ash) and then, in a second step, washing with the remaining water (a total of 2.5 l/kg). Pb is successfully stabilized so that its concentration in the treated ash is much lower than the legal limit. It is noticed that for the methods tested for the MSW incineration ash, the pH of the leachate shows values from 7.3 to 10.8 and the fact that Pb is successfully stabilized in each case confirms the successful stabilization of Pb over a wide pH range when using phosphoric acid. The concentration of other metals in the leachate also decreases, with the exception of Cr concentration which is increased but is still below the limit value. Additionally, satisfactory removal of the salts from the ash in the liquid waste is achieved, resulting in a TDS leachate concentration of ash after treatment lower than the legal limit. There is no noticeable reduction in the ash weight after treatment, as about 10% of raw ash weight is removed due to salts washing through the liquid waste, while a quantity of phosphoric acid equal to 7% by weight of the raw ash is added. Finally, the liquid waste of the process is the least polluted with heavy metals compared to the other methods examined. It is noted that a very small amount of water was used for the salts washing compared to other studies, with the target of producing as little volume of wastewater as possible.In addition, the use of lime (Ca(OH)2)has been tested in the previously treated MSW fly ash samples. It has been shown not to further improve the treatment methods results examined in the present thesis, but in some cases leads to an increase of the leachate concentration of significantly toxic elements such as Cr, Sb and Se.From the comparison of the leaching results of MSW ash and MW ash, the high leachability of Pb and salts is identified as the main problem for both ashes. Based on this observation and other similarities in physicochemical characteristics between the two residues, the successful method developed for the MSW ash was examined for the treatment of MW ash. The efficiency of the process after minor modifications was also confirmed by the successful stabilization of MW fly ash. The variation of the method requires the same amount of phosphoric acid (7%) and the use of a small additional amount of water (3 l/kg instead of 2.5 l/kg). According to the results, Pb is successfully stabilized, having a leachate concentration much lower than the legal limit, while the concentrations of the rest metals remain low and below the limit values. The concentration of TDS in the leachate is dramatically reduced, so that being below the legal limit for the treated ash. For the treated MW ash a total weight reduction of 10% is observed due to the salts removal through the liquid waste, as about 20% of the weight of the raw ash is removed during the leaching of the salts, while a quantity of phosphoric acid equal to 10 % of the weight of the raw ash is added. According to the results, the method can successfully stabilize the MW fly ash in order to be disposed of in a landfill for non-hazardous waste. The additional use of phosphate during the treatment has been shown to result in the same metal leachability results and does not further improve the quality of the waste liquid produced.The investigation of the treatment methods highlighted the problem of mobilization of toxic metals such as Sb and Se in specific changes in the process conditions. Most literature studies do not include these elements in the measured metals and as a result their problematic leaching behavior is not evaluated. Moreover, the very strict limits the EU has set for these two metals make it necessary to analyze them when assessing a treatment method. According to the results of the present PhD thesis for these metals, it has been shown that washing with water followed by stabilization with phosphoric acid, which is the usual practice in the few studies which examine the combination of the two methods, does not lead to a successful stabilization of fly ash. Instead, in the method that led to successful stabilization, water washing takes place after the chemical stabilization. This is achieved by simply changing the sequence of the two methods and using the appropriate parameters to establish a totally effective treatment method.In summary, this PhD thesis has led to the development of a simple and low-cost treatment technique that achieves the stabilization of both MSW and MW fly ash, complying with the EU's legal limits, and can be a solution to the problem of their safe management.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2018
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Vavva, Chrisanthi
- Βάββα, Χρυσάνθη
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Ιπτάμενη τέφρα
- Καύση
- Αστικά στερεά απόβλητα
- Ιατρικά απόβλητα
- χημική σταθεροποίηση
- Φωσφορικό οξύ
- εκπλυση με νερό
- Fly ash
- incineration
- Municipal solid waste
- medical waste
- chemical stabilization
- Phosphoric acid
- water washing
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη Χημικού Μηχανικού
- Engineering and Technology
- Chemical Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/43133