Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
Business unit slack resources: their relationship with corporate controls, business unit autonomy and managers' attributes
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe dominant role of multibusiness organizations in the global business scene has made multibusiness organizations the focus of increased managerial and academic attention during the last decades. Control and autonomy play a central role in the management of multibusiness organizations. One one hand, through the operation of a control system, which monitors and evaluates the performance of the business units, headquarters attempt to ensure that organization-wide goals and objectives are achieved. On the other hand, through the decentralization of decision-making authority from headquarters to the business units, business unit managers are provided with the autonomy to respond to local needs and undertake entrepreneurial initiatives, which may benefit the organization as a whole. Striking a balance between headquarters’ control and subunit autonomy was and continues to be a major challenge for top managers in multibusiness organizations. Despite the significance of both control and autonomy for the management of multibusiness organizations, our knowledge about the effectiveness of headquarters’ formal control mechanisms in connection with business units’ autonomy is still limited. To provide some insights on this topic, the present doctoral study endeavoures to examine the effectiveness of formal control mechanisms, through their effect on the business unit’s uncommitted slack resources. For corporate managers, the accumulation of uncommitted slack resources may reduce the capital available for transfer within the organization (Mudambi, 1999) and provide business unit managers with resources to engage in self-serving initiatives (Jensen, 1986). Thus, these resources at the level of the business unit should be as low as possible. However, for business unit managers’ uncommitted slack resource may be considered as enabling the business unit’s adaptation, innovation and pursuit of business opportunities. To this end, when exercising their discretion, they will most likely tend to accumulate such resources.Based on the above, the present study aims to provide answers to the following questions:(a)What is the relationship of formal control mechanisms with the business unit’s uncommitted slack resources? In answering this question, two basic types of formal controls are examined: output-based controls and behavior-based controls, which are further distinguished between direct supervision and process controls.(b)What is the relationship of business unit’s autonomy with the business units uncommitted slack resources?Further to the above, in recent years researchers have highlighted the role of social norms and relations as mechanisms, which may supplement (Martinez, & Jarillo, 1989) or substitute (Granovetter, 1985) formal controls in managing subunits. To assess their contribution, the relationships of formal control mechanisms and autonomy with the business unit’s uncommitted slack resources are also examined in the presence of: i) social controls, ii) business unit managers’ inter-organizational social network, and iii) business unit managers' perceptions of being trusted by headquarters. To examine the above relationships, data were collected through a structured questionnaire filled-in during personal interviews with members of the Top Management Team of 151 subsidiaries of foreign and Greek groups of companies located in Greece. The results from analyses, based on Structural Equation Modeling, show in brief that: (1)Behavior-based controls are effective in reducing uncommitted slack resources at the level of the business unit. Furthermore, from the two types of behavior-based controls examined in this study, direct supervision was identified as more effective compared to process controls. The analysis of the data further revealed that both types of behavior-based controls exert their influence indirectly, by constraining the business unit’s decision-making autonomy. (2)The business unit’s decision-making autonomy is positively and significantly related with the business unit’s uncommitted slack resources.(3)Output-based controls have a positive and significant association with the business unit’s uncommitted slack resources. (4)In the presence of social controls, such as the cultivation of a shared vision, direct supervision’s effectiveness is enhanced while the effect of output-based controls on the business unit's uncommitted slack resources turns from positive into negative. (5)The more connected the business unit managers are with the rest of the organization and the more trusted they are by headquarters, direct supervision seems to loose its effectiveness, while at the same time the more impersonal process controls become more effective. Overall these results offer some interesting insights on the effectiveness of formal control mechanisms, the relationship of the business unit’s autonomy with the business unit's uncommitted slack resources and on the role of social controls, business unit managers’ connectedness, and trust by corporate managers.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
- Year dc:date
- 2014
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Chatzopoulou, Erifili-Christina
- Χατζοπούλου, Εριφίλη-Χριστίνα
Subjects
dc:subject × 12Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/43153