National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
The transformation of the transformation problem and why it matters today: insights into the debate on the transformation problem from a methodological perspective
Abstract
dc:descriptionBy following the dialectical principle ‘not definitions, but the genesis of the thing’, this thesis attempts to reconstruct the evolution of the debate on the transformation problem by tracing the main changes in method and central concern that have taken place from its initial formulation to the so-called traditional transformation problem, that is from Marx’s critique of Ricardo’s theory to Bortkiewicz’s ‘correction’ of Marx’s transformation procedure. This way of addressing the matter differs from the one that is commonly found in the dominant economic thought, for which the process to attain a particular result bears no significance, viz. the building of new models upon previous results that are accepted as true without questioning the method through which they were obtained or the character of the problem under examination in relation to the whole. In so doing, the view of the totality is lost while the history of the discussion is seen as a mere scholastic exercise with no real or practical consequence. It is in this context that contradictions in definitions appear as unsurmountable and fatal, as errors committed during the formulation of the theory that demand ‘corrections’. The reconstruction of the discussion permits to recover the totality point of view, within which contradictions in definitions disclose their real nature and meaning. The excursion into the history of the debate is, therefore, not an end-in-itself but the method of identifying the relevant problem so as to identify its solution. The genetic account is, in addition, characteristic of the method to which our main contention refers: we argue that the transformation of the transformation problem has been caused, and therefore can be explained, by the rejection and insufficient understanding of Marx’s materialist dialectic method. In our view, it is a change in the method of studying the economic reality what underlies the main criticisms of Marx’s labour theory of value, as well as the disintegration of political economy—the conversion of political economy into economics—of which the transformation of the transformation problem is an expression. Behind this change in method there is a change in concern: the aim is no longer the elucidation of the real but ‘internal consistency’, a concern that responds to the need of presenting the capitalist economy as a harmonious and everlasting form of social production. Our investigation reveals that the traditional transformation problem, by which both the labour theory of value and the transformation problem are rendered redundant, is in fact a distortion of the initial transformation problem: that with it the labour theory of value is not denied but deserted from the outset. Such distortion is, moreover, not even a problem but a false problem that leaves Marx’s theory of exploitation and competition intact.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2018
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Escobar Melendez, Cecilia Beatriz
- Εσκομπάρ-Μελέντεζ, Σεσίλια-Μπεατρίζ
Subjects
dc:subject × 34- Το πρόβλημα του μετασχηματισμού
- Εργασιακή θεωρία της αξίας
- Εργασιακή αξία
- Τιμή παραγωγής
- Εκμετάλλευση της εργασίας
- καπιταλιστικός ανταγωνισμός
- Γενικό ποσοστό κέρδους
- Ιδιοτιμές και ιδιοδιανύσματα
- Μέθοδος
- Υλιστική διαλεκτική
- Αντινομία
- Καρλ Μαρξ
- Ντέηβιντ Ρικάρντο
- Βλάντισλαβ Μπόρτκιεβιτς
- Νέο-ρικαρντιανή σχολή
- The transformation problem
- Labour theory of value
- Labour-value
- Price of production
- Exploitation of labour
- Capitalist competition
- General rate of profit
- Eigenvalues and eigenvectors
- Method
- Materialist dialectics
- Contradiction
- Karl Marx
- David Ricardo
- Ladislaus Bortkiewicz
- Neo-Ricardian School
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Οικονομικά και Επιχειρήσεις
- Social Sciences
- Economics and Business
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- BY_NC_SA
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/43516